Welch Company
San Francisco, CA


S U M M A R Y


DIARY: September 11, 2001 01:04 PM Tuesday; Rod Welch

Terrorists attack Pentagon and World Trade Center in New York.

1...Summary/Objective
2...First Bombing World Trade Center Enabled Failed Intelligence
3...Intelligence Mistakes Enabled 2nd World Trade Center Attack


..............
Click here to comment!

CONTACTS 

SUBJECTS
Terrorists Attack New York, Pentagon National Security Failed Intelli
Analysis Gap Intelligence Failure Threatens National Security
Intelligence Failure Gap in Analysis Data Information Enabled Terrori
Osama bin Laden Al Qaidi Responsible for Terrorist Attack on 010911
Analysis Human Intelligence Chronic Underfunding, Article Janes Defen
Intelligence Failure National Security Needs Analysis to Avoid Terror
CIA In-Q-Tel Submit Response to Request for Business Plan
National Security Fails When People Rely on Common Sense Rather than
People Pay a Price that is Saved Using SDS to Avoid Meaning Drift fro
Ant Grasshopper Success Sunshine Profits Encourage Bad Management Laz

4912 -
4912 -    ..
4913 - Summary/Objective
4914 -
491401 - Follow up ref SDS 12 WZD8, ref SDS 10 0000.
491402 -
491403 - Gaps in intelligence that weaken national security were exposed today,
491404 - when four (4) planes were hijacked by terrorists, many of whom were
491405 - known to US authorities, but the plot escaped detection because not
491406 - enough analysis is allocated to understand correlations, implications
491407 - and nuance of information collected by technology. ref SDS 0 UP5K  US
491408 - soil suffered the most devastating attack by foreign powers in over
491409 - 200 years, with loss of over 3,000 lives, destruction of the World
491410 - Trade Center in New York, and damage to the Pentagon, estimated to
491411 - cost over $100B to repair, plus disruption of American life and the
491412 - economy.  Some authorities are calling for increased intelligence
491413 - capability.
491414 -
491415 -      [On 011024 Anne Reed with EDS confirms need for analysis to
491416 -      strengthen intelligence. ref SDS 18 I44L
491418 -       ..
491419 -      [On 011025 DOD requests proposals for solutions. ref SDS 19 0001
491421 -       ..
491422 -      [On 011031 economy steepest drop in 10 years impacted by attacks.
491423 -      ref SDS 21 0001
491425 -       ..
491426 -      [On 011102 job losses most in 2 decades. ref SDS 22 0001
491428 -       ..
491429 -      [020118 received notice CIA seeking intelligence support through
491430 -      In-Q-Tel. ref SDS 24 7O3M
491432 -       ..
491433 -      [020125 respond to In-Q-Tel. ref SDS 25 0001
491435 -       ..
491436 -      [On 040414 1443 letter to Ross on duration of Iraq war to contain
491437 -      terrorist attacks on US soil notes price of freedom is eternal
491438 -      vigilence. ref SDS 30 2695
491440 -       ..
491441 -      [On 091014 1537 Anat Berko wrote a book published in 2007,
491442 -      and with the same title "Path to Paradise," and presents
491443 -      motivations of suicide terrorists, and their handlers.
491444 -      ref SDS 32 AK5J
491446 -       ..
491447 -      [On 100903 1532 10 years later World Trade Center has not been
491448 -      re-constructed, but work underway, and controversy over granting
491449 -      permit for building a Muslim Mosque near "Ground Zero."
491450 -      ref SDS 33 NL4H
491452 -       ..
491453 -      [On 110316 1220 letter commending Ross' son Hutch making
491454 -      progress in military service to stand guard because eternal
491455 -      vigilance is the price of freedom, with Middle East
491456 -      exploding into multiple revolutions. ref SDS 35 6N6J
491457 -
491458 -
491460 -  ..
4915 -
4916 -
4917 - Progress
4918 -
491801 - CNN reports terrorists hijacked four (4) US commercial jet airplanes
491802 - today, ref OF 3 01BR, shortly after leaving the East Coast and headed
491803 - for the West Coast.  This ensured the planes had a full load of fuel,
491804 - which made them effective bombs, for the hijackers, who gave up their
491805 - lives to attack the US. ref OF 3 0001
491807 -  ..
491808 - Two planes were flown into the World Trade Center in New York City,
491809 - ref OF 3 6L5J, causing total destruction of the Twin Towers, and
491810 - adjacent buildings. Approximately 6,000 people were killed, including
491811 - many foreign nationals. Most people below the floors that were
491812 - directly hit, were able to escape the building in time to avoid
491813 - injury.
491815 -  ..
491816 - Many New York firefighters and policemen were killed while attempting
491817 - rescue efforts, when the buildings collapsed.
491819 -  ..
491820 - A third plane was flown into the Pentagon in Washington DC, killing
491821 - approximately 200 people. ref OF 3 PPUP
491823 -  ..
491824 - The fourth plane crashed in Pennsylvania, ref OF 3 SR9N, and is
491825 - believed to have been headed for either the White House or the Capital
491826 - building.  It is also believed that passengers learned during calls
491827 - using cell phones after the plane was commandeered that the other
491828 - planes had been used as bombs, and so attacked the hijackers,
491829 - preventing them from succeeding with their objective, yet still losing
491830 - their own lives in the effort.
491832 -  ..
491833 - Responsibility for the attack is attributed to a network of terrorist
491834 - groups principally in the Middle East and North Africa. ref OF 4 RX4I
491835 - Al Qaidi, headed by Osama bin Laden has been singled out as most
491836 - likely having instigated the attack on the US today, ref OF 3 IV9O and
491837 - ref OF 4 BQ5G  This group has terrorist training camps supported by
491838 - the Taleban government of Afghanistan, according to intelligence
491839 - analysis performed after that attack by the Foreign & Commonwealth
491840 - Office (FCO) of the British Government. ref OF 4 RX4I,
491841 -
491842 -      [On 091014 1537 Anat Berko, PhD, and former Lieutenant Colonel in
491843 -      the Israeli Defense Forces, wrote a book published in 2007, and
491844 -      with the same title "Path to Paradise," and presents motivations
491845 -      of suicide terrorists, and their handlers. ref SDS 32 AK5J
491847 -  ..
491848 - The motive for the attack is attributed to political ambitions of
491849 - Osama bin Laden, who is very wealthy and is exiled from Saudi Arabia.
491850 - He reportedly seeks overthrow of the Saudi regime and believes that
491851 - attacking the US can further that cause.  Additionally, Bin Laden
491852 - heads a militant, fundamentalist branch of Islam that seeks to murder
491853 - US citizens and to destroy the US and other western nations because
491854 - western culture is seen as harmful to Islamic culture. ref OF 4 0068
491856 -  ..
491857 - Jihad is a general call to arms of all Islamic peoples for a holy war
491858 - against the US and western culture.
491860 -  ..
491861 - Previously, Muslim terrorists bombed the World Trade Center on 930226,
491862 - causing $500M in damages and less than 20 deaths; and aided by failed
491863 - intelligence and law enforcement.  This prior incident was told in a
491864 - movie produced and broadcast by HBO, reported on 980423 2123,
491865 - ref SDS 9 MV6L  The HBO movie further dramatized difficulty improving
491866 - intelligence to prevent future terrorism on US soil, by showing the
491867 - leader of the first attack who had been caught and imprisioned,
491868 - none-the-less saying that...
491869 -
491870 -              "Next time we'll bring them both down." ref SDS 9 L75L
491872 -  ..
491873 - Today, was the "next time"!!
491875 -  ..
491876 - Wide spread news reports claim that information was on file in various
491877 - US intelligence agencies about many of the 20 or so people who carried
491878 - out the terrorist attack, but nobody had enough time, using approved
491879 - tools that everybody likes, to remember how to find information for
491880 - analysis that links people and activity into patterns revealing intent
491881 - to do harm, i.e., intelligence failed to enable proactive problem
491882 - handling due to lack of tools for finding the right information and
491883 - doing critical analysis, as explained in POIMS. ref OF 1 2300
491884 -
491885 -      [On 050810 new reporting may confirm that information was on file
491886 -      for over a year about Al Qaeda attack group. ref SDS 31 VY5G
491888 -       ..
491889 -      [On 101011 1656 nobody has time to work intelligently too
491890 -      many people having too many problems not enough time to
491891 -      perform audit trail "connect the dots" maintaining well
491892 -      ordered record, foreclosures fraud, mistakes causing
491893 -      economic recovery to stall due to poor management again in
491894 -      financial services. ref SDS 34 G057
491896 -  ..
491897 - Difficulty finding critical details in time to be effective using
491898 - popular information technology (IT) approved for use on the job, was
491899 - reported on 960406. ref SDS 7 4249  On 010420 Jeff Conklin reports
491900 - organizations large and small have only a weak ability to remember and
491901 - learn from the past. ref SDS 14 IE4M  Earlier on 921127 people are
491902 - frustrated that small inconsequential details later explode into major
491903 - problems, because nobody has enough time for analysis to "connect the
491904 - dots" that reveal emerging trends. ref SDS 2 0674
491906 -  ..
491907 - Lack of analysis has, also, been attributed to cost cutting by
491908 - reducing labor expense for skilled analysts, and relying instead on
491909 - technology for gathering information and data, as reported on 980815.
491910 - ref SDS 10 1173
491911 -
491913 -  ..
491914 - First Bombing World Trade Center Enabled Failed Intelligence
491915 -
491916 - Failed intelligence enabled the first terrorist attack on the World
491917 - Trade Center February 26, 1993.  Perpetrators were in custody, but
491918 - were released by mistake.  An informant being paid $500 per week was
491919 - fired for reporting an attack was being planned, because FBI
491920 - management refused to believe the intelligence.  See...
491921 -
491922 -            Freedom Daily
491924 -             ..
491925 -            FBI Blunders and the First World Trade Center Bombing
491926 -            by James Bovard, Posted November 10, 2004
491927 -
491928 -              http://www.fff.org/freedom/fd0408c.asp
491930 -             ..
491931 -            The FBI placed an informant named Emad Salem, a 43-year-old
491932 -            former Egyptian military officer, in the midst of the
491933 -            Muslim protesters [and Salem received $500 a week, plus
491934 -            expenses].  Salem insinuated himself and became the
491935 -            bodyguard for Sheik Abdul Rahman, a radical Muslim cleric.
491937 -             ..
491938 -            In mid 1992, Salem repeatedly warned the FBI that the
491939 -            Muslim group was planning to carry off a catastrophic
491940 -            bombing in New York City. FBI supervisors were convinced he
491941 -            was concocting tall tales and fired him.
491942 -
491943 -
491945 -  ..
491946 - Intelligence Mistakes Enabled 2nd World Trade Center Attack
491947 -
491948 - Many people feel intelligence takes too much discipline to "connect
491949 - the dots" that show patterns of cause and effect, but with the cost
491950 - preliminarily estimated at $20B and loss of 3,000 lives that could pay
491951 - for a lot of effort to invest time for working intelligently.
491952 -
491953 -      [On 010916 report a lot of information never sees light of day,
491954 -      because it is too hard to find anything without SDS, ref SDS 17
491955 -      KA6H, SDS amazing memory mechanism obviously works. ref SDS 16
491956 -      0001
491958 -       ..
491959 -      [On 011024 Anne Reed with EDS confirms need for analysis to
491960 -      strengthen intelligence. ref SDS 18 I44L
491962 -       ..
491963 -      [On 011025 DOD requests proposals for solutions. ref SDS 19 0001
491965 -       ..
491966 -      [On 011029 new realites of new world order somebody must do hard
491967 -      work that connects data and information into useful intelligence.
491968 -      ref SDS 20 HT4J
491970 -       ..
491971 -      [On 011105 Jeff Conklin reports that SDS support for Com Metrics
491972 -      under the POIMS technology specification, ref SDS 23 4S6H, is a
491973 -      step in the right direction to implement management standards for
491974 -      documenting accurate communications, because SDS work product
491975 -      "walks the talk" of organizational memory that enables people to
491976 -      work intelligently. ref SDS 23 6T6O
491978 -       ..
491979 -      [On 020217 DOD program manager explains need to support FAR
491980 -      requirements for documenting work showing accurate communications
491981 -      that save lives, time and money, ref SDS 27 1332; when people
491982 -      cannot point to an accurate record they point fingers in
491983 -      accusation and blame to avoid accountability for mistakes.
491984 -      ref SDS 27 9360  SDS offers a direct solution to make management
491985 -      productive. ref SDS 27 3105
491987 -       ..
491988 -      [On 020504 study shows professional standards for communication
491989 -      practices and requirements on good management specified in FAR,
491990 -      ISO, Health Care, Covey, Drucker, law, contract notice
491991 -      provisions, and 2,000 years of literacy for contemporaneous
491992 -      documentation for alignment and feedback to work intelligently,
491993 -      quickly, and accurately are ignored in government, business,
491994 -      health care, every sector. ref SDS 29 NS6F
491996 -  ..
491997 - Janes Defense Weekly reports reduced resources for analysis linguist
491998 - skills, cultivation of agent networks, and "tradecraft" hampers
491999 - intelligence, lowering national security posture.  Increased emphasis
492000 - on technical intelligence has placed a growing demand on the people
492001 - who must process the vast amounts of resulting data and prioritize it.
492002 - ref OF 3 PPSV
492004 -  ..
492005 - Failure to add intelligence to information conceals meaning and intent
492006 - which enable prevention, further explained on 980815. ref SDS 10 6424
492008 -  ..
492009 - On 010908 success over many years using good management prevents
492010 - attack, and so causes vigilence to wain.  Like the story of the ant
492011 - and the grasshopper, laziness hampers diligence for investing time to
492012 - perform intelligence (see POIMS, ref OF 1 6649), because cursory
492013 - analysis from reacting on impulse to new information in the moment,
492014 - like replying to email, seems fast, easy and cheaper at the time.
492015 - ref SDS 15 YF5O  NWO explains the price of freedom is eternal
492016 - vigilence. ref OF 1 TW4J
492017 -
492018 -      [On 020131 Secretary of Defense, Don Rumsfeld, urges innovation
492019 -      to meet growing demand for intelligence to enable proactive
492020 -      problem handling. ref SDS 26 QF4H
492021 -
492023 -  ..
492024 - On 000227 cultural inertia prevents strengthening intelligence; only
492025 - major disruption enables people to focus on fundamentals. ref SDS 11
492026 - M35K  On 001104 demand for intelligence during peace and prosperity
492027 - becomes latent, as diligence and vigilance wane, ref SDS 13 XT5H, due
492028 - to laziness, cited on 010908. ref SDS 15 YF5O  Challenge of continual
492029 - vigilence was reviewed earlier on 940628 1255. ref SDS 4 0089
492030 -
492031 -      [On 020131 Secretary of Defense, Don Rumsfeld, explained the
492032 -      cause of cultural inertia that slows innovation. ref SDS 26 KW9N
492034 -       ..
492035 -      [On 040414 1443 letter to Ross on duration of Iraq war to contain
492036 -      terrorist attacks on US soil notes price of freedom is eternal
492037 -      vigilence. ref SDS 30 2695
492039 -       ..
492040 -      [On 110316 1220 letter commends Ross' son Hutch making progress
492041 -      in military service to stand guard because eternal vigilance is
492042 -      the price of freedom, with Middle East exploding into multiple
492043 -      revolutions. ref SDS 35 6N6J
492045 -  ..
492046 - Henry Kissinger reports on 940609 that lack of analysis makes daily
492047 - management an "Alice in Wonderland" of bumbling. ref SDS 3 4238
492048 - George Shultz makes a similar point in a speech on 970402. ref SDS 8
492049 - 8502 Robert MacNamera appears to concur in his book "In Retrospect"
492050 - reviewed on 950417. ref SDS 6 5872
492052 -  ..
492053 - Despite widespread warnings, analysis to connect information and data
492054 - into a comprehensible story seemed like "overkill," ref SDS 10 6424,
492055 - similar to reports on 890324. ref SDS 1 LZ5F and on 950204.
492056 - ref SDS 5 5932
492058 -  ..
492059 - Today, widespread reports show people care about survival and safety
492060 - enough to invest in analysis for strengthening intelligence that
492061 - avoids surprise attacks.
492062 -
492063 -     [On 011024 contacted EDS for partnering to support national
492064 -     security intelligence. ref SDS 18 0001
492066 -      ..
492067 -     [On 011025 DOD requests proposals for solutions. ref SDS 19 0001
492069 -      ..
492070 -     [On 011031 economy impacted by attacks. ref SDS 21 0001
492071 -
492072 -
492073 -
492074 -
492075 -
492076 -
492077 -
492078 -
492079 -
492080 -
492081 -
4921 -