THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net


S U M M A R Y


DIARY: April 23, 1998 09:23 PM Thursday; Rod Welch

Path to Paradise HBO movie shows small problems expand into calamity.

1...Summary/Objective
2...Small Mistakes Uncorrected Grow Explode into Catastrophy
........Path to Paradise - The Untold Story of the World Trade Center
........Bombing


..............
Click here to comment!

CONTACTS 

SUBJECTS
Terrorists 1st Bomb World Trade Center New York 930226 Many Small Pr

1103 -
1103 -    ..
1104 - Summary/Objective
1105 -
110501 - Follow up ref SDS 1 0000.
110502 -
110503 -
110504 -
110505 -
110506 -
110508 -  ..
1106 -
1107 -
1108 - Progress
1109 -
110901 - Small Mistakes Uncorrected Grow Explode into Catastrophy
110902 -
110903 - There is a lot of history showing that bumbling ignores notice and
110904 - abandons responsibility, when the cost of correction is very small,
110905 - causing small mistakes to grow into collosal catastrophy.
110907 -  ..
110908 - HBO telepvision production....
110909 -
110910 -        Path to Paradise - The Untold Story of the World Trade Center
110911 -        Bombing
110912 -
110913 -        Released June 14, 1997
110915 -         ..
110916 -        Writer:  Ned Curren
110918 -  ..
110919 - Dramatizes intelligence failed to investigate small, inconsequential
110920 - leads, signals, and warnings enabled Muslim terrorists to attack the
110921 - World Trade Center on February 26, 1993, which took many lives and
110922 - cost over $500M to repair.
110923 -
110924 -            [On 010922 suicide terrorsts highjacked 747-passenger jets
110925 -            and flew them into the World Trade Center causing total
110926 -            destruction of both towers; another plane hit the pentagon,
110927 -            causing over 2,000 dead, and thousands more injured, and
110928 -            more than $200 billion in damages. ref SDS 2 0001
110930 -             ..
110931 -            [On 091014 1537 Anat Berko wrote a book published in 2007,
110932 -            and with the same title "Path to Paradise," and presents
110933 -            motivations of suicide terrorists, and their handlers.
110934 -            ref SDS 3 AK5J
110936 -  ..
110937 - Perpetrators were in custody prior to the attack for immigration
110938 - violations, but were released because jail facilities were
110939 - "overcrowded," and there was concern about infringement of religious
110940 - freedom.
110942 -  ..
110943 - The FBI was paying $500 per week to an informant, Emad Salem, a
110944 - 43-year-old former Egyptian military officer.  Salem had became the
110945 - bodyguard for Sheik Abdul Rahman, a Muslim cleric in New York, who
110946 - planned the attack.  Salem repeatedly warned the FBI that the Muslim
110947 - group planned a catastrophic bombing in New York City.  FBI refused to
110948 - believe an attack was planned, similar to Chief Justice Frankfurter,
110949 - and others, refused to believe early reports during World War II that
110950 - Hitler was systematically exterminating millions of Jews, because the
110951 - prospect of sensless killing was too horrofic to contemplate.  Rather
110952 - than follow lessons learned from WWII, FBI management believed instead
110953 - that the informant exaggerated small, inconsequential matters in order
110954 - to stay on the FBI payroll.  Salem was fired to save $500 per week on
110955 - the "intelligence" budget.
110957 -  ..
110958 - Human biology creates psychological barriars to belief that prevent
110959 - taking action in time to be effective, unless people have already been
110960 - directly exposed to harm, noted by Grove at Intel relating that people
110961 - become innoculated against small problems and warnings that mount up
110962 - silently like "little cat feat," until disaster strikes again,
110963 - reported on 980307 1614. ref SDS 1 1657
110965 -  ..
110966 - American culture strives to rehabilitate criminals with punishments
110967 - that make law abiding conduct appealing in order to enjoy American
110968 - freedoms.  A narrow segment of Islamic extremism objects to aspects of
110969 - American freedoms so strenuou6ly that death is welcome alternative.
110970 - The prospect that enjoying freedom cannot deter a "human bomb" from
110971 - suicide and broad scale carnage against total strangers, and from whom
110972 - no earthly benefit is claimed, cannot easily be accepted as "true" by
110973 - the Western mind shaped by centuries of progress from the benefits of
110974 - freedom, declared on July 4, 1776.
110976 -  ..
110977 - Reviewers give the movie high marks....
110978 -
110979 -    1.  HBO production, amazing actors, superb dialog.
110981 -         ..
110982 -    2.  A muslim entering the US to make the bomb for a terrorist
110983 -        attack on the World Trade Center was detained by immigration
110984 -        officials because of passport irregularities, and for not
110985 -        having a visa.  Questioning revealed suspicious, nervous
110986 -        demeanor, and weak, conflicting explanation of claim to be
110987 -        visiting relatives.  The muslim then requested asylum to escape
110988 -        religious persecution.  The INS agent urged detainment to
110989 -        investigate suspicious entry purposes, and for violating
110990 -        immigration law.  INS management refused detainment to avoid
110991 -        criticism for violating religious freedom, and to avoid
110992 -        "overcrowding" incarceration facilities that violates "human
110993 -        rights."  The INS agent was told, "Jails are full.  You want to
110994 -        take him home?"
110996 -         ..
110997 -    3.  The film shows just how these terrorists jumped through about
110998 -        any and every loophole in the system under the guise of
110999 -        religious freedom.  Bomb-making right in the apartment.
111000 -        Operating right under the nose of the FBI and other law
111001 -        enforcement agencies.  Anti-American propaganda tapes found in
111002 -        an apartment which, truth be told, is not against the law.
111004 -         ..
111005 -    4.  And of course there was the chilling prophetic line at the end:
111006 -        "Next time we'll bring them both down."
111007 -
111008 -            [On 010922 suicide terrorsts highjacked 747-passenger jets
111009 -            and flew them into the World Trade Center causing total
111010 -            destruction of both towers; another plane hit the pentagon,
111011 -            causing over 2,000 dead, and thousands more injured, and
111012 -            more than $200 billion in damages. ref SDS 2 0001
111014 -         ..
111015 -    5.  Absolutely worth watching again and again.
111016 -
111018 -  ..
111019 - The HBO broadcast was criticized for bias...
111020 -
111021 -    1.  HBO Slanders Islam in "Path to Paradise"
111022 -
111023 -        June 12, 1997
111024 -
111025 -              http://www.themodernreligion.com/assault/hbo-ptp.html
111027 -         ..
111028 -    2.  Leaving behind all concerns for social responsibility,
111029 -        producers at HBO are preparing to air the made for stereotyping
111030 -        movie "Path to Paradise".  The air date for this hateful film
111031 -        is currently June 14.  AMC and the Arab-American
111032 -        Anti-Discrimination Committee have made efforts to offer
111033 -        productive suggestions, saying how the producers of "Paradise"
111034 -        could use this film to enhance tolerance.  Unfortunately this
111035 -        effort was to no avail.
111037 -         ..
111038 -    3.  The film begins with footage of terrorists making explosives
111039 -        and firing weapons, while in the sound track we hear a voice
111040 -        spewing hatred accompanied by recitation of the Qur'an. From
111041 -        there "Path" follows the story of the men who perpetrated the
111042 -        World Trade Center bombing. From the opening scene to the
111043 -        final line, "Next time we will bring them both down," a
111044 -        reference to a follow-up attempt to destroy the Trade Center
111045 -        buildings, we are subjected to every anti-Islamic stereotype
111046 -        possible.
111048 -         ..
111049 -    4.  We do not want to question HBO's statement that the film is
111050 -        based on facts derived FBI files and other sources.
111052 -         ..
111053 -    5.  The problem is with the facts that were selected and more
111054 -        importantly with those that were omitted.  In no way does the
111055 -        film attempt to show that these men are not representative of
111056 -        Muslims or the Islamic faith.  In fact it leaves the viewer
111057 -        with ominous impression that "the Muslims are coming".
111059 -         ..
111060 -    6.  This film, and the image of Islam that it presents demands a
111061 -        full and vocal response from the American Muslim community and
111062 -        all those who share a love for religious tolerance.  HBO, and
111063 -        all other film producers, must know that the public finds this
111064 -        kind of irresponsible film making totally unacceptable.
111066 -         ..
111067 -    7.  Action Requested:
111068 -
111069 -        a.  If you receive HBO, cancel your subscription.  Your dignity
111070 -            is more important than a few movies.  Mention "Path to
111071 -            Paradise" as the reason you are pulling your subscription.
111073 -             ..
111074 -        b.  Call or Fax HBO's Consumer Affairs Department.  Firmly, yet
111075 -            politely, tell them you find their casual treatment of such
111076 -            a sensitive matter insulting in the extreme.  They can be
111077 -            called at (212)512-1208.  Faxes should be sent to
111078 -            (212)512-5517.
111080 -             ..
111081 -        c.  Make sure your local Imam has a copy of this fax, ask him
111082 -            to focus this Friday's (June 13) Khutbah on the issue of
111083 -            stereotyping in the film industry and how your community
111084 -            can register a strong protest.
111086 -         ..
111087 -    8.  Talking Points:
111088 -
111089 -        a.  If this film had been about a violent organization such as
111090 -            the Irish Republican Army or Jewish Defense League, would
111091 -            not the producers have made every effort to ensure that
111092 -            they are not representative of mainstream Catholics or
111093 -            Jews?  Surely they would have.
111095 -             ..
111096 -        b.  This film makes no attempt to portray the attitudes of the
111097 -            overwhelming majority of Muslims.
111099 -             ..
111100 -        c.  Our experience after the Oklahoma city bombing, when
111101 -            Muslims were blamed and attacked before any facts were
111102 -            obtained gives us a glimpse of the type of reaction this
111103 -            film can incite.
111104 -
111105 -
111106 -
111107 -
111108 -
111109 -
111110 -
1112 -