THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net


S U M M A R Y


DIARY: September 3, 1998 01:39 PM Thursday; Rod Welch

Received ideas from Morris on explaining "how" for Comm Metrics.

1...Summary/Objective
2...Web Page Should Cite Communication Manager to Explain "How"
3...First, I am enormously encouraged that Morris took time to explain
........I.would die for someone to turn to their assistant, the VP,
........d...Morris does not mention using the Internet to deliver
........Do the CEO, CFO, marketing, engineering... need "intelligence"
....7...What about critical benefits of "intelligence" for...
4...Executives Need Explanation of Business Intelligence
5...Communication Metrics Uniquely Provides Internal Intelligence


..............
Click here to comment!

CONTACTS 
0201 - Chips & Technologies, Inc
020101 - Mr. Morris E. Jones
020102 - Sr. Vice President

SUBJECTS
Evaluation
Demo SDS via Web Site
Intelligence
Communication Metrics

0806 -
0806 -    ..
0807 - Summary/Objective
0808 -
080801 - Follow up ref SDS 20 0000, ref SDS 19 0000.
080802 -
080803 - Morris submitted ref DRT 1 0001 with a good explanation of
080804 - Communication Metrics benefits, ref SDS 0 1650, and shows how to
080805 - introduce the role of the Communication Manager. ref SDS 0 3300
080807 -  ..
080808 - He forms a message on construction contract claims, ref SDS 0 4839,
080809 - and requests my thoughts. ref SDS 0 8190  I develop analysis on need
080810 - for explaining the benefit of better communication. ref SDS 0 5916
080812 -  ..
080813 - Submitted ref DIT 1 0000 linked to this record with my thoughts.  Ask
080814 - for help creating a message that enables managers to grasp the benefit
080815 - of better communication by adding "intelligence" to information. see
080816 - ref SDS 0 5916  In the transmittal Andy Grove is cited on need to
080817 - overcome denial. ref DIT 1 8673
080818 -
080819 -    [On 980903 send copy to Ross Armstrong and ask for his help as
080820 -    well. ref SDS 21 1200]
080822 -     ..
080823 -    [On 980905 called Morris. ref SDS 22 0000]
080824 -
080825 -
080827 -  ..
0809 -
0810 -
0811 - Discussion
0812 -
081201 - Web Page Should Cite Communication Manager to Explain "How"
081202 -
081203 - Follow up ref SDS 20 0865, ref SDS 17 7695.
081204 -
081205 - Received ref DRT 1 0001 from Morris responding to my letter
081206 - yesterday... ref DIP 1 0001 on our telecon, ref SDS 20, and our prior
081207 - consideration on 980813. ref SDS 13 1872
081208 - ..
081209 - My letter asks if changes to the opening of the Communication
081210 - Metrics web page section address Morris' suggestion to add an
081211 - explanation of "how" management improvements are accomplished, as
081212 - developed yesterday. ref SDS 20 4368
081214 -  ..
081215 - Morris does not directly answer this question, but he submits a good
081216 - explanation of Communication Metrics and how it is accomplished by a
081217 - Communication Manager, to replace or supplement the explanation now
081218 - published on the web page.
081219 - ..
081220 - He asks for my thoughts. ref DRT 1 3528
081222 -  ..
081223 - First, I am enormously encouraged that Morris took time to explain
081224 - Communication Metrics.  That is the first step to understanding, short
081225 - of actual use, and only understanding can move the world forward.
081226 -
081227 - It would be helpful for Morris to criticize or otherwise indicate
081228 - having seen the changes to the web site, ref SDS 20 4368, because the
081229 - changes are linked to an explanation of the Communication Manager, see
081230 - ref OF 2 6369, which he suggests adding. ref DRT 1 3300
081232 -  ..
081233 - It is unclear from this silence whether he feels...
081234 -
081235 -    1.  Communication Manager should be mentioned in the main web
081236 -        page rather than in a link to the NWO paper.
081237 -
081238 -    2.  The explanation of the Communication Manager in the NWO paper
081239 -        is inadequate.
081241 -         ..
081242 -    3.  The scope of services, which describe the daily work of the
081243 -        Communication Manager, and the examples which show actual work
081244 -        product, are inadequate.
081246 -  ..
081247 - Analysis of Morris' draft.
081248 -
081249 -    1.  It seems long, unless it is intended as the entire explanation.
081250 -
081251 -    2.  If it is not the entire explanation, then we need to figure out
081252 -        how to integrate it.
081254 -         ..
081255 -    3.  If it is the entire explanation, then...
081256 -
081257 -        a.  How does a Communication Manager accomplish alignment,
081258 -            linkage of cause and effect, and summary?
081259 -
081260 -        b.  Why is analysis, alignment and summary prepared by a
081261 -            Communication Manager any better than if prepared by an
081262 -            executive using Word or other methods?
081264 -             ..
081265 -        c.  What about technology:  POIMS, Internet as the "how" since
081266 -            our mission statement describes using the Internet, per the
081267 -            work on 980628. ref SDS 8 7425
081268 -        ..
081269 -    4.  What are "best known" methods of information management
081270 -        used by Communication Metrics, ref DRT 1 5112, and how are they
081271 -        used differently or to greater advantage than existing work
081272 -        practices by executives and managers using email, Lotus Notes
081273 -        and other tools?
081274 -
081275 -        ...i.e., why do we need another guy?
081276 -        ..
081277 -    5.  "Intelligence" by inference is defined as...
081278 -
081279 -           "... a chronology of events, ...event linkage, history, and
081280 -           analysis. ...sumarized, and aligned with business
081281 -           objectives." ref DRT 1 3300
081283 -         ..
081284 -        This reflects POIMS definition on 980808. ref SDS 10 0615
081286 -         ..
081287 -        On 911123 Morris defined SDS. ref SDS 2 0477]
081288 -
081289 -           [On 991010 would like Morris to maintain alignment of Com
081290 -           Metrics applied to solving problem of crash on Mars of the
081291 -           NASA space probe. ref SDS 23 1560]
081292 -
081293 -           [On 991014 Morris says SDS helps discipline to use good work
081294 -           principles managers already know. ref SDS 24 2066]
081295 -         ..
081296 -        I would die for someone to turn to their assistant, the VP,
081297 -        Director, or Manager of this, that or other and say in response
081298 -        to Morris' expression...
081299 -
081300 -           "Well, Fred what do you think?  I would love to get our work
081301 -           aligned with objectives, as Morris points out.  Do we have
081302 -           anyone working on this?
081304 -            ..
081305 -           Does Communication Metrics increase the power of the
081306 -           alphabet for capturing information and converting it into
081307 -           useful knowledge for effective management?
081309 -            ..
081310 -           What it would it take to try Communication Metrics to see if
081311 -           an intelligence role can help us"?
081313 -         ..
081314 -        I am particularly heartened by Morris' expression that...
081315 -
081316 -           The process of constant analysis and alignement with
081317 -           business goals allows management to spot problems early, and
081318 -           take corrective action before a crisis. ref DRT 1 3300
081320 -         ..
081321 -        It reflects his explanation of SDS on 911123. ref SDS 2 0477
081322 -        and more recently discussions on 980405. ref SDS 7 2532
081324 -         ..
081325 -        How though does he deal with fear of accountability that
081326 -        eschews analysis and alignment because it shows problems at a
081327 -        time when accountability is more evident, rather than ignoring
081328 -        them until the cause is forgotten, per analysis on 980405. see,
081329 -        ref SDS 6 5065, which was discussed with Morris. ref SDS 7 1087
081331 -         ..
081332 -        Even though "accountability" is endemic to management, reviewed
081333 -        on 970829, ref SDS 3 4920, strong leadership is needed to help
081334 -        people overcome fear and denial in order to discover that good
081335 -        management brings credit for success rather than accountability
081336 -        for mistakes. as developed on 980405. ref SDS 6 1491
081337 -
081338 -        a.  My feeling, from the report on 980813, ref SDS 13 2204, is
081339 -            that "intelligence" should be defined as a process to ...
081341 -              ..
081342 -             1. organize
081343 -             2. align
081344 -             3. analyse
081345 -             4. summize linked to details
081346 -
081347 -            ...as currently shown in the web page. ref OF 4 7920
081348 -
081349 -                  http://www.welchco.com/00302.HTM#7920
081351 -             ..
081352 -        b.  Each of these elements are accomplished in the human mind,
081353 -            albeit poorly, particularly as the number of details grows
081354 -            and the time period over which details impact performance
081355 -            is extended over weeks, months and years, as Andy Grove
081356 -            points out in his book, reviewed on 980307. ref SDS 5 3668
081358 -             ..
081359 -        c.  Communication Metrics uses POIMS technology to perform
081360 -            these elements faster, better and cheaper than can be done
081361 -            using existing methods, as explained in the web page, and
081362 -            cited by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers report.
081364 -             ..
081365 -            Morris makes no mention of the need for technology designed
081366 -            to keep pace with the daily volume of business activity.
081367 -            This may convey the impression that Communication Metrics
081368 -            can be accomplished by adding another executive or engineer
081369 -            or administrative assistant.
081371 -             ..
081372 -            We could not organize, align, analyse and link summary to
081373 -            details by adding 10 people that a Communication Manager
081374 -            accomplishes using SDS program under POIMS technology.
081375 -             ..
081376 -        d.  Morris does not mention using the Internet to deliver
081377 -            "intelligence" that builds and maintains shared meaning. As
081378 -            noted above, ref SDS 0 4224, there is no discussion of how
081379 -            this use of the Internet improves upon existing email that
081380 -            executives are already using, per discusson on 980722. see
081381 -            ref SDS 9 4826
081382 -        ..
081383 -    6.  Morris identifies specific application of Communication
081384 -        Metrics to construction claims, ref DRT 1 6006, reflecting his
081385 -        point on 980827. ref SDS 17 8520
081387 -         ..
081388 -        I am concerned that singling out construction claims in the
081389 -        market, would be like saying the alphabet or PCs or office
081390 -        furniture or accounting are good for construction claims, but
081391 -        not for everything else.
081392 -         ..
081393 -        Do the CEO, CFO, marketing, engineering... need "intelligence"
081394 -        for better communication, as defined by Morris...
081395 -
081396 -           "... a chronology of events, ...event linkage, history, and
081397 -           analysis. ...sumarized, and aligned with business
081398 -           objectives." ref DRT 1 3300
081400 -         ..
081401 -        How can people discover the value of "intelligence" if it is
081402 -        only used to avoid accountablity for not using intelligence to
081403 -        avoid the "crisis" that lead to claims?
081405 -         ..
081406 -        Morris is correct saying at ref DRT 1 6006 that Communication
081407 -        Metrics has been used for claims management, ref SDS 1 6894,
081408 -        but it has also been used for general management (on projects
081409 -        subject to contract, as he points out) at PG&E, ref DRP 1 8444,
081410 -        and at the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. ref DRP 2 6172
081412 -         ..
081413 -        We are trying to figure out to help people overcome ignorance,
081414 -        fear and denial that "intelligence" can improve every facet of
081415 -        management in like manner as the alphabet, PCs, office
081416 -        furniture and other level of effort functions.
081417 -        ..
081418 -    7.  What about critical benefits of "intelligence" for...
081419 -    
081420 -            a.  Better listening. ref OF 4 1838
081421 -
081422 -            b.  Clear, concise, complete communication. ref OF 4 8527
081424 -         ..
081425 -        These are generic benefits like analysis, alignment, and so on
081426 -        that broaden the appeal of the methodology.
081428 -         ..
081429 -        Since we are adding "metrics" to communication, it should be
081430 -        expected that "communiciation" is improved. Since communication
081431 -        is most critical factor of successful management, we should
081432 -        have a big market, per Andy Grove's practice of taking copious
081433 -        notes to avoid the ambiguity of mental maps, as reviewed on
081434 -        980307. ref SDS 5 3668
081436 -         ..
081437 -        How do we reach it?
081438 -
081440 -  ..
081441 - Executives Need Explanation of Business Intelligence
081442 -
081443 - Follow up ref SDS 20 1124, ref SDS 17 3052.
081444 -
081445 - Morris does not comment on the explanation of "intelligence," and does
081446 - not offer an alternate explanation in his submission, so this may
081447 - indicate that the explanation now published is adequate.
081448 -
081449 -
081451 -  ..
081452 - Communication Metrics Uniquely Provides Internal Intelligence
081453 -
081454 - Follow up ref SDS 20 5872.
081455 -
081456 - Morris does not comment on this subject.
081457 -
081458 -
081459 -
081460 -
081461 -
0815 -
Distribution. . . . See "CONTACTS"