CONTACTS 
0201 - Bootstrap Institute                                                                                                                                                O-00000735 0101
020101 - Mr. Douglas C. Engelbart, Ph.D.                                                                                                                                  O-00000735 0101

SUBJECTS
OHS/DKR Meeting at SRI 000518

0403 -
0403 -    ..
0404 - Summary/Objective
0405 -
040501 - Follow up ref SDS 38 0000, ref SDS 33 0000.
040502 -
040503 - Professor Mary Keeler presented work in philosophy on the meaning of
040504 - "knowledge" that suggests a development path for technology to focus
040505 - on the role of experience and organization (i.e., a "lens") in
040506 - enhancing traditional data and information management to provide a
040507 - powerful new way of thinking that forms a discipline of "knowledge
040508 - management." ref SDS 0 8439  Jack Park assisted Professor Keeler today
040509 - by introducing an architecture for a three (3) layer design to
040510 - implement KM. ref SDS 0 8439  This supports work by Doug Engelbart,
040511 - Eric Armstrong, Eugene Kim and Joe Williams on the same scope.
040512 - ref SDS 0 5555  Cynthia Waddell with the City of San Jose, discussed
040513 - briefly the opportunity to incorporate tools that aid the disabled.
040514 - ref SDS 0 3192  Howard Liu took notes during the meeting, which is a
040515 - big step toward implementing Professor Keeler's ideas on knowledge
040516 - management, called out recently by Eugene Kim. ref SDS 0 8160  Zope is
040517 - now up and running so it can begin augmenting project collaboration,
040518 - and provide experience with DKR starter tools. ref SDS 0 3944
040519 -
040520 -     [On 000526 received minutes of meeting from Howard Liu.
040521 -     ref SDS 45 0001
040522 -
040523 -
040524 -
040525 -
040526 -
0406 -

SUBJECTS
DKR Project Staff

0503 -
0504 - Discussion
050501 -  ..
050502 - Introductions - Diverse Skills Focused on DKR Project
050503 -
050504 - Follow up ref SDS 38 2079, ref SDS 33 2079.
050505 -
050506 - No new staff reported.
050507 -
050509 -  ..
050510 - Guests:
050511 -
050512 -     Sonny Kirkley
050513 -
050514 -        Information in Place, Inc., Indiana
050515 -
050516 -     ..
050517 -     Mary Keeler
050518 -
050519 -        Featured Speaker today (see below. ref SDS 0 8439)
050520 -        Researcher
050521 -        University of Washington
050523 -  ..
050524 -     Cynthia Waddell
050525 -
050526 -        San Jose City Manager Dept, has gained attention for law and
050527 -        policy paper on Disability, Compliance Officer for American
050528 -        Disability's Act, which relates to DKR requirements as
050529 -        discussed by Neil Scott on 000406. ref SDS 15 1980
050530 -
050531 -
050532 -
050533 -
050534 -
0506 -

SUBJECTS
SRI Organizational Platform, Project Management
Project Manager
Management and Governance
SRI Organizational Platform, Project Management, 000419
Plan Needed for Guidance
Iverson, Lee Assigned Full Time by SRI
Kim, Eugene Assigned PM by Doug
Project Management

1710 -
1711 - Discussion
171201 -  ..
171202 - Project Management, Lee Iverson Led Meeting; Howard Took Notes
171203 - Assignments - Eugene Kim Provide Project Management Support
171204 -
171205 - Follow up ref SDS 38 0784.
171206 -
171207 - No discussion on SRI role for organizational platform reported on
171208 - 000419. ref SDS 18 1540
171210 -  ..
171211 - No discussion on Lee Iverson's role assigned to project full time by
171212 - SRI, reported on 000504. ref SDS 33 7743
171214 -  ..
171215 - Lee Iverson did a great job leading the meeting in Eugene's absence,
171216 - who was assigned to PM support on 000511. ref SDS 38 0784
171217 - ..
171218 - Howard Liu prepared a detailed record on a notebook computer,
171219 - which aligns with Eugene's notice on 000516 that a formal record of
171220 - meetings would be prepared, ref SDS 41 3740, to implement Doug's idea
171221 - on 000427 for a Guide to Running NICs that captures the record and
171222 - obtains feedback for alignment with objectives and requirements.
171223 - ref SDS 28 2867  This shows growing commitment to the project
171224 - following the meeting on 000330. ref SDS 14 7546  Capturing the record
171225 - is a big step toward effective knowledge management that provides
171226 - useful content for a DKR.
171227 -
171228 -     [...below comment on progress implementing Guide to Running NICs.
171229 -     ref SDS 0 3995
171231 -      ..
171232 -     [On 000524 received Howard's record on the meeting. ref SDS 45
171233 -     0001
171234 - ..
171235 - During the meeting, Lee prepared an excellent graphic on his
171236 - notebook computer showing the elements drawn on the marking board by
171237 - Jack Park to illustrate Mary Keeler's presentation.
171239 -  ..
171240 - Lee plans to distribute the graphic to the team, similar to Howard's
171241 - notes.
171242 -
171243 -
1713 -

SUBJECTS
CODIAK Intelligence Capabilities
Guide to Running Nics, 000427

2204 -
220501 -  ..
220502 - Guide to Running NICs Gathers Intelligence, Provides Feedback
220503 - Communication Manager Proposed to Compliment Tools for DKR
220504 -
220505 - Follow up ref SDS 38 3995, ref SDS 33 3995.
220506 -
220507 - Nothing has been submitted responding to the request on 000428 for
220508 - more information on the Guide to Running NICs, ref DRP 3 3000,
220509 - proposed at the meeting on 000427. ref SDS 28 2867
220510 - ..
220511 - No record of work product showing contradictions and prodding of
220512 - contributors to grow knowledge repository's capabilities as we use it,
220513 - also proposed on 000427. ref SDS 28 2867
220515 -  ..
220516 - Howard Liu took notes of the meeting on a notebook computer, which
220517 - provides an opportunity to support Communication Metrics, per above.
220518 - ref SDS 0 8160
220519 -
220520 -     [On 000524 received Howard's record on the meeting. ref SDS 45
220521 -     0001
220522 -
220523 -
220524 -
220525 -
220526 -
2206 -

SUBJECTS
Sponsor/Stakeholder Planning
Killer Application

2504 -
250501 -  ..
250502 - Search for "Killer App" Focuses on Knowledge/Enterprise Management
250503 - Sponsors Looking for Projects in Knowledge Management Arena
250504 -
250505 - Follow up ref SDS 38 4877, ref SDS 33 4877.
250506 -
250507 -    At the end of the meeting on 000413 Eric seemed to indicate plans
250508 -    to consider sponsor outreach and planning for funding at the
250509 -    meeting today, perhaps including results of Doug's meeting with SRI
250510 -    and a major potential sponsor on Monday, 000410, ref SDS 17 4877,
250511 -    which was reported on 000419 to be moved to 000425.
250513 -     ..
250514 -    There was no work on this today.  Doug is planning to visit
250515 -    Washington DC next week.
250516 -    ..
250517 -    Doug confirmed understandings from the meeting on 000511 that
250518 -    he will not have support from the project team, ref SDS 38 4628,
250519 -    nor from SRI, for the trip to Washington next week to help with
250520 -    sponsor outreach, which is the current priority, reported on
250521 -    000419. ref SDS 18 2535
250522 -
250523 -        [On 000601 Pat Lincoln supported Doug on the trip to Washington.
250524 -        ref SDS 48 2701
250525 -
250526 -
250527 -
2506 -
250601 -
2507 -

SUBJECTS
Sun Microsystems Donated Server Space
Sponsor Outreach, Support, 000324
Web Site Server Vendor
Engelbart, Doug

3306 -
330701 -  ..
330702 - Server Space for DKR Donated by Sun Microsystems
330703 -
330704 - Follow up ref SDS 38 5962, ref SDS 33 5962.
330705 -
330706 - No report of progress using server donated by Sun, per Eric's letter
330707 - on 00042, ref SDS 21 0001
330708 -
330709 -
330710 -
330711 -
330712 -
3308 -

SUBJECTS
Property Rights in Knowledge Organization
Commercial Viability
Ownership Investment Risk
Development Investment Risk

3806 -
380701 -  ..
380702 - Legal Issues Arising from Open Source and Sponsor Support
380703 -
380704 - Follow up ref SDS 38 3055, ref SDS 33 3055.
380705 -
380706 - There was no discussion on getting a license or other standing
380707 - required to operate, noted at the meeting on 000330, ref SDS 14 3995,
380708 - possibly reflecting SRI will provide organizational platform, reported
380709 - 000420, ref SDS 20 6630, and Lee Iverson assigned full-time by SRI
380710 - 000504. ref SDS 33 7743
380712 -  ..
380713 - There was no discussion for licensing options discussed on 000324, and
380714 - submission by Eric Armstrong of license ideas on 000421 ref SDS 21
380715 - 3055
380716 -
380717 -
380718 -
380719 -
380720 -
3808 -

SUBJECTS
Knowledge Define, Distinguish Data, Information
Collective IQ
Lessons Learned, Cass Studies Root Cause Analysis
Purpose DKR
Intelligence, Augment, Purpose DKR
Decision Support Opinion Purpose of DKR
Experience, History, Lessons Learned, Case Study
Glossary, Engelbart, Doug, 000518
Collaborative Document System Email Core Capability DKR, Eric, 000505
Collaborative Epistomology Core Capability DKR for Ontology, Jack, 00
3-Layer Architecture Mary Keeler's Presentation on Charles Peirce
3-layer Architecture DKR, Jack Park, 000623

5814 -
581501 -  ..
581502 - Project Objective to Produce DKR Capability
581503 -
581504 - Follow up ref SDS 38 2808, ref SDS 33 2808.
581505 -
581507 -     ..
581508 -    Knowledge Management Definition
581509 -
581510 -    Follow up ref SDS 38 5555, ref SDS 33 5555.
581511 -
581512 -    Rod and Eric reported on meeting at Intel yesterday to develop a
581513 -    common vision of knowledge management. ref SDS 42 0000
581515 -     ..
581516 -    The record of the meeting shows a definition of data, information
581517 -    and knowledge. ref SDS 42 0785
581519 -     ..
581520 -    This supplements work by...
581521 -
581522 -     •  Doug Engelbart's 1972 paper submitted to the current DKR team
581523 -        on 000327, that set out a scope to improve handling of daily
581524 -        working information. ref SDS 12 3971
581526 -         ..
581527 -     •  Eugene Kim on 000504 explaining information and knowledge,
581528 -        based on his DKR project. ref SDS 32 5003
581530 -         ..
581531 -     •  Joe Williams on 000510 explained "knowledge." ref SDS 37 0004
581533 -         ..
581534 -     •  Jack Park on 000516 defined "knowledge. ref SDS 41 4723
581536 -     ..
581537 -    Today, the team reviewed Doug's request on 000307 to develop a work
581538 -    up on knowledge and KM similar to Bellinger, ref SDS 10 4820, and
581539 -    again on 000419. ref SDS 18 4964  At the meeting on 000504 Doug
581540 -    related having been denied support by NSF because a proposal did
581541 -    not define "knowledge." ref SDS 33 5555
581542 -
581543 -       [On 000601 need for common vision of KM cited to attract funding
581544 -       from sponsors looking for proof of concept. ref SDS 48 1007
581546 -     ..
581547 -    Doug commented today that the project needs a glossary.
581548 -
581549 -       This might be a first order of business for the DKR.
581550 -
581551 -       We now have several ways of defining "knowledge" and related
581552 -       issues, including professional perspective from professor Mary
581553 -       Keeler in her paper on Charles Peirce reviewed on 000515,
581554 -       ref SDS 40 0005, and the professors remarks today, per below.
581555 -       ref SDS 0 8439  This may enable preparing a definition of
581556 -       knowledge management to guide development of the DKR, per Jack
581557 -       Park's explanation of "architecture" reported on 000426,
581558 -       ref SDS 26 0304, and discussion yesterday at Intel on the need
581559 -       for definitions of common terms that support advancing the state
581560 -       of the art. ref SDS 42 1882
581561 -
581562 -          [On 000601 Joe Williams reported during project meeting at
581563 -          SRI that he is working on glossary. ref SDS 48 5783
581565 -           ..
581566 -          [On 000601 Bill Bearden submitted first draft beginning a
581567 -          glossary. ref SDS 49 0001
581569 -           ..
581570 -          [On 000602 Eugene Kim suggests integrating DKR glossary with
581571 -          prior work cited by Doug; Joe Williams is supporting this
581572 -          initiative. ref SDS 50 0001
581574 -           ..
581575 -          [On 000615 glossary on Wiki; ground rules started.
581576 -          ref SDS 52 5783
581578 -     ..
581579 -    Reviewed difference between "knowledge" and "information" in order
581580 -    to identify core capability of DKR that shapes the purpose of the
581581 -    project, per Debra England's suggestion on 000420, ref SDS 20 5555,
581582 -    and Eric's request for support on 000208. ref SDS 8 8960
581584 -     ..
581585 -    Discussed Eric's submission on 000421, ref SDS 21 5933, expanded on
581586 -    000423 proposing that the DKR augment human intelligence.
581587 -    ref SDS 24 5933;
581589 -     ..
581590 -    Lee Iverson's progress getting Zope set up on the bootstrap.org
581591 -    website, per above, ref SDS 0 3944, will strengthen project
581592 -    correspondence, so the team can begin to gain experience with a
581593 -    connected environment, as recommended on 000505 to support
581594 -    development of project requirements specs.
581595 -
581597 -     ..
581598 -    3-Layer Architecture Possibility, Actuality, Probability
581599 -
581600 -    Mary Keeler's presentation of "Knowledge" based on Charles Peirce's
581601 -    philosophy on human "thinking," which Jack Park submitted on 000515.
581602 -    ref SDS 40 0783
581604 -     ..
581605 -    Professor Keeler's appearance accomplishes in part the objective
581606 -    for the DKR team to get professional guidance on the character of
581607 -    knowledge and human thought, requested by Doug Engelbart on 000307.
581608 -    ref SDS 10 4820  Also, need input from cognitive science, discussed
581609 -    in a call with Doug on 000327. ref SDS 12 2730  Following Mary's
581610 -    formal remarks she discussed correlations with POIMS technology,
581611 -    ref OF 1 0561, that address Doug's request for a work up on the
581612 -    meaning of "knowledge," per above. ref SDS 0 5555
581613 -
581614 -         [On 000624 letter to Mary on improving alphabet technology.
581615 -         ref SDS 54 0001
581617 -         ..
581618 -        [On 050115 Jack Park comments that Mary's paper holds that
581619 -        Perice's semiotics presents learning as deeper than refining
581620 -        accuracy of knowledge through experience. ref SDS 62 MN8O
581622 -     ..
581623 -    Jack assisted Mary in presenting Peirce's ideas on semiotics
581624 -    relative to DKR development.  Jack initially explained a diagram
581625 -    for a three (3) layer architecture with different levels of
581626 -    knowledge representation.  Mary used the diagram to discuss a
581627 -    "knowledge" development process relative to...
581628 -
581629 -                      •  Probability
581631 -                          ..
581632 -                      •  Actuality
581634 -                          ..
581635 -                      •  Possibility
581637 -     ..
581638 -    ...that seemed to suggest different levels of access, support and
581639 -    contributing content for presenting information in alternate views
581640 -    based on context.  An executive needs one view, sales needs a
581641 -    another view, engineering, production, and so on, but all supported
581642 -    by a common underlying record of experience, which Peirce
581643 -    correlates with "knowledge," discussed further below. ref SDS 0
581644 -    3528 As well, different circumstances require different views from
581645 -    day-to-day.  Constructing different views for particular context at
581646 -    specific times requires a well structured and comprehensive record
581647 -    that lends itself to assembling sub-structures quickly and easily.
581649 -     ..
581650 -    Research on 991027 indicates Greek philosophers associated
581651 -    knowledge with actualization of human reasoning. ref SDS 4 8W6O
581653 -     ..
581654 -    A 3-layer architecture for technology to support knowledge work
581655 -    seems to fit the model of network bookkeeping that applies 3-layers
581656 -    of support for accounting, reviewed on 990804. ref SDS 3 YV5M
581657 -
581658 -
581659 -         [On 000623 Jack amplifies 3-layer architecture. ref SDS 53
581660 -         EK3W
581662 -          ..
581663 -         [On 020730 Gary Johnson subits ideas that may help implement
581664 -         the 3-layer architecture. ref SDS 60 YR6F
581666 -          ..
581667 -         [On 040709 3-layer architecture defined in POIMS for people,
581668 -         process, time. ref SDS 61 NG7H  Another 3-layer architecture
581669 -         needed for deployment that entails using existing tools
581670 -         without learning anything, using organizational memory to work
581671 -         intelligently, and using SDS to construct organizational
581672 -         memory in Knowledge Space. ref SDS 61 8M9N
581674 -     ..
581675 -    Jack and Mary talked about a "lens," so possibly this design leads
581676 -    toward Knowledge Space, as people gain experience with such a
581677 -    system.  Jack mentioned this idea a few weeks ago on 000503,
581678 -    ref SDS 31 6138, and it is discussed further below. ref SDS 0 2812
581679 -
581680 -         [On 000525 received minutes of meeting from Howard Liu.
581681 -         ref SDS 45 0001
581683 -          ..
581684 -         [On 000530 sent follow up letter to Mary. ref SDS 46 9797
581686 -          ..
581687 -         [On 000531 Joe Williams commented on Peirce's philosophy and
581688 -         inquired about SDS using XML. ref SDS 47 0001
581690 -          ..
581691 -         [On 000710 Jack prepared a formal graphic of the diagram used
581692 -         today; Joe Williams put the graphic on his web site for
581693 -         general access by the team. ref SDS 55 0001
581695 -          ..
581696 -         [On 001130 Jack submits analysis of SDS showing features for
581697 -         accomplishing a 3-layered architecture for KM. ref SDS 59 5HW3
581699 -     ..
581700 -    Peirce's view of collaboration, as a core activity for accurate
581701 -    understanding, ref SDS 40 0010, supports Doug's call for augmenting
581702 -    collective IQ, reviewed on 991222, ref SDS 6 9167 and ref SDS 6
581703 -    0784, and Eric's requirements for a distributed Collaborative
581704 -    Document System (CDS), reviewed on 000505. ref SDS 34 4392
581705 -
581706 -         [On 000623 Jack advises the presentation today presented a
581707 -         3-layered DKR architecture. ref SDS 53 1998
581709 -     ..
581710 -    Prior to Mary's formal remarks, discussed Peirce's work that led to
581711 -    cognitive science, set out in the record on 000515. ref SDS 40 5083
581712 -    On 000328 letter to DKR team recommended presentation in cognitive
581713 -    science, based on review of Doug's work on 000327. ref SDS 12 2030
581714 -    Mary's comments today, in part, address that requirement.
581715 -    ref SDS 13 0003
581717 -     ..
581718 -    In particular, Peirce's call for "collaboration" is largely
581719 -    ignored.  Common ground is overlooked in philosophy, cognitive and
581720 -    management science essential to guide computer science in building
581721 -    tools that augment human intelligence for solving problems in the
581722 -    world.  Cross-fertilization of disciplines is critical for moving
581723 -    forward, but is not evident in the burgeoning practice of knowledge
581724 -    management, where it should be a bright shining star to lead the
581725 -    way.
581726 -
581727 -
581728 -
5818 -

SUBJECTS
Knowledge Space Reflects Continuous Character of Human Thought Making
Knowledge and Logic Derived from Experience, Semiotic Theory
Knowledge Space Peirce Semotic Theory of Continual Thought Builds Kno
Knowledge Requires Experience, Accuracy from Continual Refinement
Truth Moving Target Meaning Drift Requires Constant Alignment, Feedba
Meaning Derived from Patterns Experience and Symbols, Alphabet
Space, Identifying Management Details Similar to Legal Citations
Cause Effect on Values Needs, Meaning, Connections
Organic Subject Structure Experience, Meaning Drift
Communication Biggest Risk in Enterprise, Dilemma
Truth Moving Target on Information Highway, Needs SDS
Meaning Maintain Shared Over Time
New Way of Thinking Working Doug's Mission Bootstrap Institute, 99122
Knowledge Space Replaces Paradigm of Knowledge in Books

9316 -
931701 -     ..
931702 -    Key factors of "knowledge" from Peirce's work relevant to the DKR
931703 -    project...
931704 -
931705 -       1.  "Knowledge" is largely an experiential record that organizes
931706 -           a continuous information stream over time into "stories,"
931707 -           also, "history" of lessons learned, paradigms, or general
931708 -           "rules of thumb," e.g., "been there done that," rather than
931709 -           applying formal, rigid rules of logic.  Reasoning flows from
931710 -           the weight of experience showing consistent sequences of
931711 -           cause and effect for similar context. ref SDS 40 5026
931713 -            ..
931714 -           This usage is juxtaposed to "data" and "information" in the
931715 -           record from yesterday at Intel, ref SDS 42 3976; and, can be
931716 -           compared with Bellinger's work reviewed on 000307, per Doug.
931717 -           ref SDS 10 3968
931719 -            ..
931720 -       2.  "Meaning" of information from meetings, calls and activity
931721 -           (e.g., driving a nail, car, ship, airplane; stitching a
931722 -           wound, playing ball or a piano; writing computer code or a
931723 -           poem) varies according to correlations with unique patterns
931724 -           of personal experience, particularly recent experience,
931725 -           ref SDS 40 3782; and requires constant effort to refine
931726 -           accuracy through feedback loops by aligning new information;
931727 -           despite which, complete accuracy is never achieved, per
931728 -           Peircy reviewed on 000515, making "truth" a moving target
931729 -           due to meaning drift. ref SDS 40 7380  Since the mind can
931730 -           align information for only about a minute until connections
931731 -           get mixed up and commingled with subsequent information,
931732 -           reported on 950204, ref SDS 1 0550, and further since lack
931733 -           of alignment is hidden from the conscious mind until
931734 -           conflicting activity occurs minutes, hours, days, weeks,
931735 -           months, years later, called "mistakes," which then make
931736 -           managers expert "problem handlers," instead of leaders, who
931737 -           focus on near term cost savings in order to offset long term
931738 -           cost overruns due to rework to fix past mistakes, with the
931739 -           result is that...
931740 -
931742 -                  ..
931743 -                 communication is the biggest risk in enterprise
931745 -            ..
931746 -           ...as explained in POIMS. ref OF 1 8316   This poses a huge
931747 -           target of opportunity for improving handling of daily
931748 -           working information by the DKR to turn continual bumbling
931749 -           into continual learning, called out by Doug Engelbart in his
931750 -           1972 paper, which he cited recently to the team at SRI on
931751 -           000327. ref SDS 12 3971  Accuracy was argued as a benefit of
931752 -           alphabet technology by Plato in 400 BC. ref SDS 5 2320
931754 -            ..
931755 -       3.  "Lens" is a filter, or "management" function, for daily
931756 -           details that organizes information into knowledge structures
931757 -           that can be roughly called an "ontology," and, also, into
931758 -           subjects roughly called "epistomology." ref SDS 40 0784
931759 -           addresses action item 3 on 000407. ref SDS 16 4757
931760 -
931761 -             [On 000623 Jack Park submits architecture ideas that
931762 -             explain "actualities" are the "lense" Mary discusses
931763 -             today, ref SDS 53 0750, Jack is developing an engine to
931764 -             create topic maps. ref SDS 53 2915
931766 -              ..
931767 -             [On 000830 meeting says OHS goal to provide a lense for
931768 -             viewing archived email. ref SDS 57 GO4J
931770 -              ..
931771 -             [On 001010 progress reported developing Magic Lense to
931772 -             implement Augment methods. ref SDS 58 G8R3
931774 -     ..
931775 -    These three ideas provide a development path for the DKR
931776 -    project to create a continuous information stream organized into a
931777 -    powerful...
931778 -
931779 -
931780 -                         Knowledge Space
931781 -
931782 -
931783 -    ...analogous to dimensional space, explained on 960620, ref SDS 2
931784 -    3516, and cited by Jack Park on 000503. ref SDS 31 6138  This
931785 -    ushers in a whole new way of thinking under the umbrella of
931786 -    "Knowledge Management," called out by Doug Engelbart, reported on
931787 -    991222, ref SDS 6 3696, and suggested by Eric Armstrong on 000212,
931788 -    ref SDS 9 9790, answering his question on 000208 about the core
931789 -    capability of the DKR and supporting tools. ref SDS 8 8960
931790 -
931791 -         [On 000623 Jack advises the presentation today presented a
931792 -         3-layered DKR architecture. ref SDS 53 1998
931793 -
931794 -
931795 -
931796 -
931797 -
931798 -
9318 -
9319 -    Time Milg Emply T  Bill Function  Special Subject/File

SUBJECTS
OHS Open Hyperdocument System
OHS Editor XML, Requirements, Specs
Engineering Management
Atomic Data Structures, 000423
Specification
Collaborative Document System Email Core Capability DKR, Eric, 000505
DKR Data Structures, 000423
Collaboration, Core Capability DKR - Email, Eric, 000505
Collaboration, Ontology, Core Capability DKR, Jack, 000623

A611 -
A61201 -     ..
A61202 -    Editor Based on XML Initial Project Deliverable
A61203 -    Collaborative Document System and OHS Supported by Editor
A61204 -
A61205 -    Follow up ref SDS 38 5880, ref SDS 33 5880.
A61206 -
A61207 -    No record discussing project specs v0.6, ref DRP 6 0001, issued on
A61208 -    000508, ref SDS 35 0782, reviewed in depth on 000505. ref SDS 34
A61209 -    0782
A61211 -     ..
A61212 -    Except, Peirce's philosophy presented above, supports providing
A61213 -    collaborative capability for KM. ref SDS 0 4511
A61215 -     ..
A61216 -    Adding Subjects and Catagories to Email Does Not Produce Knowledge
A61217 -    Collaboration Requires Investment to Save Time, Expedite Work
A61218 -
A61219 -    There was brief discussion that "collaboration" requires more than
A61220 -    sending an email with a bunch of links to other sources under a
A61221 -    general subject of interest to the project.  The aim is to husband
A61222 -    resources and focus efforts on critical information and ideas.
A61224 -     ..
A61225 -    Thus, if someone encounters information that supports project
A61226 -    objectives, some effort should be made to guide collaborators
A61227 -    toward what is said in the reference, and which among many project
A61228 -    objectives is affected.  If a picture, graph or table is shown,
A61229 -    state what it establishes that furthers a specific project
A61230 -    requirement.  Suggest plans for incorporating this resource into
A61231 -    the DKR work program. This gives collaborators some clues that save
A61232 -    time.  Time is an important part of Knowledge Management.
A61233 -    ..
A61234 -    On 000307 Doug Engelbart pointed the team to work by
A61235 -    Bellinger on explaining the meaning and purpose of "Knowledge
A61236 -    Management," and asked the team to develop a "work up" for the DKR
A61237 -    project like Bellinger has done. ref SDS 10 4820 Examination showed
A61238 -    that Bellinger cited the "KnowledgeFarm" as a reference to help
A61239 -    people grasp the character and requirements for Knowledge
A61240 -    Management work. The KnowledgeFarm says Knowledge Management is
A61241 -    hard work. ref SDS 10 4472  One of the goals of the DKR might to be
A61242 -    to make Knowledge Management easier, so that more of it can get
A61243 -    done in the time available between meetings, calls and email.
A61245 -     ..
A61246 -    In the meantime, we have to do the hard work in order to figure out
A61247 -    the requirements for Knowledge Management, in order to figure out
A61248 -    how to make it easier.
A61249 -
A61250 -         [On 000623 Jack proposes KM is accomplished with collaborative
A61251 -         evolution of epistomology, ref SDS 53 4752, and a software
A61252 -         engine to assign subjects. ref SDS 53 2915
A61254 -          ..
A61255 -         [On 000710 Jack Park submits link to an article without
A61256 -         explaining why or how it supports a project objective.
A61257 -         ref SDS 55 3961
A61259 -          ..
A61260 -         [On 000711 submitted letter to project team recommending
A61261 -         continued efforts for effective collaboration. ref SDS 56 9396
A61262 -
A61264 -     ..
A61265 -    Atomic Data Structures Derive from Fundamental Information Unit
A61266 -    Fundamental Information Unit Focuses DKR Design Effort
A61267 -
A61268 -    Follow up ref SDS 38 4004, ref SDS 33 4004.
A61269 -
A61270 -    No evident discussion today of Joe Williams comprehensive
A61271 -    presentation on 000420 of DKR and OHS framework. ref SDS 20 4004
A61273 -     ..
A61274 -    No discussion of atomic data structures submitted by Eric on
A61275 -    000423. ref SDS 24 4977
A61276 -
A61277 -        [On 000524 Paul Fernhout submitted to Eric Armstrong and others
A61278 -        information about Pointrel Data Repository based on Python.
A61279 -        ref SDS 43 0783
A61280 -
A61281 -
A61282 -
A61283 -
A61284 -
A613 -

SUBJECTS
Augment, Doug Engelbart's System at SRI Beginning in 1960s
Augment Human Capabilities
Engelbart, Doug
Iverson, Lee
Augment Presentation, Engelbart, Iverson, Williams, Yee, 000420

AD07 -
AD0801 -     ..
AD0802 -    Augment Project at SRI in 1960s Sets Design Objectives
AD0803 -    Demonstration for Augment at Future Project Meeting
AD0804 -
AD0805 -    Follow up ref SDS 38 5992, ref SDS 33 5992.
AD0806 -
AD0807 -    No record of presentation on Augment today, per Eric's letter on
AD0808 -    000421, ref SDS 21 0001, again on 000423, ref SDS 24 0005, and
AD0809 -    Jack's report on 000426 that Doug's Augment sets the stage and
AD0810 -    vision for an effective DKR.
AD0811 -
AD0812 -
AD0813 -
AD0814 -
AD0815 -
AD0816 -
AD0817 -
AD09 -

SUBJECTS
Use Case Method Define Requirement, 00000000
Software Programming Program, Use Case Analysis, 000406

AI04 -
AI0501 -  ..
AI0502 - Use Case Methods for Software Design
AI0503 -
AI0504 - Follow up ref SDS 38 4933, ref SDS 33 4933.
AI0505 -
AI0506 - No discussion of Eugene Kim's comprehensive submission on 000504
AI0507 - suggesting the scope of OHS, and detailing specific use cases that
AI0508 - improve literacy, supported by Jack Park. ref SDS 32 0784
AI0509 -
AI0510 -
AI0511 -
AI0512 -
AI0513 -
AI06 -

SUBJECTS
Existing Capability, Start with What is Available, 000302
Pilot Test New Capabilities, 000227
Zope Email System, 000427
SlashDot Email System, 000427
ArsDigita Email System, 000427
Document Management
Pilot Test New Capabilities, 000227
Pilot Test Email for Organizing and Thought Tracking, 000428
Zope DKR OHS Email Starter Technology with Addressability, 000504

AS11 -
AS1201 -     ..
AS1202 -    Zope Easy to Install, Strong Email for DKR Project
AS1203 -    Starter Tools for DKR Email, Project Team to Pilot Test
AS1204 -    Pilot Test Email Programs to Evaluate DKR Starter Technologies
AS1205 -
AS1206 -    Follow up ref SDS 38 3944, ref SDS 33 3944.
AS1207 -
AS1208 -    Lee Advised that Zope is now up and running on Bootstrap.org, per
AS1209 -    Howard's notes. ref DRP 8 0574
AS1210 -
AS1211 -        [On 000524 received Howard's notes. ref SDS 45 0001
AS1213 -     ..
AS1214 -    This supports action item reported on 000505 to implement project
AS1215 -    requirements for OHS/DKR, ref SDS 34 5072, per prior planning
AS1216 -    reported by Lee at the meeting on 000504. ref SDS 33 9000
AS1217 -
AS1218 -        [On 000525 Lee reports Zope difficult to implement. ref SDS 44
AS1219 -        3944
AS1221 -         ..
AS1222 -        [On 000609 Lee reports Wiki up and running; enables project to
AS1223 -        focus better than using email. ref SDS 51 0001
AS1225 -         ..
AS1226 -        [On 000615 Lee explains social contract procedures for using
AS1227 -        Wiki. ref SDS 52 9000
AS1228 -
AS1229 -
AS1230 -
AS1231 -
AS1232 -
AS13 -

SUBJECTS
WBI Transcoding Vector
WBI 3 Tier Server Architecture, 000427
DirectDom, JDOM Processors of XML DKR, 000427
Park, Jack, Iverson, Lee
WBI Vector Presentation, Engelbart, 000420
Source Development System (SDS) Transcoding, 000511
SDS Source Development System Transcoding, 000511

B409 -
B41001 -  ..
B41002 - Current Proposal for DKR Transcoding - Complex Process
B41003 - Architecture - Three-Tier Server for WBI Implementation
B41004 -
B41005 - Follow up ref SDS 38 4674, ref SDS 33 4674.
B41006 -
B41007 - No discussion at the meeting today.
B41008 -
B41010 -     ..
B41011 -    Fundamental Issues of DKR Project Focused by DOM
B41012 -    DOM (Document Object Model) Uses XML for Doc Management
B41013 -
B41014 -    Follow up ref SDS 38 3640, ref SDS 33 3640.
B41015 -
B41016 -    No evident discussion on DOM and DDOM issue; nor of data base issue
B41017 -    with respect to W3C, Python and Java discussed, as well, on 000504.
B41018 -    ref SDS 33 3994
B41020 -     ..
B41021 -    Augment Data can be Transcoded
B41022 -
B41023 -    Follow up ref SDS 38 4558, ref SDS 33 4558.
B41024 -
B41025 -    No discussion on Augment issue.
B41026 -
B41028 -     ..
B41029 -    Gnutella Eliminates Browser/Server Distinction
B41030 -
B41031 -    Follow up ref SDS 38 4868, ref SDS 33 4868.
B41032 -
B41033 -    No discussion on Gnutella issue.
B41034 -
B41035 -
B41036 -
B41037 -
B41038 -
B411 -

SUBJECTS
Project Planning, Objectives
Plan Needed for Guidance
Management and Governance
Agenda Issues

B906 -
B90701 -  ..
B90702 - Project "Plan" to Attract Sponsors
B90703 -
B90704 - Follow up ref SDS 38 6036, ref SDS 33 6036.
B90705 -
B90706 - There was no discussion of the project plan from work on 000324.
B90707 - ref SDS 11 9776
B90709 -  ..
B90710 - Action item to demonstrate ability to perform, costs and benefits
B90711 - required to attract sponsors, shown on 000407, still needs attention.
B90712 - ref SDS 16 6973
B90714 -  ..
B90715 - On 000419 Doug announced plans for a trip to Washington for sponsor
B90716 - support.  At the meeting on 000420 Eric set objective to provide
B90717 - proposal ideas to support Doug's trip, that shows a project
B90718 - development plan. ref SDS 20 8667
B90719 - ..
B90720 - Proposal ideas for Doug's trip were not discussed today.
B90721 -
B90722 -     [On 000601 trip to Washington indicated need for stronger
B90723 -     planning. ref SDS 48 1760
B90724 -
B90725 -
B90726 -
B90727 -
B90728 -
B90729 -
B90730 -
B908 -