THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700


S U M M A R Y


DIARY: October 6, 1999 01:45 PM Wednesday; Rod Welch

Received from S&C Ford tire spec and warranty for work on 990507.

1...Summary/Objective
2...Tire Spec and Warranty Received from S&C
.....Customer Vehicle and Tire Identification...
.....Product Information
3...Website for Firestone
4...Gold Pledge Limited Warranty
5...Rotate Tires Performed Free of Charge by Vendor
6...Safety Warning Vibration May Indicate Tire Failure
7...Speed ratings Shown on Tires
8...Tire Service - Web Site Has Different Number
9...Tire Registration
10...Supplemental Limited Mileage Warranty - Seems Repetitious
11...Road Hazard Limited Warranty Option Not Purchased
12...Lifetime Wheel Balance Plan Not Purchased
13...Lifetime Alignment Certificate Not Purchased
14...Maintenance Record
15...Vehicle Manufacturer's Recommended Tire Pressure, Lug Nut Torque
16...Firestone One Month Road Test Not Performed

ACTION ITEMS.................. Click here to comment!

1...S&C did not submit a cover letter explaining what is submitted and how
2...There is no explanation that summarizes how a non-professinal
3...Need stamp on the page for Mileage Warranty Certificate
4...Need tire serial numbers and registration submitted by S&C to
5...S&C or Firestone need to explain what is supplemental protection?
6...Need price for Road Hazard Limited Warranty option.
7...Need price for Lifetime Wheel Balance Plan.
8...Need price for Lifetime Alignment Certificate.
9...Tire pressure and lug nut torque specs missing.
10...The store is supposed to provide details on customer road test.

CONTACTS 
0201 - S & C Ford                           415 553 4400 fax or 800...
020101 - Mr. Larry Smith; Manager
020102 - Service Department

SUBJECTS
Millie's Mercury Sable, 940423
New Firestone Tires Installed, 990507
Warranty Firestone Tires Installed, 990507
Ford Recall, Change Oil, Hoses, Tire Tread Wear

0606 -    ..
0607 - Summary/Objective
0608 -
060801 - Follow up ref SDS 28 0000, ref SDS 27 0000.
060802 -
060803 - Received a Firestone tire warranty that has handwritten information on
060804 - page 12 which covers the work performed by S&C Ford on 990507. There
060805 - is no cover letter and no explanation of coverage.  Tire serial
060806 - numbers are missing, and a verification stamp has not been entered
060807 - showing that tire registration was performed by S&C Ford, as called
060808 - out on page 11.
060809 -
060810 -     [On 991015 sent letter on pending issues. ref SDS 29 0001]
060811 -
060812 -     [On 991018 called to follow up. ref SDS 30 0001]
060813 -
060814 -
060815 -
0609 -
0610 -
0611 - Progress
0612 -
061201 -  ..
061202 - Tire Spec and Warranty Received from S&C
061203 -
061204 - Received today in an envelope from S&C Ford the following 20 page
061205 - document...
061206 -
061207 -
061208 -          Tire Maintenance, Warranty and Safety Manual
061209 -
061210 -
061211 -                         Firestone
061212 -
061213 -
061214 - ...which is entered in the record. ref OF 1 0001
061215 -
061216 - This provides identification that S&C did not provide when the tires
061217 - were sold on 990507. ref SDS 6 LJNL
061218 -
061219 -  ..
061220 - S&C did not submit a cover letter explaining what is submitted and how
061221 - it relates to the record.
061222 -
061223 - The document contains 20 pages from front to back cover of very small,
061224 - probably a 4 or 6 point font, that is very hard to read.  Need a
061225 - magnifying glass.
061226 -                             ..
061227 - There is no explanation that summarizes how a non-professinal
061228 - tire expert, such as most customers, should be alerted to key
061229 - information that guides use of the warranty.
061230 -
061231 -      Page 12 seems to say we have a 70,000 mile warranty. ref OF 1
061232 -      3005 and ref SDS 0 7104
061233 -
061234 -      What is the "Basic Protection" that should be known by the
061235 -      customer, as shown for the General Tire warranty provided by S&C
061236 -      Ford on 951020. ref SDS 3 2146
061237 -
061238 - This generally satisfies the requirement to complete the record on the
061239 - Firestone tires which S&C Ford installed on 990507, ref SDS 6 5548 per
061240 - following requests...
061241 -
061242 -      991001... call. ref SDS 28 0001
061243 -      990920... letter ref DIP 5 0001 submitted. ref SDS 27 0001
061244 -      990731... letter ref DRP 4 7493 omits items. ref SDS 25 5775
061245 -      990722... call. ref SDS 24 9766
061246 -      990715... letter ref DIP 4 0360 submitted. ref SDS 23 8966
061247 -      990708... call. ref SDS 21 1935
061248 -      990603... call. ref SDS 13 3569
061249 -      990602... call. ref SDS 12 0001
061250 -      990601... call. ref SDS 11 0001
061251 -      990525... call. ref SDS 9 0001
061252 -      990520... call. ref SDS 8 3953
061253 -      990519... letter ref DIP 1 0001 submitted. ref SDS 7 2968
061254 -      990507... service visit omitted items. ref SDS 6 5548
061255 -     ..
061256 -     Customer Vehicle and Tire Identification...
061257 -     
061258 -     Someone, possibly Larry, entered by handwriting on page 12
061259 -     ref OF 1 6624, the following Customer information...
061260 -
061261 -         Millie Welch
061262 -         440 Davis Court #1602
061263 -         San Francisco, CA 94111
061264 -
061265 -         Original Invoice:  314868, ref DRP 2 0001
061266 -
061267 -                Tires are shown at... ref DRP 2 1560
061268 -
061269 -         Date of Purchase: 990507. ref SDS 6 3712
061270 -
061271 -         Year of Vehicle:  1993
061272 -         Make of Vehicle:  Mercury
061273 -         Model of Vehicle:  Sable
061274 -         Remaining Mileage:  76368
061275 -     ..
061276 -     Product Information
061277 -     
061278 -     Handwriting on page 12 ref OF 1 3005, shows following product
061279 -     spec...
061280 -
061281 -           Note...handwritting illegible, as occurs in medical practice
061282 -           reported on 990912. ref SDS 26 0900
061283 -
061284 -         Tire Size:  P205/65/R15
061285 -
061286 -         Speed Rating:  92S
061287 -
061288 -            Page 9 shows the "S" speed rating is for 112MPH.  There is
061289 -            no listing for a speed rating of 92MPH.
061290 -         ..
061291 -         Tire Type:  FT70C with UNI-T-BL
061292 -                     TLW:70
061293 -         ..
061294 -         Mileage Warranty:  70,000
061295 -         ..
061296 -         Serial Numbers:
061297 -
061298 -            This information is missing in the form. ref OF 1 3003 The
061299 -            Tire Registration section says this information is supplied
061300 -            by the tire vendor. ref SDS 0 0350
061301 -         ..
061302 -         Mileage Warranty Certificate
061303 -
061304 -            Need stamp on the page for Mileage Warranty Certificate
061305 -            ref OF 1 9582, S&C did not enter a stamp.
061306 -
061307 -
061308 -
061309 - Website for Firestone
061310 -
061311 -   Page 4 in the warranty gives a website...
061312 -
061313 -                    http://www.firestone-usa.com
061314 -
061315 -   ...we can get location for nearest store. ref OF 1 3177
061316 -
061317 - This site also has a section for tire selection...
061318 -
061319 -     http://www.firestone-usa.com/tireselect/Tireselector.asp
061320 -
061321 - ...where the year, make and model of the vehicle can be entered.
061322 -
061323 - I entered 1993, Mercury, Sable, and the web site opened the following
061324 - page...
061325 -
061326 - http://www.firestone-usa.com/tireselect/cgi/get_tires.plx?year=1993&make=MERCURY&model=Sable(All+Models)
061327 -
061328 - ...that showed...
061329 -
061330 -                       P205/65R15
061331 -
061332 -             is the standard tire size for your
061333 -             1993, MERCURY, Sable(All Models)
061334 -
061335 - ...this aligns with information entered on page in the warranty by
061336 - S&C. ref SDS 0 2055
061337 -
061338 - Further down on this page there is a link for...
061339 -
061340 -
061341 -                       FT70C with UNI-T
061342 -
061343 -
061344 - This likely clarifies the illegible handwritting in the warranty
061345 - manual submitted by S&C. ref SDS 0 4884
061346 -
061347 - ...clicking takes to the following page...
061348 -
061349 -
061350 -           http://www.firestone-usa.com/products/fsft70c.htm
061351 -
061352 - ..
061353 - Further down this page shows a link for a...
061354 -
061355 -                        70,000 mile warranty
061356 -
061357 -                        Gold Pledge Limited Warranty
061358 -
061359 -
061360 -    This suggestes there are two warranty options.
061361 -
061362 - Since the warranty received from S&C has entered on page 12...
061363 -
061364 -
061365 -                   Mileage Warranty:  70,000
061366 -
061367 -
061368 -    ...this seems to indicate 70,000 mile warranty is the applicable
061369 -    choice on the web site...
061370 -
061371 -
061372 -        http://www.firestone-usa.com/warranty/warr12.htm#firemile
061373 -
061374 -
061375 - This site, however, does not have all of the language in the warranty
061376 - received from S&C Ford.  There is only a single page that covers the
061377 - following topics...
061378 -
061379 -     Replacement Price
061380 -     Replacement Warranty
061381 -     Consumer Rights
061382 -     Conditions and Exclusions
061383 -     Owner's Obligations
061384 -
061385 -
061386 -  ..
061387 - Gold Pledge Limited Warranty
061388 -
061389 - The Warranty received from S&C has many more sections, than show on
061390 - the Firestone web site for the 70,000 mile warranty. ref SDS 0 2862
061391 - This indicates S&C submitted a Gold Pledge Limited Warranty, which has
061392 - terms and conditions at the following web site address...
061393 -
061394 -
061395 -       http://www.firestone-usa.com/warranty/warr3.htm#fire
061396 -
061397 -
061398 -
061399 -  ..
061400 - Rotate Tires Performed Free of Charge by Vendor
061401 -
061402 - Page 4 in the warranty says...
061403 -
061404 -   ... rotate tires any time you notice irregular or uneven treadwear,
061405 -   or every 5,000 miles or at vehcile manufacturer's recommended
061406 -   mileage, if sooner.  This service is free on tires purchased from
061407 -   THE STORE... ref OF 1 3077
061408 -
061409 -   Page 11 in the warranty says...
061410 -
061411 -   Individual tire pressures must be checked after rotation and
061412 -   adjusted to the vehicle manufacturer's recommendation for the tire's
061413 -   new location on the vehicle. Vehicle alignment should be checked if
061414 -   irregular wear is evident. ref OF 1 2990
061415 -
061416 -
061417 -
061418 -  ..
061419 - Safety Warning Vibration May Indicate Tire Failure
061420 -
061421 -   Page 5 in the warranty says...
061422 -
061423 -   Serious personal injury or death may result from a tire failure.
061424 -   Many tire failures are preceded by vibration, bumps, bulges or
061425 -   irregular wear.  If a vibration occurs while driving your vehicle or
061426 -   you notice a bump, bulge or irregular wear, have your tires and
061427 -   vehicle evaluated by a qualified service person.
061428 -
061429 -   This reflects experience on 950927. ref SDS 2 9640
061430 -
061431 -
061432 -  ..
061433 - Speed ratings Shown on Tires
061434 -
061435 -   Page 9 in the warranty says...
061436 -
061437 -   Some tires, bear a letter "speed rating" designation indicating the
061438 -   tire's design speed capability. ref OF 1 9477
061439 -
061440 -   A table shows "S" has a speed rating of 112 MPH. ref OF 1 2088
061441 -
061442 -   Explanation for reading speed rating information on the tires is
061443 -   explained. ref OF 1 6364
061444 -
061445 -
061446 -
061447 -  ..
061448 - Tire Service - Web Site Has Different Number
061449 -
061450 -
061451 -   Page 11 in the warranty says...
061452 -
061453 -   ...call the Technical Service Department. U.S.A.:
061454 -
061455 -
061456 -               1-800-367-3872 or write:
061457 -
061458 -        Customer Retention Services
061459 -        c/o Bridgestone/Firestone, Inc.
061460 -        2550 West Golf Road
061461 -        Rolling Meadows, IL  60008
061462 -
061463 -   ...as shown at ref OF 1 8034
061464 -
061465 -
061466 - However, the Firestone web site...
061467 -
061468 -
061469 -          http://www.firestone-usa.com/warranty/warr10.htm
061470 -
061471 -
061472 - ...gives a different phone number...
061473 -
061474 -
061475 -             1-800-356-4644 or Canada: 1-800-267-1318
061476 -
061477 -
061478 -
061479 - ..
061480 - Tire Registration
061481 - 
061482 -   Page 11 in the warranty says...
061483 -
061484 -   Registration of your tires is an important safety precation since it
061485 -   allows the manufacturer to notify you in the event of a recall. When
061486 -   you purchase replacement tires at THE STORE, we will register the
061487 -   tires for you. ref OF 1 8114
061488 -
061489 -   You need not register tires which come as original equipment on new
061490 -   vehicles, as the vehicle and the manufacturer handle this for you.
061491 -   ..
061492 -   The Firestone web site says the customer will receive from the
061493 -   tire dealer a registration card on which the tire serial numbers
061494 -   have been recorded.
061495 -
061496 -   Need tire serial numbers and registration submitted by S&C to
061497 -   Firestone. ref SDS 0 0030
061498 -
061499 -
061500 -
061501 -  ..
061502 - Supplemental Limited Mileage Warranty - Seems Repetitious
061503 -
061504 - There is a section beginning on page 13, ref OF 1 5893, that seems to
061505 - repeate information beginnong on page 1.
061506 -
061507 - S&C or Firestone need to explain what is supplemental protection?
061508 - is provided, and whether this is included on our tires.
061509 -
061510 -
061511 -  ..
061512 - Road Hazard Limited Warranty Option Not Purchased
061513 -
061514 - There is a section beginning on page 15, ref OF 1 4893, that explains
061515 - additional warranty coverage that can be purchased.
061516 -
061517 - Need price for Road Hazard Limited Warranty option.
061518 -
061519 - This section requires a stamp on page 16 to be valid, and there is no
061520 - stamp reflecting that we have not purchased the option.
061521 -
061522 -
061523 -  ..
061524 - Lifetime Wheel Balance Plan Not Purchased
061525 -
061526 - There is a section beginning on page 17, ref OF 1 2333, that explains
061527 - additional warranty coverage that can be purchased.
061528 -
061529 - Need price for Lifetime Wheel Balance Plan.
061530 -
061531 - This section requires a stamp on page 17 to be valid, and there is no
061532 - stamp reflecting that we have not purchased the option.
061533 -
061534 -
061535 -  ..
061536 - Lifetime Alignment Certificate Not Purchased
061537 -
061538 - There is a section beginning on page 18, ref OF 1 5553, that explains
061539 - additional warranty coverage that can be purchased.
061540 -
061541 - Need price for Lifetime Alignment Certificate.
061542 -
061543 - This section requires a stamp on page 18 to be valid, and there is no
061544 - stamp reflecting that we have not purchased the option.
061545 -
061546 -
061547 -  ..
061548 - Maintenance Record
061549 -
061550 - On the back of the manual, page 19, there is a form to record
061551 - maintenance history to support warranty claims, and as a reminder of
061552 - preventive maintenance. ref OF 1 7206
061553 -
061554 - There is a field for entering beginning mileage.  It is blank but the
061555 - figure is available on page 12, ref OF 1 0738, also shown above.
061556 - ref SDS 0 0483
061557 -
061558 - A question arises from the record on using the warranty on 990507,
061559 - whether S&c needs this form, or whether their regular service records
061560 - are sufficient to establish entitlement.
061561 -
061562 -
061563 -  ..
061564 - Vehicle Manufacturer's Recommended Tire Pressure, Lug Nut Torque
061565 -
061566 - On the back of the manual, page 19, there is a form to record
061567 - manufacturer's recommended tire pressure and lug nut torque; however,
061568 - this information is no entered. ref OF 1 2881
061569 -
061570 - Tire pressure and lug nut torque specs missing.
061571 -
061572 -
061573 -  ..
061574 - Firestone One Month Road Test Not Performed
061575 -
061576 - On the back of the manual, page 19, entitlement to a one month road
061577 - test of new tires is explained.  If the customer is not completely
061578 - satisfied the tires can be returned to the location from which the
061579 - tires were purchased within ONE MONTH of purchase for a full refund.
061580 -
061581 - The store is supposed to provide details on customer road test.
061582 - ref OF 1 3078
061583 -
061584 - Our record on 990507 shows that S&C did not provide details.
061585 - ref SDS 6 1782  This information was not available until today,
061586 - 991006, and so that should be the effective date of the test period.
061587 -
061588 -
061589 -
061590 -
061591 -
061592 -
061593 -
061594 -
061595 -
061596 -
0616 -
Distribution. . . . See "CONTACTS"