THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net


S U M M A R Y


DIARY: February 8, 2005 03:40 PM Tuesday; Rod Welch

Called Henry on visit with Doug Engelbart for 80th birthday party.

1...Summary/Objective
2...Visit to California Successful Funding for Fleabyte Not Approved
3...Organizational Memory in ASB Dispute SDS Unique Support
4...Dispute SDS Unique Support Organizational Memory in ASB
5...Study What Works Read POIMS 3 Times Discover Improved Reading
6...Ingenuity Gap Solution Fleabyte Homer-Dixon Contributor
7...Homer-Dixon Author Ingenuity Gap Contribute to Fleabyte
8...Education Target for Transformation High School Pilot Test


..............
Click here to comment!

CONTACTS 
0201 - Bootstrap Institute                                                                                                                                                O-00000735 0101
020101 - Mr. Douglas C. Engelbart, Ph.D.
0202 - Bootstrap Institute                                                                                                                                                O-00000735 0501
020201 - Mr. Henry van Eyken; Webmaster

SUBJECTS
Gracious Host Jack Successful Trip to Doug Engelbart's 80th Birthday
Financial Support Not Offered for Launching and Publishing Fleabyte
80th Birthday Party for Doug Invitation to Event Honoring Doug at SR
Eykan Henry Van Commended by Doug Engelbart During Cerimonies 80th B
Organizational Memory Objection SDS Unique Design Only Technololgy H

2107 -
2107 -    ..
2108 - Summary/Objective
2109 -
210901 - Follow up ref SDS 14 0000, ref SDS 12 0000.
210902 -
210903 -
210904 -
210905 -
210906 -
210907 -
210908 -
210910 -  ..
2110 -
2111 -
2112 - Progress
2113 -
211301 - Visit to California Successful Funding for Fleabyte Not Approved
211302 -
211303 - Henry enjoyed the visit to the Bay Area a week ago to attend Doug
211304 - Engelbart's 80th birthday tribute sponsored by SRI, and held on
211305 - 050129, shown by the invitation reported 050119. ref SDS 12 0001
211307 -  ..
211308 - Apparently, Doug paid for Henry's trip, which included business
211309 - meetings last week after the party for Doug at SRI on Saturday,
211310 - 050129.
211312 -  ..
211313 - Today, Henry was disappointed that no assurance of financial support
211314 - was given, but rather he was encouraged to commence publishing
211315 - Fleabyte for promoting civic journalism, per Henry's letter on 050110.
211316 - ref SDS 9 UQ9L  Henry's letter on 050112 presented plans to apply
211317 - Doug's ideas for an ABC improvement method for aiding augmented
211318 - thinking. ref SDS 10 OE9N  He cited the goal of improving education to
211319 - apply the "C" activity in Doug's ABC scheme. ref SDS 10 AJ7W
211321 -  ..
211322 - Jack Park was very gracious during Henry's visit by driving Henry to
211323 - various locations for meetings, and was supportive of Henry's goals
211324 - for Fleabyte, also, shown by Jack's letters on 050110, ref SDS 9 W83F,
211325 - and a few days later on 050112. ref SDS 10 W83F
211326 -
211327 -    [On 060905 Jack very gracious and professional with attribution to
211328 -    SDS. ref SDS 17 W34M
211330 -  ..
211331 - Doug, too, was gracious in singling Henry out during the cerimonies at
211332 - SRI for recognition supporting Doug's goals the past 5 years,
211333 - beginning in 2000.
211334 -
211335 -
211336 -
211337 -
211338 -
2114 -

SUBJECTS
Organizational Memory Objection SDS Unique Design Only Technololgy H
Editorial Memory SDS Support Publication of Fleabyte Favorably Appro

3404 -
340501 -  ..
340502 - Organizational Memory in ASB Dispute SDS Unique Support
340503 - Dispute SDS Unique Support Organizational Memory in ASB
340504 -
340505 - Follow up ref SDS 7 FO3H.
340506 -
340507 - Henry related today that his meetings in California last week with
340508 - both Doug and Jack seemed supportive of SDS.  He mentioned that Doug
340509 - was pleased by Henry's announcement on 050126 that SDS can be used for
340510 - editorial memory to publish Fleabyte. ref SDS 13 WI5O
340512 -  ..
340513 - Henry further indicated today that, during private meetings with Doug
340514 - last week, Henry cited SDS as the only product supporting the concept
340515 - of "organiztional memory," which is listed in the ASB at Boeing filed
340516 - on 040818, ref SDS 5 S69N, and later sent to Doug on 041027,
340517 - ref SDS 6 WF5U, and subsequently also submitted to Henry on 041221.
340518 - ref SDS 8 SQ6T  On 041110 SDS unique capabilities for intelligence
340519 - support were reviewed. ref SDS 7 FO3H  Henry had previously made this
340520 - observation in a letter dated 050117, and reviewed on 050118, but
340521 - which was not distributed to the group. ref SDS 11 MF5W
340523 -  ..
340524 - Henry gave the impression today that Doug was disappointed by Henry's
340525 - comment that "organizational memory" is currently only supported by
340526 - SDS.  Doug showed a paper or possibly several papers he had published
340527 - years ago that used this term.  During the call today, Henry seemed to
340528 - indicate that Doug did not demonstrate any technology that supports
340529 - organizational memory, as set out in the ASB citing POIMS, ref OF 5
340530 - 1101, and further in the NWO. ref OF 12 PWVQ  Henry explained today
340531 - having seen a demonstration of Doug's technology some years ago, and
340532 - did not report anything on organizational memory at that time.  On
340533 - this occassion, Doug did not further demonstrate support for
340534 - organizational memory
340547 -  ..
340548 - Doug may have drawn from Henry's comments, perhaps in combination with
340549 - the ASB defining a technology standard for "organizational memory,"
340550 - and which Doug received on 041027 along with a transmittal that, also,
340551 - mentions "organizational memory," ref SDS 6 MW6H, that Welch claims
340552 - rights of some kind to this phrase, and Doug disputes any such claims,
340553 - similar to Jack Park, who objected on 000403 to Welch having rights to
340554 - linking technology. ref SDS 2 W546
340556 -  ..
340557 - Today, I explained to Henry that Welch makes no claims on the term
340558 - "organizational memory," just as this was conveyed to Jack on 000403
340559 - regarding linking. ref SDS 2 W546  Both are generic terms in the
340560 - public domain, as noted previously on 041110. ref SDS 7 TV5K  The
340561 - record on 000403 explains that SDS support for "dynamic linking" in
340562 - conjunction with "organic subject structure" seems unique in the
340563 - literature.  At that time, Jack did not cite other technologies that
340564 - support this combination. ref SDS 2 W555
340566 -  ..
340567 - On 011210 Doug wrote a letter to Terry Windograd at Stanford saying
340568 - SDS has unique capabilities, which he did not specify. ref SDS 3 JL5I
340570 -  ..
340571 - In any case, POIMS explains a concept of personal and organizational
340572 - integrated memory and management, ref OF 3 6221, that describes SDS
340573 - functionality.  The POIMS concept and SDS support seem unique in the
340574 - literature and the technology industry.
340576 -  ..
340577 - Organizational memory was adopted as a simple "intellectual bridge"
340578 - for people to begin considering the larger concepts of intelligence
340579 - support and Communication Metrics, reported on 040615, ref SDS 4
340580 - Y55R, and this confirmed in a letter to the aerospace company.
340581 - ref SDS 4 R57R
340582 -
340583 -
340584 -
340585 -
340586 -
340587 -
3406 -

SUBJECTS
Default Null Subject Account for Blank Record

3503 -
350401 -  ..
350402 - Study What Works Read POIMS 3 Times Discover Improved Reading
350403 -
350404 - Follow up ref SDS 9 K98T.
350405 -
350406 - During the call today, we discussed Henry's letter on 050110
350407 - explaining his practice to read a book twice and make notes for
350408 - analysis in order to improve comprehension. ref SDS 9 K98T  We
350409 - discussed briefly analysis on 050110 showing that applying this
350410 - practice to POIMS would lead to better understanding of new ideas for
350411 - review in Fleabyte. ref SDS 9 XD6I
350413 -  ..
350414 - Henry seemd to say that he has read POIMS several times.
350416 -  ..
350417 - We further discussed today getting feedback from Henry's reading of
350418 - SDS foundational documents in the manner that Professor Ransdell
350419 - submitted, as discussed in the letter to Henry on 050118?  Without
350420 - feedback, there is no understanding and no progress.
350422 -  ..
350423 - Henry will respond on this point.
350424 -
350425 -
350426 -
350427 -
350428 -
350429 -
3505 -

SUBJECTS
Homer-Dixon Author Ingenuity Gap Contribute to Fleabyte Education Ta
Continual Learning Needs Continual Education Transformation to Cultu
New Way Thinking Education Continual Learning Homer-Dixon Author Ing
Continual Learning Root Cause Analysis Align Communication Objective
Analysis Hard Work Deliberative Analysis Not New Paul Teicholz Uses
Continual Learning Knowledge Deepens Broadens that Enables Enlighten

4908 -
490901 -  ..
490902 - Ingenuity Gap Solution Fleabyte Homer-Dixon Contributor
490903 - Homer-Dixon Author Ingenuity Gap Contribute to Fleabyte
490904 - Education Target for Transformation High School Pilot Test
490905 -
490906 - During the call today, Henry was pleased to announce that Thomas
490907 - Homer-Dixon, an author cited in Henry's letter on 050110, ref SDS 9
490908 - 4S4L, has recently indicated support for Fleabyte.  This may entail
490909 - contributing articles.
490911 -  ..
490912 - Henry explained plans to target students in high school for applying
490913 - augmented thinking, which Henry has set as the objective of Fleabyte.
490915 -  ..
490916 - As a result of Homer-Dixon's interest in Fleabyte, Henry has started
490917 - an article to explain opportunity and plans for improving education.
490918 - SDS may contribute for some students with stronger study practices
490919 - that synthesize reading, writing, and practice, discussed above.
490920 - ref SDS 0 FY9J
490921 -
490922 -     [On 050214 Henry submits article that proposes Fleabyte civic
490923 -     journalism to help solve ingenuity gap based on Doug Engelbart's
490924 -     ideas for CODIAK. ref SDS 16 01GA
490926 -  ..
490927 - We reviewed briefly the discussion with Morris yesterday along similar
490928 - lines, ref SDS 15 5F71, where the goal is to implement SDS support for
490929 - a new way of thinking and learning that integrates and synthesizes
490930 - traditionally separate tasks of reading and writing to make study and
490931 - analysis faster, easier with links to relevant sources and history,
490932 - developed on 950204. ref SDS 1 C257
490934 -  ..
490935 - Henry asked for the record of discussions with Morris to support his
490936 - article.
490937 -
490938 -
490939 -
490941 -  ..
4910 -
4911 -
4912 - 2117
491301 -  ..
491302 - Submitted ref DIT 1 0001 to Henry saying...
491303 -
491304 -    1.  Glad you had a productive and enjoyable trip to California for
491305 -        Doug's 80th birthday tribute at SRI a week ago on 050129.  With
491306 -        Jack Park playing gracious host, and Doug singling you out
491307 -        during the ceremonies for supporting his work, in addition to
491308 -        paying for your trip from Montreal (??), ref SDS 0 UI5O, this
491309 -        sounds like good progress on goals for civic journalism with
491310 -        Fleabyte. ref DIT 1 0001
491312 -         ..
491313 -    2.  In our discussion today, you described recent collaboration
491314 -        with Thomas Homer-Dixon, ref SDS 0 UA7N, who was mentioned in
491315 -        your correspondence a few weeks ago, ref DIT 1 OM6I, for a
491316 -        review you did on his book: "The Ingenuity Gap." ref SDS 9 4S4L
491318 -         ..
491319 -    3.  Today you explained that Mr. Homer-Dixon has expressed interest
491320 -        in contributing to Fleabyte on concepts of "augmented thinking"
491321 -        for learning at the high school level, and that you have
491322 -        already begun an article on this issue. ref DIT 1 CN7G
491324 -         ..
491325 -    4.  Well, "Birds of a feather...!" ref DIT 1 RN7M
491327 -         ..
491328 -    5.  I mentioned in our call today discussion along the same lines
491329 -        yesterday with Morris, who teaches graduate engineering at San
491330 -        Jose State college, and, also, works at Intel. ref DIT 1 2P8F
491331 -        Perhaps the record yesterday can help shape your article along
491332 -        with input from Homer-Dixon. ref SDS 15 5F71
491334 -         ..
491335 -    6.  As well, when time permits please follow up with professor
491336 -        Ransdell cited in the letter on January 27th (shown below).
491337 -        Today, you recalled reading the letter while travelling to
491338 -        California last week. ref DIT 1 TP9F  Joe's analysis of
491339 -        education, learning, and communication (referenced with links
491340 -        below) could make for lively collaborators on your article, and
491341 -        possibly lead to the kind of help you are seeking for managing
491342 -        and editing Fleabyte.
491344 -         ..
491345 -    7.  Again, glad you had a great visit with Doug and the gang.
491346 -        ref DIT 1 8Q9O
491348 -         ..
491349 -    8.  By copy to Morris, he can clarify his views, if needed.  Feel
491350 -        free to contact Morris directly for follow up.  He is always
491351 -        accommodating and helpful when possible.  Also, include Jack in
491352 -        the distribution, because of his interest and insights in
491353 -        learning issue, noted in correspondence last month. ref DIT 1
491354 -        00W2
491355 -
491356 -
491357 -
491358 -
491359 -
491360 -
491361 -
491362 -
491363 -
491364 -
491365 -
491366 -
491367 -
4914 -
Distribution. . . . See "CONTACTS"