THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net


S U M M A R Y


DIARY: February 5, 2001 10:01 AM Monday; Rod Welch

Alon Swartz called about contacting SRI to pilot test BrowseUp.

1...Summary/Objective
2...Meeting Requested to Discuss OHS Project Pilot Testing BrowseUp
3...SRI Hesitates About Pilot Testing BrowseUp
4...Open Source Excellent for Improving Technology
5...SDS Foundation for New Venture Based on Secret of KM


..............
Click here to comment!

CONTACTS 
0201 - BrowseUp                                                                                                                                                           O-00000776 0101
020101 - Mr. Alon Schwarz; President & CEO

SUBJECTS
Versioning Transclusion Links with Proxy Server, BrowseUp, Jack Park
SRI Linking Technology BrowseUp Demonstrated for OHS/DKR Project
Hyperscope Linking Presentation by Engineer from Israel
Links Added to Web Resources Produced by Others, 010122, BrowseUp
BrowseUp Supports Linking Needed for Hyperscope
Trial Pilot Testing by OHS/DKR
BrowseUp Testing by OHS/DKR, Alon Swartz
Dilemma Industry Doesn't Know How to Design KM

0810 -
0810 -    ..
0811 - Summary/Objective
0812 -
081201 - Follow up ref SDS 34 0000, ref SDS 32 0000.
081202 -
081203 - Alon Schwarz sent two letters requesting a meeting tomorrow to discuss
081204 - the OHS project.  He plans to be in town from his office in New York
081205 - for a few days, and wants to visit while he is here.  Talked to Alon
081206 - by phone.  He wants support to encourage SRI to pilot test BrowseUp,
081207 - and indicates frustration about decision making process.
081208 -
081209 -      [On 010214 submitted follow up to Alon. ref SDS 36 0001
081211 -       ..
081212 -      [On 010216 report SRI plans to develop Hyperscope independently
081213 -      from BrowseUp. ref SDS 37 H57L
081215 -  ..
0813 -
0814 -
0815 - Progress
081601 -  ..
081602 - Meeting Requested to Discuss OHS Project Pilot Testing BrowseUp
081603 -
081604 - Received ref DRT 1 0001 from Alon Schwarz who is CEO and co-founder of
081605 - BrowseUp, which he demonstrated to Doug's OHS team at SRI on 010122.
081606 - ref SDS 30 V2WR
081607 -
081608 -      Alon says in his letter he would like to meet to talk a bit about
081609 -      things, please let him know if I have time in the next two days.
081611 -  ..
081612 - Received a second letter, ref DRT 2 0001, saying....
081613 -
081614 -    I would like to meet you on the OHS. Will you have any time
081615 -    tomorrow?
081617 -  ..
081618 - These letters follow up....
081619 -
081620 -    1.  On 010128, ref DRP 5 0001, Alon plans to begin beta testing for
081621 -        BrowseUp at SRI. ref SDS 34 0001
081622 -
081623 -    2.  Report on 010127 that Doug is trying to install BrowseUp on his
081624 -        computer to pilot test BrowseUp. ref SDS 33 567F
081626 -         ..
081627 -        Doug feels BrowseUp can support OHS. ref SDS 33 4EWC
081629 -         ..
081630 -        Jack Park indicated BrowseUp is available for Open Source
081631 -        development for a payment of $5M. ref SDS 33 IP8M
081633 -         ..
081634 -        John Deneen indicates a combination of BrowseUp and SDS can
081635 -        advance OHS. ref SDS 33 ZQ7M
081637 -         ..
081638 -    3.  On 010125 Eugene Kim calls for testing BrowseUp. ref SDS 32
081639 -        C2WL
081640 -
081642 -  ..
081643 - Based on this background, sent a letter to Alon saying.....
081644 -
081645 -    I can meet tomorrow, but Wednesday would be better.  Possibly we
081646 -    can talk on the phone if there is a schedule conflict.  In any
081647 -    case, I would like a heads up on your agenda, so maybe a phone call
081648 -    would help.  My number is 415 781 5700.
081649 -
081650 - //
081651 -
0817 -

SUBJECTS
Counterintuitive Hyperscope Design Takes a Long Time to Discover for
BrowseUp Counterintuitive to Link Web Pages on Internet Takes Long Ti
Counterintuitive KM Design Architecture Human Thought Requires Experi
Counterintuitive New System Knowledge Conflicts Common Sense

1406 -
140701 -  ..
140702 - SRI Hesitates About Pilot Testing BrowseUp
140703 -
140704 -
1408 -
1409 - 1005
1410 -
1411 -
141102 -  ..
141103 - A few minutes after sending the above email, received a call from
141104 - Alon.
141106 -  ..
141107 - Alon explained having met several times with Doug, and he gave him a
141108 - CD to install BrowseUp on his computer for pilot testing.
141109 -
141110 -    This aligns with the report on 010127. ref SDS 33 567F
141112 -  ..
141113 - Alon got the impression at that time that Doug would support pilot
141114 - testing BrowseUp by SRI.
141116 -  ..
141117 - Recently, Doug has evidently indicated SRI is not taking up pilot
141118 - testing BrowseUp immediately, and may have in mind developing this
141119 - capability independently, using open source management methods, per
141120 - Doug's OHS Launch plan submitted on 001025. ref SDS 19 ADK1
141121 -
141122 -     This aligns with the report on 001017 that SRI plans to develop a
141123 -     better SDS program for knowledge management, using open source
141124 -     methods. ref SDS 18 9622
141125 - ..
141126 - Alon has related to Doug that it is difficult to create BrowseUp
141127 - technology; it takes a long time because the design is
141128 - counterintuitive.
141129 -
141130 -     On 990615 NSF was notified KM design counterintuitive, therefore
141131 -     government support justified, ref OF 3 4774, for research to
141132 -     demonstrate SDS has secret of KM. ref SDS 2 2808
141134 -      ..
141135 -     On 000608 counterintuitive design prevents programmers from
141136 -     discovering secret of KM. ref SDS 13 0452
141138 -      ..
141139 -     On 001004 OHS/DKR team was notified KM design is counterintuitive;
141140 -     hard to discover without experience using SDS.
141142 -      ..
141143 -     On 001127 letter to Eric Armstrong on Doug's OHS/DKR team advised
141144 -     that if the team does not use SDS as a template for developing KM,
141145 -     then they must be prepared for along development process that will
141146 -     require starting over many times to gain enough experience for
141147 -     discovering the secret of KM. ref SDS 23 TH9O
141149 -      ..
141150 -     On 001121 proposed OHS/DKR team gain experience using SDS to learn
141151 -     how to design KM, because KM is counterintuitive. ref SDS 21 XU8I
141153 -      ..
141154 -     On 001206 letter, ref DIP 2 0001, cites IBM's experience with
141155 -     their KM project failing shows KM is difficult, requires
141156 -     experience using SDS. ref SDS 24 0001
141158 -  ..
141159 - Alon is concerned that pilot testing BrowseUp seems more difficult
141160 - than indicated by Doug's initial reception, and subsequent
141161 - demonstration at SRI on 010122. ref SDS 30 CP7I
141162 -
141163 -     Alon's report appears to conflict to some degree with Doug's call
141164 -     for pilot testing of new ideas in his 1992 paper, which he cited
141165 -     on 991222 as the guiding principles of the OHS/DKR effort.
141166 -     ref SDS 3 5402
141168 -      ..
141169 -     On 001025 Doug's OHS Launch plan requires pilot testing tools like
141170 -     BrowseUp. ref SDS 19 S57K
141172 -      ..
141173 -     On 010111 Doug planned to support pilot testing SDS by SRI.
141174 -     ref SDS 28 N85H
141176 -      ..
141177 -     On 000829 Pat Lincoln reported that Curt Carlson prefers that SRI
141178 -     develop ideas internally. ref SDS 16 SY5F
141180 -  ..
141181 - Alon requested ideas for expediting review by SRI?
141183 -  ..
141184 - Suggested.....
141185 -
141186 -     1.  Jim Spohrer introduced BrowseUp to Doug, and so evidently
141187 -         thinks highly of this opportunity.
141188 -
141189 -         Jim has a good relationship with Doug, and so might be willing
141190 -         to discuss with Doug ideas for moving ahead to pilot test
141191 -         BrowseUp, based on Jim's reputation in the industry.
141192 -
141193 -            [On 010211 Jim's biography and background show he could be
141194 -            a strong voice to assist BrowseUp. ref SDS 35 04YW
141196 -          ..
141197 -     2.  Pat Lincoln is the Director of Computer Science at SRI.  He
141198 -         has a strong desire to develop technology for improving
141199 -         collaboration, reported on 010111. ref SDS 27 EF6M  Pat has
141200 -         been a fair and honest broker getting new ideas considered,
141201 -         and so could be contacted about helping Doug complete review
141202 -         of BrowseUp toward starting a Pilot Test.
141204 -          ..
141205 -         Pat's contact information is....
141206 -
141207 -               650 859 5454
141208 -
141209 -               Lincoln@csl.sri.com
141210 -

141211 -               http://www.csl.sri.com/~lincoln/
141213 -      ..
141214 -     [On 010214 Alon is working on getting some open api's for SRI to
141215 -     use BrowseUp. ref SDS 36 KJ2H
141216 -
141217 -
141218 - //
141219 -
141220 -
141221 -
1413 -

SUBJECTS
Schwarz, Alon, BrowseUp
Management Cannot Make Assignments
Poor Management Do Something Even If Wrong Open Source Empowerment
Arguments About License and Ownership
VC Finance for SDS KM Project
BrowseUp, Alon Schwarz Provide VC for SDS KM Project
Design Technology Breakthroughs Not Conducive to Open Source
BrowseUp Alon Schwarz Reviewing SDS for VC Support

2210 -
221101 -  ..
221102 - Open Source Excellent for Improving Technology
221103 - SDS Foundation for New Venture Based on Secret of KM
221104 -
221105 - Alon indicated that getting government funding for an OHS project is
221106 - not an efficient method for expediting progress.
221107 -
221108 - He noted that open source development is excellent for implementing
221109 - and advancing new technology, but is less effective for developing
221110 - core technologies.
221111 -
221112 -    This aligns with background on 000426 showing open source
221113 -    developers are not attracted, motivated nor can they be directed to
221114 -    perform work to develop a new concept, ref SDS 9 1404; and further
221115 -    aligns with planning on 000503 for SDS to support open source
221116 -    development of DKR based on SDS core design. ref SDS 10 6903
221118 -  ..
221119 - Alon will review Welch tools and theory for KM implemented by SDS and
221120 -
221121 -
221122 -                     Communication Metrics
221123 -
221124 -
221125 -           http://www.welchco.com
221126 -
221128 -       ..
221129 -      [On 010214 submitted follow up to Alon. ref SDS 36 VNE4
221130 -
221131 -
221132 -
221133 -
221134 -
221135 -
2212 -
Distribution. . . . See "CONTACTS"