THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net


S U M M A R Y


DIARY: March 26, 1996 09:20 AM Tuesday; Rod Welch

Received call from PMI Publications re NWO article.

1...Summary/Objective
2...Case Law, Regulation & PMBOK
3...Asilomar Event Article
4...Project World PMI Dinner Meeting
......Asilomar Survey of Support Managers Need
......Asilomar Post Event Article
5...Risk Management Study Analysis, Author's Response
6...Authority of Project Manager, PMP Certification
7...PMBOK & ISO 10006 Correlations
8...PMI Has Edits on NWO... Paper that Require Expedited Review
....................There is not enough time
9...Communication Manager
.....Haste Makes Waste
.....PMI Cannot Apply PMBOK

ACTION ITEMS.................. Click here to comment!

1...Jim will search for people to do this column. We considered a

CONTACTS 
0201 - PMI Communications                                                                                                                                                 O-00000095 0108
0202 - PMI Communications                                                                                                                                                 O-00000095 0109
020201 - Ms. Jeannette Cabais; News Editor

SUBJECTS
PMI Monthly meetings
Review published legal cases
Respond PMI Articles
PMI Publications Review Case Law
Advertising, July Event
Survey of Attendees

1108 -
1108 -    ..
1109 - Summary/Objective
1110 -
111001 - Follow up ref SDS 23 0000, ref SDS 21 0000.
111002 -
111003 - Jim called in response to ref DIP 1 9444 submitted in the record on
111004 - 960125, ref SDS 15 8843, and earlier discussions at Project World,
111005 - confirmed in the letter, ref DIP 3 0000, submitted on 951231.
111006 - ref SDS 12 0000, and relating our discussion at Project World PMI
111007 - meeting on 951214. ref SDS 10 0032
111009 -  ..
111010 - There has been no response to questions on the Risk Managemnet
111011 - article.  I suggested Jim publish the questions.  I will submit the
111012 - name of David Buoncristiani for a panel of lawyers to address the
111013 - question of sound management practice.  I will submit an article on
111014 - the Asilomar Conference for publication in the June PMNETwork.
111015 -
111016 -    [Did this last point at ref SDS 31 line 114.]
111017 -
111018 -
111019 -
111021 -  ..
1111 -
1112 -
1113 - Discussion
1114 -
111401 - After I spoke to Jeannett about the NWO paper, I asked to talk to Jim.
111403 -  ..
111404 - He said he has been sick and is still not 100%.
111406 -  ..
111407 - I mentioned that it seems like a lot of people have been sick this
111408 - year for some strange reason, and related the experience trying to
111409 - coordinate with Intel where David Vannier got pneumonia, reported on
111410 - 960229. ref SDS 20 9999
111412 -  ..
111413 - I mentioned the challenge of doing analysis, as reflected in our
111414 - discussion today.  We considered breifly the letter to David that in
111415 - order to figure out how to work faster, we have to slow down, per
111416 - ref DIP 2 0034 and ref DIP 2 0034, submitted on 960223.  ..
111421 - Case Law, Regulation & PMBOK
111422 -
111423 - PMI publications can review case law and regulations for consistency
111424 - with sound management practice in the PMBOK, for the reasons in my
111425 - letter to Jim at ref DIP 3 9332.
111426 -
111427 -     Jim said there are occassional reviews of the law in PMI
111428 -     publications.  I explained these efforts typically report what was
111429 -     decided, but do not consider how the cases align with sound
111430 -     management practice, and whether PMBOK needs to be adjusted, or
111431 -     whether the law should be adjusted.
111433 -      ..
111434 -     Jim will search for people to do this column.  We considered a
111435 -     panel comprised of a few lawyers, public works executives, say
111436 -     from the Corps of Engineers, the Navy, private industry such as
111437 -     Bechtal, and the AGC.  There should be geographical diversity to
111438 -     accomodate evolution in various jurisdictions.  Jim is considering
111439 -     developing a research effort within acadamia.  This section would
111440 -     be a good place to report on that research.
111441 -
111443 -  ..
111444 - Asilomar Event Article
111445 - Project World PMI Dinner Meeting
111446 -
111447 - Follow up ref SDS 14 line 112, and ref SDS 25 line 149.
111448 -
111449 - We considered the objective of an article to draw executives to attend
111450 - Asilomar.  The article needs language that speaks to the executive
111451 - mindset, i.e., the desire to work by conversation, ref SDS 19 2004,
111452 - and the lack of time to read and write, which results in nobody being
111453 - prepared for their work, ref SDS 22 6870.
111454 -
111455 -     [See follow up at ref SDS 31 9442.]
111457 -  ..
111458 - I explained the challenges Bill has encountered working with the PMI
111459 - Committee on finalizing an agenda and speakers, ref SDS 26 6683.
111461 -  ..
111462 - We recognized the correlations between the quality of performance and
111463 - decisions, and the impact of time in the management environement,
111464 - similar to Jim's efforts to get the NWO paper edited, discussed below.
111465 - ref SDS 0 8534
111467 -  ..
111468 - Jim commented that dealing with PMI committees who are volunteers with
111469 - other interests and limited time, presents significant management
111470 - challenges.
111472 -  ..
111473 - Jim said PMI Communications plans to run some advertisements that will
111474 - publicize the Asilomar Conference.  I did not ask him about these
111475 - plans.
111477 -  ..
111478 - We discussed the advantage of a specific article in addition to an ad,
111479 - to draw the correlation between the Project World Event, Asilomar and
111480 - the New World Order paper under the theme Leaderhsip and Technology.
111481 -
111482 -      One approach would be for us to submit the planning that has been
111483 -      done so far, including the speakers and scope, and Jim can then
111484 -      fashion an article, per analysis at ref SDS 16 line 81, ref SDS
111485 -      17 line 161.
111486 -
111487 -          [Ultimately, did not do this.  Submitted the actual agenda
111488 -          and an article on the correlation with the NWO paper and
111489 -          recent articles on downsizing, ref SDS 31 line 129, pluss I
111490 -          included quote from General Hatch, ref SDS 31 line 270.]
111491 -
111493 -       ..
111494 -      Asilomar Survey of Support Managers Need
111495 -
111496 -      I mentioned the idea of a survey form that could be included to
111497 -      obtain input for the Asilomar event in defining a new management
111498 -      science, new work role and support managers feel they need to be
111499 -      more effective, per analysis at ref SDS 24 line 489.
111501 -       ..
111502 -      Jim requested that I draft an article and proposed survey form,
111503 -      and submit this background.
111505 -       ..
111506 -      He needs it by the end of next week, so it can be published in
111507 -      the June issue which will be mailed to members on May 23.  This
111508 -      timing is adequate to provide notice for the people we want to
111509 -      encourage to attend.
111510 -
111511 -         [See follow up at ref SDS 31 line 139.]
111513 -  ..
111514 - I advised I am meeting with Bill DeHart this morning and then Intel
111515 - later today on the event, so we can figure out what action to take on
111516 - these ideas about an article on Asilomar and survey for speaker input.
111517 -
111518 -          [See follow up with Bill at ref SDS 26 line 119.]
111519 -
111521 -       ..
111522 -      Asilomar Post Event Article
111523 -
111524 -      Jim said he will be attending the Asilomar event and so he can
111525 -      report on the results.
111526 -
111527 -
111529 -  ..
111530 - Risk Management Study Analysis, Author's Response
111531 -
111532 - Followed up work at ref SDS 14 line 129.
111533 -
111534 - Jim said PMI has not heard from the author of the article.
111535 -
111536 - We considered that an appropriate course would be for PMI to publish
111537 - the analysis at ref SDS 8 line 99, and editorialize on the the impact
111538 - of time in exacerbating the risks of inadequate communications, as
111539 - described in the original article.  The editorial can request comments
111540 - from the membership on dealing with the time/information continuum
111541 - which will be treated at Asilomar.
111542 -
111543 -
111545 -  ..
111546 - Authority of Project Manager, PMP Certification
111547 -
111548 - Followed up discussion at ref SDS 14 line 151.
111549 -
111550 -    Jim said he has submitted the SDS record to PMI members working on
111551 -    the issue, but has not heard back.  He has not had time to follow
111552 -    up.  This reflects the challenge of volunteer committee work
111553 -    discussed above with respect to the Asilomar event.
111555 -     ..
111556 -    We considered follow up for Jim to simply publish an editorial on
111557 -    the issue to spur dialog for input into the PMI folks thinking
111558 -    about the direction and future of PMI.  This effort cannot be
111559 -    undertaken too soon.  Attendance at monthly meetings at NCC seems
111560 -    to be down sharply, and this presages a drop in membership,
111561 -    especially as more downsizing occurs.
111562 -
111563 -
111565 -  ..
111566 - PMBOK & ISO 10006 Correlations
111567 -
111568 - Followed up discussion at ref SDS 14 line 172.
111569 -
111570 - We considered how this matter will be an aspect of the Asilomar event
111571 - as described in the NWO paper.  The article we submit will reflect
111572 - this idea, ref OF 2 line 45.
111573 -
111574 -    [Did this at ref SDS 31 line 145.]
111575 -
111576 -
111577 -
1116 -

SUBJECTS
New World Order needs old time religion
Time - Too Busy Being Busy
Haste Makes Waste
PMBOK, Apply Consistently with Technology
Management productivity, Needs Integration
Museum, Communication Manager Takes
Bumbling Comedy of Errors, Guess Gossip

2609 -
261001 -  ..
261002 - PMI Has Edits on NWO... Paper that Require Expedited Review
261003 -
261004 - Follow up ref SDS 13 0000, ref SDS 15 0000.
261005 -
261006 - Talked to Jeannette Cabanis.
261008 -  ..
261009 - She said the original work ref OF 1 1055 rambled and used a
261010 - conversational tone that required rework to conform with professional
261011 - standards for publication by PMI.
261012 -
261013 -      I did not mention Jim's observation on 951026 that he liked the
261014 -      article very much. ref SDS 6 9932  I also did not ask if others
261015 -      found the article hard to follow, because many have indicated
261016 -      that the new ideas in the piece are difficult.  By definition new
261017 -      ideas are difficult.  Few could follow the theory of relativity
261018 -      when it was first published.
261020 -  ..
261021 - Jeanette has edited the article to 5,000 words and created headnotes
261022 - per understandings with Jim on 951214, ref SDS 10 0032, and previously
261023 - on 951226. ref SDS 6 9932
261025 -  ..
261026 - Jeannett wants to fax her ideas on the NWO paper for my comments.
261028 -  ..
261029 - I asked her to send me a disk.
261031 -  ..
261032 - She said there is not enough time for the mail.  They need to finalize
261033 - the article by tomorrow.
261034 -
261035 -      [On 960430 another example of bumbling mistakes by "expediting"
261036 -      notice on Asilomar agenda. ref SDS 32 7008]
261037 -
261038 -      [On 960405 Jeannette has article in April PMnetwork, ref SDS 29
261039 -      9604, explaining advantages of PM career.]
261041 -       ..
261042 -      [On 050411 received request for article within 3 days for
261043 -      publication in PMNetwork on business intelligence. ref SDS 34
261044 -      L25K
261046 -  ..
261047 - I indicated suprise about the apparent emergency notification of
261048 - changes to the paper PMI has had since last August.
261050 -  ..
261051 - Jeanette said she has had the paper only for the past 10 days.
261053 -  ..
261054 - I explained a fax is not an efficient medium to facilitate the work
261055 - PMI is requesting, and further in conflicts with practices being
261056 - presented in the article.  I asked if she can zip the file she
261057 - prepared for the article, and send it via the Internet?
261059 -  ..
261060 - Jeannett will do this, and will also fax a hard copy to Millie in case
261061 - the internet thing crashes, as often happens.  I will review it
261062 - tonight after returning from the meeting with Intel; I will try to
261063 - submit comments tomorrow in time to meet PMI's publication deadline.
261065 -  ..
261066 - I asked to talk to Jim.
261067 -
261069 -  ..
261070 - Talked to Jim.
261072 -  ..
261073 - Jim says that his team is on a tight deadline; he confirmed they have
261074 - to finalize the article by tomorrow.  He did not indicate if he has
261075 - read the revised work performed by Jeannette, since on 951026 Jim
261076 - indicated he liked the original very much, ref SDS 6 9932.
261078 -                     ..
261079 -                    There is not enough time
261080 -
261081 -    ...to submit PMI's proposed changes in the NWO article and the
261082 -    reasons for them so they can be analysed and treated in a careful
261083 -    manner to ensure good ideas are integrated into the work, and
261084 -    erroneous ones are corrected.
261086 -     ..
261087 -    This challenge is particularly acute where PMI is publishing
261088 -    introduction to a new management science that is outside everyone's
261089 -    experience.
261091 -  ..
261092 - We considered the irony of an article on better time and information
261093 - management for which there is not enough time to adequately analyse
261094 - the information, i.e., to connect it up to create knowledge, per
261095 - Jeanette's email. ref DRT 1
261096 -
261097 -     [On 960412 received thank you letter from PMI. ref SDS 30 0001
261099 -      ..
261100 -     [On 960418 received actual article published in the May issue.
261101 -     ref SDS 33 0001
261102 -
261104 -  ..
261105 - Communication Manager
261106 -
261107 - This record supports the NWO thesis that the central challenge of the
261108 - New World Order is the tension between using summary methods due to
261109 - constant information, and mistakes this causes that degrades
261110 - management productivity under Drucker's rule cited in the paper.
261111 - ref OF 9 0664  Poor work reduces earnings, leading to more
261112 - downsizing, which leads to worse work -- the implosion described in
261113 - the paper.  The role of communication manager and technology is to
261114 - meet the challenge of timely notice in order to apply PMBOK practices
261115 - of aligning communications to accomplish productive work.
261116 -
261117 -         [On 960405 irony PMnetwork publishes article on taking time to
261118 -         check accuracy, essential to avoid the cost of rework to
261119 -         correct mistakes. ref SDS 29 F15U
261121 -          ..
261122 -         [On 960405 same issue of PMnetwork reports downsizing by
261123 -         cutting cost of project managers, perhaps because they did not
261124 -         take time to check their work, and so cost overruns led to
261125 -         cost cutting. ref SDS 29 0300
261126 -
261128 -      ..
261129 -     Haste Makes Waste
261130 -     PMI Cannot Apply PMBOK
261131 -
261132 -     I explained the meeting we are having today with Chips &
261133 -     Technologies and Intel to help them shape their presentations at
261134 -     Asilomar to address the issues in the NWO paper.  If I had been
261135 -     notified of PMI's interest in changing the article last week, this
261136 -     effort could have been incorporated into the work flow so it
261137 -     received the attention PMI Communication's ideas deserve.  Now we
261138 -     are forced to hurry.  Haste makes waste!  I cannot address PMI's
261139 -     concerns until tonight, when I am tired.  This seems to conflict
261140 -     with PMBOK strictures to apply sound management practice.
261142 -          ..
261143 -         [On 960419 letter to PMI Comm applies anomoly on not having
261144 -         enough time and money to avoid mistakes, causing delays and
261145 -         cost overruns. ref SDS 31 0001
261147 -  ..
261148 - We reviewed similarities in the record on editing the NWO article,
261149 - with work on the PMI Committee, at Chips, Intel, Turner, per letter to
261150 - Intel, ref DIP 2 0001, issued on 960223 and citing the challenge of
261151 - the ages -- nobody has time to think. ref SDS 18 JZ6M
261153 -  ..
261154 - Everyone wants to be notified of problems but nobody makes it to the
261155 - museum. There is not enough time in the New World Order.
261157 -  ..
261158 - I suggested the value of the PMBOK is to provide cultural inertia for
261159 - people to slow down long enough to succeed faster.
261161 -  ..
261162 - I will request PMI's analysis of the NWO paper for careful comments at
261163 - a later date, per Fran Webster's suggestions in his letter, received
261164 - on 941006. ref SDS 1 0000
261165 -
261166 -     What I am wondering is that in order to decide to publish, someone
261167 -     had to read the paper.  This evidently disclosed merit and a
261168 -     rambling conversational tone, cited by Jeanneatte. ref SDS 0 1470
261169 -
261170 -        [On 960403 General Hatch, Commander, USACE, Ret reported he
261171 -        read the NWO three (3) times in order to understand how to add
261172 -        intelligence support for management. ref SDS 28 5592
261174 -      ..
261175 -     Someone else must have been asked to read the paper again for a
261176 -     second opinion, under the reasoning Fran Webster cites that it
261177 -     takes awhile for the ideas in the NWO paper to sink in,
261178 -     ref DRP 1 0001  These readings likley raised questions, e.g., "I
261179 -     don't understand this, I don't understand that.  This does not
261180 -     seem connected.  That seems rambling."  Why could not these
261181 -     markings and concerns have been submitted 4 or 5 months ago, or 4
261182 -     or 5 weeks ago, or 4 or 5 days ago?
261183 -
261184 -
261185 -
261186 -
2612 -
261201 -
2613 -

SUBJECTS
PMI Articles in Publications
New World Order needs old time religion

2904 -
2905 - 2028 received PMI Com version of NWO
290601 -  ..
290602 - Millie delivered the fax and I downloaded the zip file via internet.
290604 -  ..
290605 - Jeanette's email asks for my bio, but it seems to be attached to the
290606 - fax.
290607 -
290608 -     Jeanette's file is a Word document, ref OF 5 line 30.
290609 -
290610 -     I created the file ref OF 6 line 30 to create a revision file
290611 -     showing the changes I was able to identify over night.
290613 -      ..
290614 -     The next day, I created a separate file, ref OF 7 line 30 that has
290615 -     the final version of what I returned to PMI.  I actually returned
290616 -     ref OF 6 line 30, so they can see the revisions.
290617 -
290619 -  ..
290620 - The main problem is that the flow has been so changed that I do not
290621 - have a good feel for the conceptual development and transitions of the
290622 - material in the newly proposed form.
290624 -  ..
290625 - I have spent about 6 hours working with individual pieces.  This has
290626 - not been enough time to analyse what has been removed.  There is
290627 - considerable redundancy, which seems to occur because the removed
290628 - portions no longer require linking back to the primary concepts.
290630 -  ..
290631 - The back page needs a lot more work.  There is too much repetition of
290632 - certain phrases.  Will have to do it tomorrow; I cannot think clearly
290633 - anymore now.
290634 -
290635 -    [On 960327 submitted comments on PMI's proposed edits to NWO.
290636 -    ref SDS 27 0001
290637 -
290638 -
290639 -
290640 -
290641 -
290642 -
290643 -
290644 -
2907 -
Distribution. . . . See "CONTACTS"