THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net


S U M M A R Y


DIARY: September 27, 2004 10:24 AM Monday; Rod Welch

SDS thinking through writing supported by writing to learn.

1...Summary/Objective
2...WAC Definition Writing to Learn
3...Writing to Learn Definition WAC
4...Thinking Through Writing Supports POIMS Theory of Analysis

ACTION ITEMS.................. Click here to comment!

1...Many of the tips are inherent using SDS, as shown by this record and

CONTACTS 

SUBJECTS
Capture Record Improves Knowledge Management Organizational Memory
WAC Definition Writing to Learn Thinking Through Writing Supports PO
Thinking through Writing Intelligence Integrates Time Information Cr
Intelligence Genius Thinking Improved by SDS Automated Integration T

1006 -
1006 -    ..
1007 - Summary/Objective
1008 -
100801 - Follow up ref SDS 7 6F4I.
100802 -
100803 - Received ref DRT 1 0001 from Gary, and he called to further explain
100804 - his letter today has support showing others have grasped the concept
100805 - of thinking through writing enabled by SDS, and explained in POIMS.
100806 - ref OF 7 3742  This research further supports the recent addition of
100807 - an outline in NWO on "intelligence" support that leverages ability to
100808 - think, remember, and communicate. ref SDS 7 456O
100810 -  ..
100811 - Gary's letter says...
100812 -
100813 -    1.  Google searches on "learning through writing" and "writing to
100814 -        learn" turn up some interesting results including a book I have
100815 -        started to read but not completed, "Writing To Learn" by
100816 -        William Zinsser. ref DRT 1 0001
100818 -            ..
100819 -           http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0062720406/103-7380595-0533419?v=glance#product-details
100821 -  ..
100822 - Examining this location shows a review of Zinseer's book, but does not
100823 - directly say anything about "thinking through writing" either
100824 - expressly or conceptually.  The review commends the book for tips on
100825 - clear, stylish writing by relying on accuracy, brevity, and clarity.
100827 -  ..
100828 - Gary continues...
100829 -
100830 -    2.  The WAC Journal, a national peer-reviewed journal on writing across the
100831 -        curriculum
100832 -
100833 -           http://wac.colostate.edu/journal/
100835 -  ..
100836 - This location does not seem to have anything directly on point, but
100837 - lists a number of sources which may have caught Gary's attention.
100838 -
100839 -
100841 -  ..
100842 - WAC Definition Writing to Learn
100843 - Writing to Learn Definition WAC
100844 - Thinking Through Writing Supports POIMS Theory of Analysis
100845 -
100846 - Follow up ref SDS 5 8854, ref SDS 2 3443.
100847 -
100848 - Gary continues with a reference to a web site that appears to be
100849 - sponsored by Colorado State under a WAC Journal that is part of a WAC
100850 - Clearinghouse.  WAC...
100852 -                   ..
100853 -                  Writing Across the Curriculum
100855 -  ..
100856 - The WAC Clearinghouse brings together five journals, four books
100857 - series, and resources for teachers who use writing in their courses.
100858 - The site is open to all, but please consider joining the
100859 - Clearinghouse and contributing to the community by helping to build
100860 - this site.
100862 -  ..
100863 - Gary's letter comments...
100864 -
100865 -    3.  A Fuller Definition of Writing to Learn
100866 -
100867 -           http://wac.colostate.edu/intro/pop4a.cfm
100869 -  ..
100870 - This site says in part...
100871 -
100872 -        Although how writing fosters critical thinking is not clear
100873 -        (Applebee), theoreticians and practitioners alike agree that
100874 -        writing promotes both critical thinking and learning (See
100875 -        Adams, Britton, Bruner, Emig, Herrington, Knoblauch and
100876 -        Brannon, Odell, Parker on the linked bibliography.) As Toby
100877 -        Fulwiler and Art Young explain in their "Introduction" to
100878 -        Language Connections: Writing and Reading Across the
100879 -        Curriculum:
100880 -
100881 -            Writing to communicate--or what James Britton calls
100882 -            "transactional writing"--means writing to accomplish
100883 -            something, to inform, instruct, or persuade. . . .  Writing
100884 -            to learn is different. We write to ourselves as well as
100885 -            talk with others to objectify our perceptions of reality;
100886 -            the primary function of this "expressive" language is not
100887 -            to communicate, but to order and represent experience to
100888 -            our own understanding. In this sense language provides us
100889 -            with a unique way of knowing and becomes a tool for
100890 -            discovering, for shaping meaning, and for reaching
100891 -            understanding. (p. x)
100893 -  ..
100894 - The language above aligns well with POIMS explanation of think,
100895 - remember and communciation, listen and learn. ref OF 7 3742  Analysis
100896 - on 890809, ref SDS 1 9Y5I, Peter Drucker's view of analysis, shown on
100897 - 931130, ref SDS 4 4966, and extensive feedback from professional
100898 - writers on 930112. ref SDS 2 9405  Further, 20 years experience using
100899 - SDS shows that traditional methods common to professional writers are
100900 - significantly strengthened under the POIMS design. ref OF 7 3773
100902 -  ..
100903 - Gary's letter continues...
100904 -
100905 -    4.  Writing to Learn with Learning Logs
100906 -
100907 -           http://www.glencoe.com/sec/teachingtoday/weeklytips.phtml/54
100909 -  ..
100910 - This location has a number of writing tips to enhance learning.  There
100911 - is no evident direct support for the expression "thinking through
100912 - learning," nor conceptually that writing leveages intelligence.
100914 -  ..
100915 - Many of the tips are inherent using SDS, as shown by this record and
100916 - the references that support the work today.  This might be an area
100917 - where SDS could be sold to students to implement study practices.  The
100918 - reason students would not want to do this flows from the fact they
100919 - only need to remember material long enough to take a test.  While
100920 - knowledge is organic supported by the SDS design, this is not evident
100921 - to students, nor to most teachres, except perhaps in the sciences.
100923 -  ..
100924 - Connecting understandings with ability to track back to reasoning that
100925 - solved prior problems, might be useful in some academics.
100927 -  ..
100928 - Why not notify WAC about opportunity to implement good practices
100929 - consistently?
100931 -  ..
100932 - Gary continues...
100933 -
100934 -    5.  Writing Across the Curriculum and Writing in the Disciplines,
100935 -        with numerous resource links
100936 -
100937 -           http://owl.english.purdue.edu/handouts/WAC/
100939 -  ..
100940 - This location says in part...
100941 -
100942 -        Writing to Learn
100944 -         ..
100945 -        This particular approach to WAC frequently makes use of
100946 -        journals, logs, microthemes, and other, primarily informal,
100947 -        writing assignments.  If they write reactions in their own
100948 -        words to information received in class or from reading,
100949 -        students often comprehend and retain information better.  Also,
100950 -        because students write more frequently, they either maintain or
100951 -        improve their writing skills and avoid a decrease in writing
100952 -        ability from entrance to senior year.
100954 -  ..
100955 - This is all true; why though is there nothing about getting the
100956 - teacher to keep a log, the principal, the CEO, the engineer, etc.  Why
100957 - is comprehension and retention only useful for students?
100959 -  ..
100960 - Analysis on 991108 explains that memory is important to students
100961 - because they get rewarded with grades based on performance.  The CEO
100962 - gets paid without accurate memory and comprehension. ref SDS 6 7520
100964 -  ..
100965 - Gary continues...
100966 -
100967 -    6.  Teaching Reasoning Through Writing
100968 -
100969 -           http://www.gse.uci.edu/nbc/portfolioshtml/jonstrebler/Entry1.html
100971 -  ..
100972 - This site generally supports the concept of thinking through writing;
100973 - there is nothing specific that asserts the proposition, as shown at a
100974 - couple of the other sites, per above. ref SDS 0 5G42
100976 -  ..
100977 - Gary concludes...
100978 -
100979 -    7.  That's enough to make the point that writing as a means of
100980 -        learning, fostering thinking and reasoning, and in general
100981 -        promoting grasp of material is a rather well known concept at
100982 -        the university level. It is far from universal, but it seems to
100983 -        be widespread. ref DRT 1 ES9K
100985 -  ..
100986 - There is no evidence that the "widespread concept" is also widely
100987 - practiced, particularly on the job, for reasons in the record on
100988 - 991108. ref SDS 6 YO62
100989 -
100990 -
100991 -
100992 -
100993 -
100994 -
100995 -
1010 -