THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net
S U M M A R Y
DIARY: August 3, 2003 07:08 AM Sunday;
Rod Welch
Gary submits analysis of SDS benefits hidden in plain sight.
1...Summary/Objective
..............
Click here to comment!
CONTACTS
0201 - Boeing O-00000816 0505
020101 - Mr. Garold L. Johnson
020103 - Modeling and Simulation O-00000816 0505
SUBJECTS
Benefits Advantages Hidden in Plan Sight by Fog of Daily Information
0603 -
0603 - ..
0604 - Summary/Objective
0605 -
060501 - Follow up ref SDS 4 LV8G.
060502 -
060503 - Received an email from Gary saying...
060504 -
060505 - 1. Subject: SDS Barriers to acceptance
060506 - Date: Sat, 2 Aug 2003 14:48:16 -0700
060507 - From: "Garold \(Gary\) L. Johnson"
060508 - To: "Rod Welch"
060510 - ..
060511 - 2. Rod,
060512 -
060513 - Please see my record at
060514 -
060515 - http://www.welchco.com/sd/08/GLJDY/02/03/08/02/073004.HTM
060517 - ..
060518 - 3. I wanted to get this to you sooner than my next update
060519 - (sometime this weekend).
060521 - ..
060522 - 4. It is still rough, but I feel pretty good about parts of it.
060524 - ..
060525 - 5. I also wanted to make sure I still remembered how to publish to
060526 - the web<g>.
060528 - ..
060529 - Thanks,
060531 - ..
060532 - Gary
060533 -
060535 - ..
060536 - Gary's record provides intellectual bridges showing how SDS advances
060537 - traditional practices using diaries and documents.
060539 - ..
060540 - Submitted a reponse saying....
060541 -
060542 - a. Subject: SDS Acceptance to Augment Intelligence
060543 - Date: Sun, 03 Aug 2003 06:10:52 -0700
060544 - From: Rod Welch
060545 - To: "Garold (Gary) L. Johnson"
060546 - CC: "Nord, Jerry"
060548 - ..
060549 - b. Gary,
060550 -
060551 - Excellent analysis in your record today of "intellectual
060552 - bridges" that help people understand the advance from documents
060553 - to a culture of knowledge. ref SDS 5 0001
060555 - ..
060556 - c. Your explanation is cogent and compelling on how common
060557 - experience using traditional "documents," ref SDS 5 0148, and
060558 - "diaries," ref SDS 5 VF4F, cause the benefits of SDS to be
060559 - "hidden in plain sight," as explained in your letter received
060560 - on 030708. ref SDS 4 LV8G
060562 - ..
060563 - d. Drawing these out, as you have in the manner of the child
060564 - noting the "Emperor has no cloths," helps people step from the
060565 - old world of sole reliance on documents to a new world order of
060566 - "Knowledge Space," defined in POIMS. ref OF 2 034J
060568 - ..
060569 - e. Couple of quick points which don't need immediate attention,
060570 - but may justify consideration when time permits....
060571 -
060572 - 1. There are a few spelling errors and places where a word may
060573 - have been omitted that is needed, or should be removed, to
060574 - convey meaning.
060576 - ..
060577 - 2. Standard SDS format is that below the Summary/Objective,
060578 - which is well crafted in your record, we need a structure
060579 - break that is typically identified with a single word like
060580 - "Progress" or in this case "Analysis" or something similar.
060581 - See the example on 030708. ref SDS 4 7L6J
060583 - ..
060584 - This is not a requirement for SDS, but has proven to be
060585 - good practice for Com Metrics by refining the mental
060586 - perspective on the task at hand.
060588 - ..
060589 - 3. Recall the objective on 020924 to correlate analysis to
060590 - foundational documents in POIMS, etc. ref SDS 3 0001
060592 - ..
060593 - 4. Consideration should be given to customer "barriers" and
060594 - "resistance" that are reported in the record under SI
060595 - account 03 00050 01 05 10.
060597 - ..
060598 - An example is account 03 00050 01 05 10 09CI citing Andy
060599 - Grove noting people are inoculated against improvement by
060600 - success, reported on 980307. ref SDS 1 3740 Since
060601 - "success" is relative, Grove's analysis extends to everyone
060602 - on the job because skills seem adequate by virtue of
060603 - success holding an assignment, never mind that most of the
060604 - time on the job is spent fixing mistakes, under the theory
060605 - of "rework" set out in the Corps of Engineer's report on
060606 - 971007. ref DRP 3 4172
060608 - ..
060609 - Other barriers arise from the tension between the desire to
060610 - know and understand that is enabled by SDS, and the fear of
060611 - accountability because so and so "knew or reasonably should
060612 - have known," thus and so, as noted in POIMS. ref OF 6 4079
060614 - ..
060615 - How do these attitudes that drive common excuses for
060616 - failure to improve cited by Secretary of Defense Don
060617 - Rumsfeld, ref SDS 2 KW9N, weigh against the growing need
060618 - for improvement, also, noted by Rumsfeld in remarks to the
060619 - War College, reported on 020131. ref SDS 2 QE4H
060621 - ..
060622 - 5. Try to correlate better memory and analysis enabled by SDS
060623 - to formal requirements for "good management" (mentioned in
060624 - your record discussing the scientific method....
060626 - ..
060627 - http://www.welchco.com/sd/08/GLJDY/02/03/08/02/073004.HTM#IL60
060628 -
060629 - ...) There may be helpful guidance on this in POIMS discussing
060630 - "Command and Control of the Record"....
060632 - ..
060633 - http://www.welchco.com/03/00050/01/09/01/02/00030.HTM#1113
060635 - ..
060636 - How can we help people bridge the gap between published standards
060637 - for traceability to original sources, supported by experts and by
060638 - government regulations, as noted in POIMS....
060640 - ..
060641 - http://www.welchco.com/03/00050/01/09/01/02/00030.HTM#QT5L
060642 -
060643 - ...and which are ignored because good management is hard work
060644 - using conventional methods, however, even though SDS makes
060645 - compliance fast and easy, there is no enforcement of standards,
060646 - policy and regulations, so demand for SDS to enable good
060647 - management remains latent, rather a patent reality that drives
060648 - sales and improves lives. It's another KM dilemma that fits the
060649 - model of your analysis on advantages of SDS.
060651 - ..
060652 - 6. Correlate support for good management under para 4 to
060653 - requirements for CFISR that is one way people think about
060654 - overcoming the daily "fog of war" on the battlefield, in
060655 - the boardroom, the engineering office, etc., as occurred at
060656 - Enron and elsewhere.
060658 - ..
060659 - 7. Implications for education and learning using a new way of
060660 - thinking to accomplish goals of Doug Engelbart reviewed on
060661 - 991222...
060663 - ..
060664 - http://www.welchco.com/sd/08/00101/02/99/12/22/104523.HTM#3696
060666 - ..
060667 - Was Professor Ransdell correct in his letter on 000716 that
060668 - SDS enables a theory of knowledge that underlies
060669 - civilization based on a practice of community....
060671 - ..
060672 - http://www.welchco.com/sd/08/00101/02/00/07/16/111107.HTM#7838
060674 - ..
060675 - How does Professor Ransdell's view align with your analysis
060676 - on 030413...
060678 - ..
060679 - http://www.welchco.com/sd/08/GLJDY/02/03/04/13/103500.HTM#0001
060680 -
060681 - ....and now again today?
060682 -
060684 - ..
060685 - Thanks.
060687 - ..
060688 - Rod
060689 -
060690 -
060691 -
060692 -
060693 -
060694 -
060695 -
060696 -
060697 -
060698 -
060699 -
060700 -
060701 -
060702 -
060703 -
060704 -
0608 -
Distribution. . . . See "CONTACTS"