THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700


S U M M A R Y


DIARY: September 28, 1994 02:01 PM Wednesday; Rod Welch

Submitted ideas on scope definition of CDWR job, and cost savings.

1...Summary/Objective
2...Cost Savings Potential for PG&E - $100K
3...Developed plan for engergize and test work, and for contract scope


..............
Click here to comment!

CONTACTS 
0201 - PG&E Proj Mngmnt Transm Sys        415 973 6778 fax 8426
020101 - Mr. Bill DeHart, PMP
020102 - Project Manager, Room 1183B-V11C =415 973 5655 pger 510 810 3026
020103 - Project Management Group

SUBJECTS
Construct Space for Comm. Control Area by
Line Protection Equipment, Section 6.2
Transfer Trip, Control Room
Telecommunications, Transfer Trip
Cost Savings Avoid Rework Mistakes

2107 -    ..
2108 - Summary/Objective
2109 -
210901 - Submitted ref DIT 1 0000 with analysis of cost savings developed
210902 - on 940927, ref SDS 13 6639, and then discussed this with Bill.
210903 -
210904 -     [On 941004 Bill cited cost savings advantage of SDS. ref SDS 15
210905 -     8899]
210906 -
210907 -     [On 941010 reviewed with Chris Snyder. ref SDS 16 1377]
210908 -
210909 - This is an example of cost savings by avoiding the cost of rework.
210910 -
210911 -     [On 971008 received report from U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
210912 -     showing procedure for calculating cost savings from avoiding
210913 -     mistakes that cause "rework." ref SDS 19 1273]
210914 -
210915 -
210916 -  ..
2110 -
2111 -
2112 - 1438 discussion with Bill
2113 -
211301 - Cost Savings Potential for PG&E - $100K
211302 -
211303 - Bill said he called Kevin Coffee, and Kevin does not recall the scope
211304 - of "Line Protection" as set out in the contract.
211305 -
211306 - Bill said "Line protection" includes the relays and transfer trip
211307 - system on the tie lines (this is reflected in the schedule for SLO
211308 - Hydro and Casmalia).
211309 -
211310 - Ordinarily PG&E would install any work in its facilities, such as at
211311 - SLO Substation and Santa Maria.  Since the transfer trip system mainly
211312 - is built in the CDWR facility and it requires telephone service, which
211313 - CDWR is providing, it is unclear at this time why CDWR would be
211314 - responsible for providing phone service, which is part of the transfer
211315 - trip system, yet was not intended to construct the other parts of the
211316 - transfer trip system in its own facilities.  There is nothing in the
211317 - contract about CDWR making separate arrangements for telephone service
211318 - to support the "Line Protection" system.
211319 -
211320 - A straight forward interpretation that the contract intends for CDWR
211321 - to install the transfer trip, as part of "Line Protection" in its own
211322 - facilities, is consistent with CDWR's understandings as explained in
211323 - the analysis yesterday. ref SDS 13 6639.
211324 -
211325 - Bill said PG&E began designing a transfer trip system based on
211326 - requirements from its standard handbook.  However, the contract says
211327 - that "Line Protection" should be constructed to PG&E design standards,
211328 - so the existence of standards in a handbook, does not speak to
211329 - contractual responsibility for performing the work.
211330 -
211331 - Bill indicated that Jivat may have information on the authority for
211332 - PG&E undertaking this work.
211333 -
211334 -      [On 940929 discussed with Jivat at ref SDS 14 9558.]
211335 -
211336 -
211337 - Clarifying this matter may offer further opportunities for PG&E to
211338 - meet its schedule and budget objectives, since the Transfer Trip
211339 - system is approximately $100K.
211340 -
211341 -      [On 941107 coordinated with CDWR. ref SDS 17 0000.]
211342 -
211343 -
211344 -
2114 -

SUBJECTS
Arco Sub - Polonio Pass, Energize & Test
SLO Hydro Plant, Energize & Test
Casmalia, Energize and Test
Controls, Scope, General, Energize & Test,

2507 -
250701 -  ..
250702 - Developed plan for engergize and test work, and for contract scope
250703 -
250704 - Follow up ref SDS 13 8854
250705 -
250706 - The letter at ref DIT 1 0000 also submits the notes developed on
250707 - 940927. ref SDS 13 8854
250708 -
250709 - Bill indicated he wants to submit this to Kevin Coffee.
250710 -
250711 -
250712 -
250713 -
2508 -
2509 -
2510 - 1438 discussion with Bill
2511 -
251101 - He feels now that the work done in shaping the revised Schedule will
251102 - give CDWR notice of PG&E's interpretation.  PG&E will clarify the
251103 - intent of this matter in subsequent meetings and correspondence.
251104 -
251105 -      [On 941107 followed up ref SDS 17 7699, and on 941208 revised
251106 -      schedule was reviewed with CDWR. ref SDS 18 9558.]
251107 -
251108 -
251109 -
251110 -
251111 -
251112 -
251113 -
251114 -
251115 -
2512 -
Distribution. . . . See "CONTACTS"