Welch Company
San Francisco, CA
S U M M A R Y
DIARY: December 30, 2010 04:01 PM Thursday;
Rod Welch
HP call about c16 shut down system memory failures.
1...Summary/Objective
2...C16 Slow Internet Access Disk Network Transfer Memory Address Failing
3...HP Weak Record Technical Support C16 HDX 18t Notebook
4...HP Tech Support Requests $50 Assess Memory Failure Buy Hardware
5...C16 Technical Support Purchase 1 Year HP Contract $99 HDX 18t
6...HP 1 Year Contract $99 Technical Support HDX 18t Purchase on C16
7...C16 Technical Support Agreement 1 Year HP HDX 18t Department
8...24-7 SmartFriend PC Tune Up Service
9...Memory BIOS Test Pasted
10...HP Refuses Tech Support C16 Out of Warranty Despite Service Contract
11...Disks 1 and 2 BIOS Tests Successful
..............
Click here to comment!
CONTACTS
SUBJECTS
Windows XP Failing C16 Slow Internet Access Slow Data Transfer Memor
2703 -
2703 - ..
2704 - Summary/Objective
2705 -
270501 - Follow up ref SDS 8 0000.
270502 -
270503 -
270504 -
270506 - ..
2706 -
2707 -
2708 - Progress
2709 -
270901 - C16 Slow Internet Access Disk Network Transfer Memory Address Failing
270902 -
270903 - Past few months seems like c16 Internet access has slowed; this has
270904 - been attributed to virus problems, reported in another record today.
270905 - 101230 1158, ref SDS 8 J85H
270907 - ..
270908 - More recently the past few days, have experienced extremely slow data
270909 - transfer across the network between c16 and c17.
270911 - ..
270912 - Additionally, when c16 is shut down or restarted, there is a report of
270913 - memory failure, also, shown in the record today on 101230 1158.
270914 - ref SDS 8 G266
270916 - ..
270917 - Can reports of memory failure cause symptoms of slow Internet access,
270918 - and slow transfer between computers across the network?
270919 -
270920 - [...below on 101230 1601 at 1721, after buying
270921 - out-of-warranty support contract, ref SDS 0 PQ5W, HP
270922 - assisted opening BIOS and running memory test, which
270923 - passed. ref SDS 0 UH8G
270925 - ..
270926 - [...below on 101230 1601 at 1740 HP support supervisor has
270927 - encountered same memory report on his computer at home.
270928 - ref SDS 0 UI41
270929 -
270930 -
270931 -
270933 - ..
2710 -
2711 -
2712 - 1606
2713 -
271301 - HP Weak Record Technical Support C16 HDX 18t Notebook
271302 -
271303 - Background working with HP Technical support for c16 is reported on
271304 - 090715 2123. ref SDS 5 V89L
271306 - ..
271307 - HP has technical support reported on 090623 1648. ref SDS 2 OS6L
271309 - ..
271310 - Technical Support....
271311 -
271312 - 877 266 8359
271314 - ..
271315 - HP has another number for Technical Support on HP HDX 18t, reported on
271316 - 090708 1109. ref SDS 4 U26H
271317 -
271318 - 866 408 5408
271319 -
271321 - ..
2714 -
2715 -
2716 - 1600
2717 -
271701 - HP Tech Support Requests $50 Assess Memory Failure Buy Hardware
271702 -
271703 - Called HP for HDX 18t support at 2nd number... ref SDS 0 XL9J
271704 -
271705 - Telephone message that all agents busy.
271707 - ..
271708 - On hold...
271709 -
271711 - ..
2718 -
2719 -
2720 - 1646
2721 -
272101 - HP customer agent answered............ Mike.
272103 - ..
272104 - Computer c16 was purchased on 090623 1648. ref SDS 2 294M
272106 - ..
272107 - Product ID part and serial numbers are listed on 090623 1648.
272108 - ref SDS 2 YP9H
272110 - ..
272111 - Problems to solve listed above............... ref SDS 0 Y15H
272113 - ..
272114 - Mike says that in order for customers to determine they need to buy
272115 - memory, HP requires customers to pay $50 for a telephone call so an
272116 - engineer to tell them what memory to buy from HP.
272118 - ..
272119 - Asked for supervisor.
272120 -
272122 - ..
2722 -
2723 -
2724 - 1701
2725 -
272501 - C16 Technical Support Purchase 1 Year HP Contract $99 HDX 18t
272502 - HP 1 Year Contract $99 Technical Support HDX 18t Purchase on C16
272503 -
272504 - Talked Lawrence, supervisor.
272505 -
272506 - Lawrence agreed with Mike that to find out what memory is needed have
272507 - to pay $50 for this phone call.
272509 - ..
272510 - Lawrence then said that HP sells 1 year tech support contracts for out
272511 - of warranty customers. The cost is $99 for unlimited assistance and
272512 - repair services during the year, compared to paying $50 for 1
272513 - incident, like today.
272515 - ..
272516 - This is not an extended warranty for HP parts, like memory, drives,
272517 - processors, video adapters, etc. HP helps customers diagnose problems
272518 - and devleop solution plans, and in some cases resolve problems. If a
272519 - hardware failure is identified, customers have to buy the hardware.
272520 - HP only performs installation with certified HP technicians.
272522 - ..
272523 - Agreed to pay $99 for the 1 year of support.
272525 - ..
272526 - Lawrence transferred the call back to Mike.
272527 -
272528 -
272530 - ..
2726 -
2727 -
2728 - 1711
2729 -
272901 - Talked to Mike.
272902 -
272903 - Purchased 1 year Tech Support for c16 out of warranty.
272905 - ..
272906 - Mike requested product and serial numbers again, listed in the record
272907 - purchasing c16 on 090623 1648. ref SDS 2 YP9H
272909 - ..
272910 - Mike went off line to setup tech support contract.
272911 -
272912 -
272913 -
2730 -
SUBJECTS
C16 Technical Support $99 Contract 1 Year HP HDX 18t Department HP C
3903 -
3904 - 1714
390501 - ..
390502 - C16 Technical Support Agreement 1 Year HP HDX 18t Department
390503 -
390504 - Mike back online. He gave a number for the customer support
390505 - contract...
390506 -
390507 - Agreement............................. CA02909006-0001
390509 - ..
390510 - Telephone phone support 1 year................. $99
390512 - ..
390513 - Paid with Wells Fargo Debit card.
390515 - ..
390516 - Posted expense ledger up to date...
390520 - ..
390521 - Mike sent a letter explaining the transaction...
390523 - ..
390524 - Received following from HP during the call...
390525 -
390526 - 1. Subject: HP Care Pack Service Plan Registration Confirmation
390527 - Date: Fri, 31 Dec 2010 01:13:32 -0000
390534 - ..
390535 - 2. Ref: HP Care Pack Service #:CA02909006
390537 - ..
390538 - 3. Congratulations on your purchase of a HP Care Pack Service.
390539 - You can now take full advantage of HP's award winning Total
390540 - Care service and support programs, giving you the peace of mind
390541 - and confidence that comes with knowing that HP will take care
390542 - of you if you need help with your HP or Compaq products.
390544 - ..
390545 - 4. This email is to confirm the details of the HP Care Pack
390546 - Service purchased for your product(s) and contains important
390547 - information on the terms and conditions of the plan.
390549 - ..
390550 - 5. HP Care Pack Service #................ CA02909006
390551 - Service Level......................... 141 - 141 HP 1YR TECH PHONE SUPPORT NO HW
390554 - ..
390555 - 6. Agreement Start Date.................. 12/30/2010
390556 - Agreement End Date.................... 12/30/2011
390559 - ..
390560 - 7. Payment............................... $99.00
390561 - Discount.............................. $0.00
390562 - Tax................................... $0.00
390563 - Total Payment......................... $99.00
390564 - Payment Date.......................... 12/30/2010
390566 - ..
390567 - 8. Customer Address:
390572 - ..
390573 - 9. Should you experience a problem with your product, at any time,
390574 - please contact HP Total Care at 1-(800)-474-6836 (1-800-HP
390575 - invent) or 1-(800)-652-6672 (1-800-OK Compaq) for your Compaq
390576 - products.. Have this email handy when placing your call, as
390577 - you will need to know your product model, serial number and HP
390578 - Care Pack Service number.
390580 - ..
390581 - 10. Remember that HP Total Care's award-winning support and
390582 - services provide you with 24 x 7 assistance online or over the
390583 - phone, toll-free. Our exclusive Owner Services will help keep
390584 - all of your HP and Compaq products up and running. Visit us
390585 - at
390586 -
390587 - http://www.hp.com/go/totalcareservices
390588 -
390589 - ...to better understand all your service and support options
390590 - for the life of your product.
390592 - ..
390593 - 11. If there are any questions you have about your HP Care Pack
390594 - Service terms and conditions or if your contact details change,
390595 - please call HP Total Care at 1-(800)-474-6836 (1-800-HP invent)
390596 - or 1-(800)-652-6672 (1-800-OK Compaq) for your Compaq
390597 - products..
390599 - ..
390600 - 12. Visit us at....
390601 -
390602 - http://www.hp.com/go/terms
390603 -
390604 - ...to view the terms and conditions of your purchased service.
390606 - ..
390607 - 13. We value your business and look forward to assisting you.
390609 - ..
390610 - 14. Sincerely,
390611 -
390612 - *******************************
390614 - ..
390615 - 24-7 SmartFriend PC Tune Up Service
390616 -
390617 - There is an attachment, which is not referenced in HP's letter, and
390618 - says...
390619 -
390620 - 1. HP Total Care
390622 - ..
390623 - 2. YOU MADE THE RIGHT CHOICE.
390625 - ..
390626 - 3. Thank you for your recent HP Total Care Extended Service Plan
390627 - purchase. You'll increase your peace of mind and minimize
390628 - disruptions with all that HP Total Care has to offer.
390629 -
390630 - 1. 24/7 toll-free assistance by phone and online
390631 - 2. Award-winning service and support
390632 - 3. Advice and support from HP technicians
390633 - 4. Hardware protection and software system coverage
390635 - ..
390636 - 4. HP Total Care offers a wide array of services.
390638 - ..
390639 - 5. HP SmartFriend - A convenient, prepaid consultative service to
390640 - answer your "how to" questions on select hardware and software
390641 - issues not covered by standard warranties.
390643 - ..
390644 - 6. HP PC Tune-up Service - Improve the performance of your PC with
390645 - personalized assistance and instruction.
390647 - ..
390648 - 7. HP Total One - Cover your HP or Compaq PC together with up to
390649 - three qualifying HP peripherals.
390651 - ..
390652 - 8. HP House Call - Enjoy the comfort of knowing an HP technician
390653 - will come right to your door, if needed./1
390655 - ..
390656 - 9. HP Accidental Damage Protection - Drops, spills and accidents
390657 - happen. Protect against the unpredictable and safeguard your
390658 - HP investment.
390660 - ..
390661 - 10. HP Pick Up and Return - Have your qualifying HP product picked
390662 - up, diagnosed, repaired and returned to you./2
390664 - ..
390665 - 11. HP Next-Day Exchange - Get a replacement for qualifying HP
390666 - products delivered to your door by the next business day./3
390668 - ..
390669 - 12. To view the terms and conditions and termination policy for
390670 - your purchased service, visit the HP Total Care website at
390671 -
390672 - http://h71036.www7.hp.com/hho/cache/338708-0-0-225-121.html
390674 - ..
390675 - Footnotes.....
390676 -
390677 - 1. Need will be determined by an HP support representative.
390678 - Does not include holidays or weekends. On-site services are
390679 - provided only if the issue cannot be corrected remotely.
390681 - ..
390682 - 2. Does not include holidays or weekends.
390684 - ..
390685 - 3. When call is received before 4 p.m. Central time.
390687 - ..
390688 - 13. Copyright 2009 Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P. The
390689 - information contained herein is subject to change without
390690 - notice. 08-050A
390692 - ..
390693 - Received a second letter from Mike saying...
390694 -
390695 - 1. Subject: 1 year phone support Agreement
390696 - Date: Fri, 31 Dec 2010 01:18:53 +0000 (UTC)
390700 - ..
390701 - 2. Agreement Submit / Update
390702 -
390703 - Your agreement has been successfully submitted.
390705 - ..
390706 - 3. Agreement number: CA02909006 -0001 Agreement Type: 141 - 141
390707 - HP 1YR TECH PHONE SUPPORT NO HW start date: 12/30/2010 end
390708 - date: 12/30/2011 total charge: $99.00 payment method: Visa
390709 -
390710 -
390711 -
390712 -
3908 -
SUBJECTS
Windows XP Failing C16 Slow Internet Access Slow Data Transfer Memor
6303 -
6304 - 1721
630501 - ..
630502 - Memory BIOS Test Pasted
630503 -
630504 - After entering into agreement and paying for 1 year out-of-warranty
630505 - support contract, per above, ref SDS 0 IR84, and after receiving HP's
630506 - correspondence on scope of service, per above, ref SDS 0 RL53,
630507 - including the secind letter, ref SDS 0 HI7M, Mike provided technical
630508 - support as called out in the agreement, per above. ref SDS 0 MB6R
630510 - ..
630511 - Mike helped run a memory test, to assess reports of memory problems,
630512 - per above. ref SDS 0 Y15H
630514 - ..
630515 - 1. Disconect power cable, and remove battery.
630516 - 2. Press power on button for 15 seconds.
630517 - 3. Restor battery and then power cable.
630518 - 4. Power system, and press F10 continuously to open BIOS.
630519 - 5. Diagnostics memory test.
630521 - ..
630522 - Memory test in BIOS passed.
630523 -
630524 - [...below in this record on 101230 1601 at 1921 after
630525 - completing Tech Support call at HP, BIOS tests show both
630526 - disks show no signs of defect. ref SDS 0 TJ4K
630527 -
630529 - ..
630530 - HP Refuses Tech Support C16 Out of Warranty Despite Service Contract
630531 -
630532 - Mike said that since c16 is configured for multi-boot productivity,
630533 - HP's warranty policy prevents providing further technical support to
630534 - diagnose problems, reported above. ref SDS 0 Y15H HP failure to
630535 - support the customer was previously reported on 090705 1545.
630536 - ref SDS 3 RG56 A few days later, HP again refused help to configure
630537 - c16 productively, reported on 090708 1109. ref SDS 4 PQ9R After
630538 - further review, HP case manager not only said the customer can
630539 - configure the HP HDX 18t for dual boot with Windows XP and Windows 7,
630540 - he provided a video showing how to do the work, and gave guidance on
630541 - getting device drivers. ref SDS 4 0Q4H
630543 - ..
630544 - Mike feels HP's initial refusal to help the customer was correct, and
630545 - that HP later providing technical support to configure dual boot was a
630546 - mistake. He was adamant that HP warranty provides technical support
630547 - only for computers as shipped from the factory, because changing the
630548 - operating system for productivity makes the computer out of warranty.
630550 - ..
630551 - We reviewed the record showing HP was just paid $100, ref SDS 0
630552 - 0218, to provide out-of-warranty support.
630554 - ..
630555 - We just need help doing diagnostics, like the BIOS memory test, Mike
630556 - just suggested, per above. ref SDS 0 UH8G This kind of friendly
630557 - assistance trouble shooting problems seems to be the express purpose
630558 - of HP's Total Care program, per above. ref SDS 0 MB4J
630560 - ..
630561 - Mike feels HP can only provide additional support after performing a
630562 - factory re-install of Vista.
630564 - ..
630565 - This would wipe out weeks of work setting up line-of-business
630566 - capability on c16, reported on 090715 2123. ref SDS 4 PX6N
630568 - ..
630569 - Mike said there is nothing he can do, since his boss won't approve
630570 - supporting customers who change factory configuration.
630572 - ..
630573 - Asked to speak with the supervisor again.
630575 - ..
630576 - Mike explained that his boss must implement HP policy on not helping
630577 - customers to use HP products
630578 -
630579 -
630581 - ..
6306 -
6307 -
6308 - 1740
6309 -
630901 - Talked to Supervisor Lawrence.
630902 -
630903 - This was a constructive meeting with the telephone.
630905 - ..
630906 - Turns out that Lawrence has encountered the same error message problem
630907 - on his computer at home configured for dual boot with Linux and
630908 - Windows, as encountered with c16, reported above. ref SDS 0 Y165
630910 - ..
630911 - After he removed dual boot with Linux, the problems cleared.
630913 - ..
630914 - This aligns with Morris' experience using Linux. He has continual
630915 - problems getting everything to run.
630917 - ..
630918 - Lawrence said computers are becoming so complex with multiple
630919 - services, that the operating system and hardware gets overloaded with
630920 - and simply fail in confusion. The Windows registry gets bigger and
630921 - bigger with entries for failed configurations. The operating system
630922 - is eventually overwhelmed like people who get confused by information
630923 - overload.
630925 - ..
630926 - Case study on procurement and setup of c17 shows complexity of
630927 - computers to work intelligently using SDS for Knowledge Management
630928 - support. Getting set up takes longer and longer, reported on 101115
630929 - 1843. ref SDS 6 MQ8F
630931 - ..
630932 - C16 has been running for over a year without a flaw and supporting
630933 - following periphals connected...
630934 -
630935 - 1. Keyboard with USB port
630936 - 2. LAN connection to router with cable and Wireless
630938 - ..
630939 - In the past month, have added...
630940 -
630941 - 3. External backup hard drive USB
630942 - 4. HDMI cable to Vizio VA320M television for monitor.
630943 - 5. HP Photosmart C4780 printer wirless with OCR support.
630945 - ..
630946 - Lawrence said that failure to execute safe removal of USB connections,
630947 - like the external hard drive, can cause system failures reported
630948 - today, per above. ref SDS 0 Y15H
630950 - ..
630951 - Discussed Pat's comments on Tuesday that HP has encountered problems
630952 - configuring HP printers with HP computers, reported on 101228 0944.
630953 - ref SDS 7 V49M
630955 - ..
630956 - Lawrence said there are some steps HP can help the customer perform
630957 - today evaluating and possibly solving current problems, per above.
630958 - ref SDS 0 Y15H If initial steps fail, then HP recommends restoring
630959 - factory defaults, which has Windows Vista installed. This entails a
630960 - complete reinstallation, so that means formatting the drive, and
630961 - starting over.
630963 - ..
630964 - HP's offer of assistance aligns with Total Care service agreement
630965 - entered into earlier today, per above. ref SDS 0 MC3Q Further fits
630966 - HP's practice of discouraging customers from requesting help from HP,
630967 - and then providing solutions, reported last year when c16 was
630968 - initially setup after purchase, reported on 090708 1109. ref SDS 4
630969 - 0Q4H
630971 - ..
630972 - Thanked Lawrence for providing assistance to make initial diagnostic
630973 - assessment.
630975 - ..
630976 - Lawrence transferred the call back to Mike.
630977 -
630978 -
630980 - ..
6310 -
6311 -
6312 - 1812
6313 -
631301 - Talked to Mike.
631302 -
631303 - Case number........................ 8046099600
631305 - ..
631306 - Mike said to open open c16 Windows 7 64-bit.
631308 - ..
631309 - Open DOS prompt and run...
631311 - ..
631312 - C>msconfig
631314 - ..
631315 - Startup
631317 - ..
631318 - disconnect everything.
631320 - ..
631321 - Booted computer c17 Windows 7 64-bit, and amazingly, everything seems
631322 - to work.
631323 -
631324 - [...below on 101230 1601 at 1948 after HP support call
631325 - ended, restored c16 Windows 7 64-bit msconfig defaults.
631326 - ref SDS 0 TJ4K
631328 - ..
631329 - Mike asked if the boot operation seemed faster with startup processes
631330 - disconnected?
631332 - ..
631333 - Advised that startup seemed faster.
631335 - ..
631336 - Mike said to
631337 -
631338 - 1. Shutdown the computer.
631339 - 2. Disconnect electrical power.
631340 - 3. Remove the battery.
631341 - 4. Press power up button for 15 seconds.
631343 - ..
631344 - After these steps....
631345 -
631346 - 5. Replace battery.
631347 - 6. Connect power cable.
631349 - ..
631350 - Power up the computer.
631352 - ..
631353 - Open Windows XP.
631355 - ..
631356 - Tested Internet access.
631358 - ..
631359 - Still extremely slow.
631361 - ..
631362 - Tested copying files from c16 to c17, still very slow.
631364 - ..
631365 - Restarted the computer.
631367 - ..
631368 - Opened Windows 7 64-bit
631370 - ..
631371 - Tested Internet access................. normal - very fast
631373 - ..
631374 - Tested copying files from c16 to c17........... normal - very fast
631376 - ..
631377 - Mike feels this record indicates that XP on c16 may be failing.
631379 - ..
631380 - Thanked Mike for excellent support.
631382 - ..
631383 - Suddenly having quirky problem using keyboard on c17, reported in
631384 - another record today for solution on 101230 1928, ref SDS 9 J85H
631385 -
631386 - [On 101230 1928 report capital letter keyboard entry
631387 - problem, and possible solution. ref SDS 9 PSWS
631388 -
631389 -
631390 -
631392 - ..
6314 -
6315 -
6316 - 1948
6317 -
631701 - Disks 1 and 2 BIOS Tests Successful
631702 -
631703 - After talking to HP...
631704 -
631705 - Opened c16 Windows 7 64-bit and restored msconfig startup defaults,
631706 - following Mike's test above. ref SDS 0 E568
631708 - ..
631709 - BIOS hard disk test - primary.
631710 -
631712 - ..
6318 -
6319 -
6320 - 2125
6321 -
632101 - Hard disk test passed - primary.
632102 -
632103 - BIOS hard disk test - secondary.
632104 -
632106 - ..
6322 -
6323 -
6324 - 2126
6325 -
632501 - Hard disk test passed - secondary.
632502 -
632503 - This record of memory and disks passing BIOS tests suggests XP on c16
632504 - is failing. This was corrected on c14 by re-installing XP, reported
632505 - on 070625. ref SDS 1 0001
632506 -
632507 -
632508 -
632509 -
632510 -
632511 -
632512 -
632513 -
632514 -
632515 -
6326 -