THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700


S U M M A R Y


DIARY: October 9, 1996 01:00 PM Wednesday; Rod Welch

Progress meeting -42' Navigation Improvement, Oakland Harbor.

1...Summary/Objective
2...Project Status
3...Change from 17 to 24 CY Bucket on Antone
4...Partial Acceptance Schnitzer Due to Shoaling Caused by Ships
5...Piling Stubs Encountered - Dutra Requests Instructions
6...Environmental Tasks Being Properly Performed
7...Mounding Material into "Islands" on Galbraith Okay
8...Visitors at Galbraith from New Jersey
9...Visitors to Inspect/Observe Antone after 961023, Port to Confirm
10...Inspectors Need Ferry Terminal Access after 1030p
11...New Procedures to be Posted from Dutra Safety Event
12...Safety Meeting Will Be Held For All Dutra Crews on 961010
13...Emergency Phone Numbers Will Be Posted
14...Worker Fell on Antone, Loss Time Accident
15...Rowdiness on Antone Resolved No Injuries, No Damage
16...Navy Sewer Line - Dutra VE Proposal Needs Schedule/Cost Impacts
.....Need Analysis of Schedule Impacts
17...Hard/Soft Polygons Proposal - Dutra to Submit Justification for Audit
18...Project Wide Survey - Will Be Completed End of Next Week
19...Inclement Weather Days, COE Submits Determination to Dutra
20...Maintenance Dredging - Dutra Proposal Not Accepted; Too High
21...Sonoma Baylands Levee Breach NTP Issued
22...Meeting on RFP Remove Electrical Line, Pending Survey Results


..............
Click here to comment!

CONTACTS 
0201 - Dutra Oakland Project Ofc          510 522 3758 fax or 800...
020101 - Mr. Jeff McWilliams
020102 - Mr. Chris Peterson; =510 522 2378
020103 - Mr. Jack Finn; =510 522 2378
020104 - Mr. Phil Torres; =510 522 2378
020105 - Mr. Ken Esse; Safety Engineer =510 522 2378
020106 - Mr. S. Hutchensen; =510 522 2378
0202 - Dutra Dredging Company             415 721 2131 fax or 800...
020201 - Mr. Robert D. Johnston; President
020202 - Mr. James J. Galli, P.E.; Manager =415 258 1583
020203 - West Coast Dredging    =Telephone/fax
0203 - Corps of Engineers, SFD            415 977 8400 fax 8483
020301 - Mr. Thomas Benero; Chief =415 977 8511; Contracting Division
020302 - Ms. Ofelia R. Rosales; Contracting Officer =415 977 8499
020303 - Contracting Division
0204 - Corps of Engineers, SFD            415 977 8400 fax 8483
020401 - Mr. Glen N. Chafe    415 331 0404
0205 - Port of Oakland, Airport           510 577 4160 fax or 800...
020501 - Mr. Karl Kuhlmann
020502 - Acting Principal Engineer in Charge of Construction =510 577 4160
0206 - Port of Oakland                    510 272 1100 fax or 800...
020601 - Ms. Gail Staba; Environmental Planner =510 272 1479
0207 - Port of Oakland                    510 272 1100 fax or 800...
020701 - Mr. Rob Andrews; Engineering Project Manager =510 272 1166
0208 - Moffatt & Nichol Engineers         510 446 7740 fax or 800...
020801 - Mr. Len Cardoza; Project Manager
0209 - Gahagan & Bryant Associates, Inc.  415 883 7683 fax 1589
020901 - Mr. Rick Olejniczak; Vice President

SUBJECTS
Corps of Engineers, SFD, Oakland Project
Weekly Progress Meeting

0404 -    ..
0405 - Summary/Objective
0406 -
040601 - Follow up work at ref SDS 2 0000.
040602 -
040603 - Antone is back on-line; Paula Lee is being serviced. Abandoned piling
040604 - stubbs discovered during dredging in Schnitzer polygon need solution.
040605 - Environmental procedures are being performed at Galbraith.  COE has
040606 - responded to Dutra's 960926 letter on changing some polygons from soft
040607 - to hard; Dutra is preparing support and justification so COE can
040608 - schedule an audit.  Dutra will submit VEP on Navy Sewer Line next
040609 - week.  Recent incidents have prompted added efforts to improve safety.
040610 - COE submitted determination of Dutra claim for time extension based on
040611 - bad weather.
040612 -
040613 -      [See submission for distribution at ref SDS 8 0000.]
040614 -
040615 -
040616 -
040617 -
0407 -

SUBJECTS
Commencement, Prosecution, Completion of Work
Galbraith, Disposal

0805 -
080501 -  ..
080502 - Project Status
080503 -
080504 -
080505 -    a.  The weekly report on "Hard Digging" for the period ending
080506 -        961007, was distributed/discussed, showing Antone working in
080507 -        Schnitzer, as of 961006, ref DIT 1 line 30, and Paula Lee at
080508 -        Galbraith.
080509 -
080510 -    b.  Jack Fink said dredging is 50% complete in Schnitzer. This work
080511 -        was interrupted by encoutering piling, as explained in
080512 -        Contractor's letter of 961007, ref DRT 1 line 26, discussed
080513 -        below.
080514 -
080515 -    c.  Dutra plans to begin dredging next in the Todd Wing.
080516 -        ..
080517 -    d.  COE's meeting notes for the 961001 Progress Meeting,
080518 -        ref DIP 3 line 16, make a correction to the notes for the
080519 -        960924 meeting on acceptance of down to grade surveys for
080520 -        various polygons, ref SDS 5 line 53.
080521 -
080522 -
0806 -
0807 -

SUBJECTS
Polygon Work Area OC10; Schnitzer
Service Dredging Equipment
Paula Lee, Antone

1306 -
130601 - Antone is back in operation following maintenance service last week.
130602 -
130603 - The Paula Lee is now being serviced at Rio Vista OA 961006, ref DIT 1
130604 - line 24. Tom White asked for an estimate of when the Paula Lee will be
130605 - back on line?  Dutra is unsure at this time.  There is no status on
130606 - the DB-24.
130607 -
130608 -
130609 -  ..
130610 - Change from 17 to 24 CY Bucket on Antone
130611 -
130612 - There was no discussion about changing from a 17 to a 24 CY bucket
130613 - during the recent maintenance service, ref SDS 2 line 159, which was
130614 - discussed at the progress meeting on 960924, ref DIP 1 line 12.
130615 -
130616 -     [In a call to the Antone on 961010, Dutra indicated the change to
130617 -     the 24 CY bucket may occur after the christening ceremony on
130618 -     961023, ref SDS 7 line 123.]
130619 -
130620 -
130621 -
130622 -
1307 -

SUBJECTS
Inner Harbor Work Area, Schnitzer
Acceptance Schnitzer Due to Ships causing
Surveys Predredge, Postdredge
Measurement and Payment, Dredging
Shoaling

1808 -
180801 -  ..
180802 - Partial Acceptance Schnitzer Due to Shoaling Caused by Ships
180803 -
180804 - Bob Johnston asked about developing a procedure to partially accept
180805 - the Schnitzer polygon.  He explained that ships turning in the basin
180806 - cause shoaling in areas that have been dredged to grade.
180807 -
180808 -      There was no discussion of how this occurs.  Is material mounded
180809 -      up in areas dredged to grade, and/or moved/shoved by ship
180810 -      turbulence from undredged, or partially dredged areas, to areas
180811 -      that have been cut to grade?
180812 -
180813 - Shoaling is discussed in section 02480-13, ref OF 5 line 1184, and in
180814 - 02480-14.4, ref OF 5 line 1275.
180815 - ..
180816 - Tom White advised that COE is analysing the shoaling issue,
180817 - ref SDS 4 line 300.
180818 -
180819 - There was consideration of whether Dutra has actually encountered any
180820 - shoaling so far?  Bob said nothing specific has transpired as yet;
180821 - however, he cited Dutra's history dredging in this area shows shoaling
180822 - will likely occur due to the dynamics of ship traffic.
180823 -
180824 - Tom Benero asked how the matter has been handled in the past? Bob
180825 - recalled addressing it with the Port of Oakland.
180826 -
180827 - Bob suggests a joint meeting to address the matter, similar to
180828 - discussion with Tom White and Phil Torres on 961004, ref SDS 4 line
180829 - 327.
180830 -
180831 -      [See follow up on partnering meeting at ref SDS 10 line 203.]
180832 -
180833 -
1809 -

SUBJECTS
Inner Harbor Work Area, Schnitzer
Piling encountered, Schnitzer

2005 -
200501 -  ..
200502 - Piling Stubs Encountered - Dutra Requests Instructions
200503 -
200504 - Bob Johnston requested timely response to Dutra's 961007 notice that
200505 - piling stubs have been encountered in the Schnitzer polygon,
200506 - ref DRT 1 line 26.
200507 -
200508 - Glenn Chafey indicated a similar issue may arise in the Todd Wing
200509 - polygon, based on another COE contract that is underway at that
200510 - location.
200511 -
200512 - Bob Johnston indicated the piles do not impede dredging with the
200513 - Antone, but wood splinters may require a directed effort to retrieve
200514 - "floaters" as cited in Dutra's 961007 letter, ref DRT 1 line 30. There
200515 - was also discussion of possible need for boats and crew with poles to
200516 - retrieve the "floaters", should they be encountered.
200517 - ..
200518 - Chris Peterson explained that Dutra's pumps have been impeded
200519 - of -loading dredged material from the scow to the land fill as set out
200520 - in Dutra's 961007 letter, ref DRT 1 line 31.
200521 -
200522 - Tom White advised that COE has already commenced investigation and
200523 - will respond to Dutra's notice as soon as possible.
200524 -
200525 -     [See follow up at ref SDS 11 line 91.]
200526 -
200527 -
2006 -

SUBJECTS
Environmental Protection
Galbraith Disposal Requirements

2305 -
230501 -  ..
230502 - Environmental Tasks Being Properly Performed
230503 -
230504 - Gail Staba reported that procedures are working perfectly, per meeting
230505 - on 961001, ref SDS 2 line 208.
230506 -
230507 -
230508 - Mounding Material into "Islands" on Galbraith Okay
230509 -
230510 - Chris Peterson asked if material can be mounded into "islands" of
230511 - varying heights at Galbraith.  Are there any requirements on how the
230512 - material is layed with respect to height?
230513 -
230514 - Gail indicated there are no specific limits or requirements, since
230515 - there will be a follow on operation under a separate contract to move
230516 - the material to final grade.
230517 - ..
230518 - Rick Oleniczak recalled this was discussed on Phase I, and
230519 - determined similarly to Gail's explanation today.
230520 -
230521 - Tom White asked if Rob Andrews has considred this issue?  Gail
230522 - recalled discussing this matter with Rob.
230523 -
230524 -
230525 -  ..
230526 - Visitors at Galbraith from New Jersey
230527 -
230528 - Gail advised that the Port is facilitating a field trip on 961015 from
230529 - 0330p to 0400p, for a contingent of 4 people from the New Jersy
230530 - Departments of Commerce and Environment, including a consultant from
230531 - Seattle.
230532 -
230533 - She asked to be notified if COE and or Dutra want to include a
230534 - representative.
230535 -
230536 - Bob Johnston said Dutra will join this trip.
230537 -
230538 -
230539 -  ..
230540 - Visitors to Inspect/Observe Antone after 961023, Port to Confirm
230541 -
230542 - Gail advised that the Port has a group that would like to visit the
230543 - Antone on 961021.
230544 -
230545 - Bob Johnston said the visit should be scheduled for sometime
230546 - following 961023 because the Antone is scheduled for a christening
230547 - event.
230548 -
230549 - Gail asked how large a party can be accomodated in such a field trip.
230550 - Bob indicated that any number of people can visit.  Gail asked if 15
230551 - people is okay, and Bob said that would be fine.
230552 -
230553 - Gail will confirm the date for the visit, sometime after 961023.
230554 -
230555 -
230556 -
2306 -

SUBJECTS
Access to the Work

2404 -
240401 -  ..
240402 - Inspectors Need Ferry Terminal Access after 1030p
240403 -
240404 - Rick Oleniczak advised that inspectors who leave the site and
240405 - disembark at the Alameda Ferry Terminal need to have a way to unlock
240406 - the gate or otherwise have the gate unlocked.
240407 -
240408 - Chris Peterson said Dutra will take care of this.
240409 -
240410 -      [See follow up at ref SDS 10 line 446.]
240411 -
240412 -
2405 -

SUBJECTS
Safety and Health, Safety Seminar
Safety Improvements
Safety Meeting on Current Accidents/Incidents
Emergency Numbers

2807 -
280701 -  ..
280702 - New Procedures to be Posted from Dutra Safety Event
280703 -
280704 - Leonard SooHoo asked about the status of the memo on safety from
280705 - Dutra's event on 960923, per meeting on 961001, ref SDS 2 line 281?
280706 -
280707 - Ken Esse indicated communications and response of all hands is very
280708 - much improved.
280709 -
280710 -     [See discussion on QA at ref SDS 7 line 178; and follow up at next
280711 -     meeting, ref SDS 10 line 487.]
280712 -
280713 -
280714 -  ..
280715 - Safety Meeting Will Be Held For All Dutra Crews on 961010
280716 -
280717 - Leonard SooHoo asked if there are any new procecures to address the
280718 - accident and the incident (reported below)?
280719 -
280720 - Ken Esse said Dutra will hold a major safety meeting tomorrow with all
280721 - affected project employees, to explain procedures for avoiding
280722 - accidents and the particular matters reported below.
280723 -
280724 -
280725 -
280726 -  ..
280727 - Emergency Phone Numbers Will Be Posted
280728 -
280729 - Bob Johnston recalled that Dutra submitted a list of names and phone
280730 - numbers for responsible Dutra management to call in case of
280731 - emergencies, as occurred the past few days (see below).
280732 -
280733 - There was discussion of a phone number at Dutra to call that lists key
280734 - people to call in case of an emergency.
280735 -
280736 - Dutra Safety Engineer should submit plan and/or notice of action taken
280737 - for posting and distributing the list of emergency numbers in order to
280738 - facilitate timely responsiveness.
280739 -
280740 -
280741 -
2808 -

SUBJECTS
Safety and Health, Accidents
Worker Fell Walking Down Stairs with Tools

2905 -
290501 -  ..
290502 - Worker Fell on Antone, Loss Time Accident
290503 -
290504 - Ken Esse reported that last Saturday, 961005, a worker slipped and
290505 - fell on the dredge Antone while descending a stairwell carrying tools
290506 - in both hands.
290507 -
290508 - The worker is expected to be off the job recuperating until
290509 - approximately 961101.
290510 -
290511 - Ken Esse has prepared a report on the incident ref DRT 2 line 8, that
290512 - was submitted to COE marked at "Preliminary," with "Final" report to
290513 - follow, ref DIT 3 line 22, via fax on 961009, including
290514 -
290515 -       •  Eng Form 3394 signed by Ken on 961007
290516 -
290517 -       •  <GH56 Supervisor's Accident Investigation form dated 961005
290518 -
290519 -       •  Weekly Safety Meeting Report dated 961007, that covers proper
290520 -          methods to descent stairs.
290521 -
290522 -
2906 -

SUBJECTS
Safety and Health, Accidents
Rowdiness on Antone

3005 -
300501 -  ..
300502 - Rowdiness on Antone Resolved No Injuries, No Damage
300503 -
300504 - Ken Esse reported that last Sunday, 961006, a worker who evidently has
300505 - sleeping quarters on the Antone, returned during his off-duty hours to
300506 - the Antone in a drunken condition and caused a disturbance.  This
300507 - individual may have broken his hand.  There were no reports of others
300508 - being injured nor of equipment being damaged.
300509 -
300510 - Bob Johnston said this person has been fired.
300511 -
300512 - Ken Esse has prepared a report on the incident.
300513 -
300514 -     [See follow up at ref SDS 10 line 509.]
300515 -
300516 -
3006 -

SUBJECTS
Value Engineering, 52.248-3
Navy Sewer Line Re-design
Commencement, Prosecution, Completion of
Schedule

3407 -
340701 -  ..
340702 - Navy Sewer Line - Dutra VE Proposal Needs Schedule/Cost Impacts
340703 -
340704 - Leonard asked about Dutra's expanded cost estimate for current design
340705 - and for revised crossing, as discussed at the Progress meeting on
340706 - 961001. ref SDS 2 5477.
340707 -
340708 - Bob Johnston indicated final drawings are expected from Dutra's
340709 - engineer by next week oa Tuesday, 961014.
340710 -
340711 -       [On 961015 COE received Dutra's submission at the Progress
340712 -       Meeting. ref SDS 10 5739]
340713 - ..
340714 - Tom White asked about impacts on scheduling.
340715 -
340716 -     Need Analysis of Schedule Impacts
340717 -
340718 -     There was discussion that Dutra should include in its proposal
340719 -     tasks, durations and CPM sequencing that shows impact on project
340720 -     schedule, if VE proposal is accepted.
340721 -
340722 -     What dates must be met for design changes by Dutra, review and
340723 -     approvals by COE, and procurements, if any, by Dutra, in order to
340724 -     avoid delaying the project?
340725 - ..
340726 - Bob said Dutra's proposal is not addressing these issues.  Their
340727 - focus is on getting an acceptable design.  He indicated procurement
340728 - time is not presently recognized as a long lead issue.
340729 -
340730 -     [On 961010 reviewed Dutra's letter of 960812 (not discussed at the
340731 -     meeting today), ref SDS 6 4562; and Dutra letter 960906 (also not
340732 -     discussed today) that says Dutra needs 100 days to procure pipe,
340733 -     if alternate design is approved, ref SDS 6 7503.]
340734 -
340735 - Bob said a railroad permit must be obtained and mentioned other
340736 - approvals that are needed in order to accomplish the Value Engineering
340737 - proposal Dutra is pursuing.
340738 -
340739 - Marc McGovern urged that the contractor proceed with the current
340740 - contract design.
340741 - ..
340742 - Gail Staba suggested that Rob Andrews be consulted on impacts to
340743 - Port of Oakland interests.
340744 -
340745 -
340746 -
340747 -
3408 -

SUBJECTS
RFPs Soft-Hard Polygons
Justify Increase Unit Price

3505 -
350501 -  ..
350502 - Hard/Soft Polygons Proposal - Dutra to Submit Justification for Audit
350503 -
350504 - Monti Jaggers advised that COE responded to Dutra's 960926 letter,
350505 - ref DRP 1 line 22, in a letter to Dutra dated 961003, ref DIP 4 line
350506 - 26, as discussed at the Progress Meeting on 961001, ref SDS 2 line
350507 - 347.
350508 -
350509 - Tom Benero asked when Dutra expects to submit the information COE
350510 - needs to schedule an audit in connection with determining an equitable
350511 - adjustment for Dutra, as follows:
350512 -
350513 -     1.  Explains rational basis for lump sum payment above unit prices
350514 -         bid for dredging hard material in polygons not subject to
350515 -         change, per ref SDS 1 line 112.   Is there a material change
350516 -         in the character of hard material in different polygons that
350517 -         permits the government to pay more than unit bid prices?  The
350518 -         proposal amounts must track to contract bid items.
350519 -         ..
350520 -     2.  Shows credit owed the government for the change in
350521 -         disposal sites discussed at meeting on 960920, ref SDS 1 line
350522 -         65.
350523 -
350524 - Bob Johnston advised Dutra's letter of 960926 was not intended to
350525 - respond to FAR requirements cited in COE letters and requested by COE
350526 - at the meeting on 960920, ref SDS 1 line 115.  Dutra is still working
350527 - on this part of the justification for their proposals to RFPs, and
350528 - expects to submit it in response to COE letter dated 961003, possibly
350529 - by next Tuesday, 961015.
350530 -
350531 -     [See letter from Contractor acknowledging it has not yet submitted
350532 -     justification for pricing in its proposals, ref SDS 9 line 115.]
350533 -
350534 -
350535 -
3506 -

SUBJECTS
Variations in Estimated Quantities
Surveys Predredge, Postdredge
Quantity Surveys for Payment

4006 -
400601 -  ..
400602 - Project Wide Survey - Will Be Completed End of Next Week
400603 -
400604 - Rick Oleniczak reported the field work by G.B. Star Company is
400605 - expected to be completed the end of this week.  He expects to have
400606 - data by the end of next week.  There was an unusually high tide that
400607 - disrupted use of a benchmark which required re-work to ensure accuracy
400608 - of the survey.
400609 -
400610 -
4007 -

SUBJECTS
Time Extension 1 CD/8K CY
Time for Completion, 840 CD
Time Extension for Weather Delays

4306 -
430601 -  ..
430602 - Inclement Weather Days, COE Submits Determination to Dutra
430603 -
430604 - Tom Benero submitted to Mr. Johnston the COE response dated 961008,
430605 - ref DIT 2 line 30, to Dutra's request dated 960906 for time extension
430606 - due to weather delays.
430607 -
430608 -    (Need to ask Tom Benero about serial letter numbering.)
430609 -
430610 -      [See follow up at Action Item meeting ref SDS 12 line 222.]
430611 -
430612 -
4307 -

SUBJECTS
RFP __ Maintenance Dredging, Inner Harbor

4404 -
440401 -  ..
440402 - Maintenance Dredging - Dutra Proposal Not Accepted; Too High
440403 -
440404 - Marc McGovern advised that COE cannot accept Dutra's proposal to
440405 - perform this work because the cost is too high.
440406 -
440407 -
440408 -
440409 -
440410 -
4405 -

SUBJECTS
Disposal at Sonoma Baylands
Sonoma Baylands Disposal Requirements

4605 -
460501 -  ..
460502 - Sonoma Baylands Levee Breach NTP Issued
460503 -
460504 - Notice to proceed was given yesterday on the Sonoma Baylands levee
460505 - breach.
460506 -
460507 - Leonard SooHoo asked for a schedule of when Dutra will be working in
460508 - Sonoma Baylands?
460509 -
460510 - Dutra will advise COE on this matter.
460511 -
460512 -
4606 -

e in OC-4B-5
4702 - =============================
4703 -
4704 -
470401 -  ..
470402 - Meeting on RFP Remove Electrical Line, Pending Survey Results
470403 -
470404 - Tom Benero is setting up a meeting next Thursday, but will hold up
470405 - until Marc's new survey is done and will re-evaluate.
470406 -
470407 -
470408 -
470409 -
470410 -
470411 -
470412 -
470413 -
470414 -
470415 -
470416 -
Distribution. . . . See "CONTACTS"