THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net
S U M M A R Y
DIARY: November 8, 2005 08:43 PM Tuesday;
Rod Welch
Commend Guardino at Stanford and Benz at UCSF for 2nd opinions to Help Millie.
1...Summary/Objective
2...Commend Doctor Guardino at Stanford Cancer Center for Good Advice
3...Commend Doctor Benz at Stanford Cancer Center for Good Advice
..............
Click here to comment!
CONTACTS
0201 - Stanford Medical Center O-00000837 0706
020101 - Dr. Alice (Ellie) Guardino, MD, PHD O-00000837 0706
020102 - Assistant Professor Brest Oncology
020104 - Department of Medicine
020105 - Cancer Center O-00000837 0706
0202 - University of California San Franci O-00000835 0703
020201 - Dr. Christopher C. Benz, MD O-00000835 0703
020202 - Professor of Oncology
020203 - Medical Oncology Department O-00000835 0703
020204 - Mr. FirstName O-00000835 0703
SUBJECTS
Report to Doctor Guardino on Millie's Progress Implementing 2nd Opin
2nd Opinion Received Stanford Assessment and Plan Diagnosis Patient
1204 -
1204 - ..
1205 - Summary/Objective
1206 -
120601 - Follow up ref SDS 11 0000.
120602 -
120603 - Notified Doctor Guardino about favorable results implementing second
120604 - opinion recommendations on surgery. ref SDS 0 3H5X Cite Peggy's good
120605 - fortune under the doctor's care. ref SDS 0 3A3P Notified Doctor Benz
120606 - of Millie's strong recovery following recommendations in the doctor's
120607 - second opinion, ref SDS 0 G36K, including referrals to surgical
120608 - specialists. ref SDS 0 GN4P
120609 -
120610 - [On 051109 letter to Doctor's Bailey, Grissom, and Shim commending
120611 - contributions in recent 2nd opinions that guided Millie's
120612 - treatment, and notifying of favorable results. ref SDS 14 QG6H
120613 -
120614 -
120615 -
120616 -
120617 -
120619 - ..
1207 -
1208 -
1209 - Progress
1210 -
121001 - Commend Doctor Guardino at Stanford Cancer Center for Good Advice
121002 -
121003 - On 051008 Peggy called and we learned that she is being treated for
121004 - breast cancer by Doctor Guardino at Stanford, ref SDS 11 KS7G, who had
121005 - previously filed a 2nd opinion in Millie's case, received on 051209.
121006 - ref SDS 4 0001 The doctor's 2nd opinion work product for consultation
121007 - on 041019, ref SDS 2 0001, later led in part to Millie considering
121008 - mastectomy surgery on 051021. ref SDS 12 526H The purpose of this
121009 - letter is to commend the doctor on results of her work helping Millie,
121010 - and to express confidence that Peggy will get high quality treatment.
121012 - ..
121013 - Since Stanford does not support working intelligently, had to send a
121014 - conventional letter through the US Post Office system.
121016 - ..
121017 - Submitted ref DIT 1 0001 to the doctor saying...
121018 -
121019 - 1. We have been planning to report Millie's progress, but relapse
121020 - and treatment have delayed response. A few weeks ago, we were
121021 - saddened hearing that our very close friend has breast disease.
121022 - Millie and Peggy met in the 1970s, when both were promoted to
121023 - account executives for major textile manufacturers, and so
121024 - became pioneers charting a new career path for women. With
121025 - this long and special bond, we are heartened that you have the
121026 - lead managing Peggy's care. ref SDS 11 KS8H, and were very
121027 - pleased to assure her on your commitment to excellence.
121029 - ..
121030 - Doctor Guardino's commitment to excellence is demonstrated by
121031 - insisting her assistant verify accuracy of even inconsequential data,
121032 - reported on 041019. ref SDS 2 BV92 The doctor took the time to
121033 - examine original test materials, which was not done at UCSF.
121034 - ref SDS 2 ER8O Additionally, the doctor's 2nd opinion received on
121035 - 041209 was well written, and had very few errors. ref SDS 4 0001
121037 - ..
121038 - Letter to the doctor continues...
121039 -
121040 - 2. Millie has good news. On October 27th, the doctor advised
121041 - that, following mastectomy surgery, testing shows Millie is
121042 - disease-free. ref SDS 13 M58G This seems quite a miracle, and
121043 - Millie appreciates that disease may recur. For the time being,
121044 - we are grateful she is off treatment and recovering well. In
121045 - sum, Millie's Kaiser team synthesized your recommendations for
121046 - surgery, with ideas from Doctor Benz at UCSF on systemic
121047 - treatment. Scope of surgery was guided by recent second
121048 - opinions from Doctors Grissom and Bailey. Treating stage IV
121049 - and secondary IBC with surgery, when there is no evidence of
121050 - disease, suggests Millie may provide yet another example for
121051 - helping others. ref DIT 1 NO6O Many lessons learned emerge
121052 - from Mil's patient history. ref SDS 8 6L4M
121054 - ..
121055 - 3. Again, it was a great pleasure working with Stanford Medical
121056 - Center, and thanks very much for outstanding work product in
121057 - your second opinion. Peggy is fortunate to be in good hands.
121058 - ref DIT 1 NO81
121059 -
121060 -
121061 -
121062 -
1211 -
SUBJECTS
Report to Doctor Benz at UCSF on Millie's Progress Implementing 2nd
2403 -
240401 - ..
240402 - Commend Doctor Benz at Stanford Cancer Center for Good Advice
240403 -
240404 - On 041117 Doctor Benz recommend there is no role for surgery to treat
240405 - Millie. ref SDS 3 OU5P On 050729 primary care physcian recommended
240406 - immediate surgery. ref SDS 7 BZ56 On 050819 Doctor Benz was asked for
240407 - a 2nd opinion on surgery, in light the prior opinion that surgery is
240408 - not a good solution for Millie. ref SDS 9 PB4O On 050823 UCSF
240409 - responded that Doctor Benz refused comment, and made referral to
240410 - Doctors Grissom and Bailey. ref SDS 10 AI8N
240412 - ..
240413 - Submitted ref DIT 2 0001 to Doctor Benz via email to Sheridan Tinker,
240414 - with copy to Margaret Rubino, following up Margaret's letter on
240415 - 050823. ref SDS 10 AI8N
240417 - ..
240418 - The letter to Doctor Benz says...
240419 -
240420 - 1. On July 27th, Millie's primary care physician recommended
240421 - mastectomy following favorable response to treatment with
240422 - Taxotere and capecitabine, which you had recommended late last
240423 - year. Since testing showed no evidence of continuning disease,
240424 - due diligence required asking for follow up comment, based on
240425 - your opinion stating there is no role for surgery in her case.
240426 - UCSF reported on August 23rd that you made referral to Doctors
240427 - Grissom and Bailey for surgical expertise. ref DIT 2 0L5N
240429 - ..
240430 - 2. Millie got excellent support from Grissom and Bailey, relying
240431 - in part on your prior opinion, ref DIT 2 H66M, and leading to
240432 - surgery on October 21, that implemented proposals for an
240433 - innovative solution. ref SDS 12 MP8K
240435 - ..
240436 - 3. Good news - on October 27th, Kaiser advised that testing shows
240437 - Millie is disease-free. ref SDS 13 0001 Today, we learned that
240438 - her CA 15-3 cancer marker has suddenly and dramatically dropped
240439 - to 34, down from 45 the past three (3) months; 34 is by far the
240440 - lowest level in Millie's four (4) year ordeal. This seems
240441 - quite a miracle! ref DIT 2 NO6O Millie appreciates that
240442 - disease may recur; but, for now, we are greatful she is off
240443 - treatment and recovering well. In sum, recovery was
240444 - accomplished by implementing your ideas on systemic treatment,
240445 - (beginning on 050329, ref SDS 5 T58M], and when testing
240446 - eventually showed no evidence of disease, Kaiser proposed
240447 - surgery. [on 050610, ref SDS 6 XQ41] Treating a stage IV
240448 - patient for secondary IBC with surgery, when there is no
240449 - evidence of disease, suggests Millie may provide lessons
240450 - learned from patient history. ref SDS 13 XA5N
240452 - ..
240453 - 4. Congratulations for playing a pivitol role in Millie's
240454 - recovery. You and UCSF deserve a well done for quality advice
240455 - on treatment and referrals, demonstrating personal and
240456 - organizational integrated management. ref DIT 2 H683
240458 - ..
240459 - 5. If time permits, please comment on biopsy of surgical tissue
240460 - finding DCIS [reported on 051027, ref SDS 13 615K, and in
240461 - relation to Kaiser's report of disease-free status. ref DIT 2
240462 - PPVS
240463 -
240464 -
240465 -
240466 -
240467 -
240468 -
240469 -
240470 -
240471 -
240472 -
240473 -
240474 -
240475 -
240476 -
240477 -
240478 -
240479 -
240480 -
240481 -
240482 -
2405 -
Distribution. . . . See "CONTACTS"