THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700


S U M M A R Y


DIARY: July 13, 1995 01:54 PM Thursday; Rod Welch

Received resume from Rick Talley to Focus Group speaker for PMI event.

1...Summary/Objective
2...Cost
3...How Does Focus Group Support Project Management
4...Cost
5...He has a fee schedule as follows:
6...Initial Consideration of Ed's Presentation
.....Run Over on the Information Highway

ACTION ITEMS.................. Click here to comment!

1...I need to submit information to Rick to explain our program and get

CONTACTS 
0201 - Talley Research                    415 389 9945 fax 383 2156.
020101 - Mr. Rick Talley
0202 - Center Prof Dev & Training         602 970 0101 fax 423 0526
020201 - Mr. Edward E. Scannel, C.S.P., C.M.P.; President

SUBJECTS
PMI Event Program, 1996, Speakers
Nov Event, Speakers, Date, initial target
Dates of Events

0805 -    ..
0806 - Summary/Objective
0807 -
080701 - Followed up work at ref SDS 4 line 62, at ref SDS 1 line 17, and work
080702 - at ref SDS 2 line 682 to get speakers for Nov event.
080703 -
080704 - Want speaker on focus group methodology for Nov event, as well as
080705 - planning theater, per ref SDS 3 line 65, ref SDS 2 line 639.
080706 -
080707 -
080708 -
080709 -
0808 -
0809 -
0810 - Progress re Rick Talley        Talley Research  415 389 9945
0811 -
081101 - Received ref DRT 2 line 30, per ref SDS 4 line 76.  This is just a
081102 - resume of Talley's services and clients.  There was no cover letter,
081103 - so I created something for the record.
081104 -
081105 -
081106 - Cost
081107 -
081108 - Talley does not submit a request for payment, so maybe he will speak
081109 - for the opportunity to reach the audience.
081110 -
081111 -
081112 - How Does Focus Group Support Project Management
081113 -
081114 - The resume indicates Talley has no work for project managment
081115 - situations, ref DRT 2 line 81.  Talley's list of "Catagory Experience"
081116 - seems to center on evaluating market pototential for products and
081117 - services, as expected for a Market Research firm.
081118 -
081119 -     This question is important to the Focus Group speaker because he
081120 -     wants to appeal to attendees as prospective clients.
081121 -
081122 - Since we are planning to advance Focus Group as a communication method
081123 - of value to PMI membership and since PMI membership are interested in
081124 - managing projects, the question arises about how Focus Group
081125 - methodology would support managing projects?
081126 -
081127 - My experinece with Focus Group, however, which dealt with political
081128 - issues, indicates this method can be used to perform group analysis
081129 - on any subject.
081130 -
081131 - Should get Talley to suggest an application.
081132 -
081133 -     One might be to develope procedures for managing a project such as
081134 -     "Communication Management," paper flows.  The people who have to
081135 -     accomplish the "system" and those who will receive documents could
081136 -     be in a focus group in order to get requirements, suggestions,
081137 -     since often people have knowledge they are not aware of, or how it
081138 -     fits in relations to the needs and expections of others.
081139 -
081140 -     Another would be to assess prospects of implementing procedures
081141 -     that have been developed, including the introduction of new
081142 -     technology, such as a software program, e-mail.
081143 -
081144 -     Perhaps in designing an improvement of an existing facility such
081145 -     as a hospital, we would want to gather reaction from people who
081146 -     will be using the facility such as doctors, nurses, custodians,
081147 -     administrators, and so on.  This would work to gather information
081148 -     to create a design, and to evaluate the adequacy of a design in
081149 -     progress.
081150 -
081151 -     We might do a focus group on bidding procedures that have special
081152 -     problems, such as on a very unique project.  Contractors could be
081153 -     brought in to assess how they would react to terms under
081154 -     consideration.
081155 -
081156 -         Usually the level of investiation is someone will call a few
081157 -         contractors and ask some questions, as occurred on the Pier
081158 -         10 project.  Better control through Focus Group might yield
081159 -         better bid documents, tighter bids and fewer claims.
081160 -
081161 -
081162 - I need to submit information to Rick to explain our program and get
081163 - his input on scope.
081164 -
081165 -     My initial view is that he comes in near the end of the first
081166 -     half day, is introduced and explains the process, and situations
081167 -     where it can be applied (per above).
081168 -
081169 -     In the afternoon, he will conduct one of the Focus Groups,
081170 -     hopefully 1 of 3 of about 10 folks.
081171 -
081172 -
081173 -
0812 -
0813 -
0814 - Center for Professional Development  - Ed Scannell
0815 -
081501 - Received ref DRT 1 line 20 from Ed Scannell, per our discussion at ref
081502 - SDS 5 line 61.
081503 -
081504 - Ed confirms he can speak on 951111, which is the weekend prior to
081505 - 951118, when we initially set for the event.
081506 -
081507 - Ed has impressive credentials, reflecting my impression of his work
081508 - at PMA event in Arizona.
081509 -
081510 - Cost
081511 -
081512 - He has a fee schedule as follows:
081513 -
081514 -                      1 hour       $2,500
081515 -                      Half day     $3,500
081516 -                      Full day     $5,000
081517 -
081518 - We would like to use Ed for half a day, but it will require planning
081519 - to see how he fits with other presenters, e.g., Planning Theater,
081520 - Focus Group, Human memory, Partnering
081521 -
081522 - Can we get $3,500 for Ed to be there for half a day, and be a
081523 - combination entertainer, present the main body of explanation about
081524 - the history of communication, and bring us up to today.
081525 -
081526 -      The objective is to give people a chance to grasp why they hold
081527 -      certain views about the relation between time and information,
081528 -      i.e., what drives the desire to summarize.
081529 -
081530 -      Another option is to see if he could discount his fee for an
081531 -      entire day, or maybe we just use him for 2 hours instead of half
081532 -      a day.
081533 -
081534 -
081535 - Initial Consideration of Ed's Presentation
081536 -
081537 - Ed can set out major communication issues for the practice of
081538 - management, in particular "meetings," since he is past president of
081539 - Meeting Professional International, ref DRT 1 line 48, and has written
081540 - books on communication, creativity, meeting planning, management and
081541 - team building.
081542 -
081543 -
081544 -     Run Over on the Information Highway
081545 -
081546 -     We would like to get from Ed that no amount of communication
081547 -     skill, creativity and meeting planning can result in a successful
081548 -     meeting, if people are going from meeting to meeting, innundated
081549 -     with documents and calls, i.e., receive too much information to
081550 -     understand, and follow up.
081551 -
081552 -     An example are inadequate notes, such as the prop from the Forum
081553 -     meetings, ref SDS 3 line 92.
081554 -
081555 -     This could set up the focus and planning theater efforts for the
081556 -     afternoon program.
081557 -
081558 -         One solution in a meeting of 10 or 30 people, the leader
081559 -         should call on someone at random to summarize the meeting,
081560 -         and assign that person to do the SDS meeting notes.
081561 -
081562 -         The problem with this is that often people attend who have an
081563 -         interest and responsibility for only a few of perhaps 20 - 50
081564 -         issues.  That person should be not liable to grasp the whole
081565 -         thing.  For external projects one might not want someone else
081566 -         to control the content of the record, except possibly in a
081567 -         partnering situation, and even then it coule be irresponsible
081568 -         to permit someone else to control the record.  For internal
081569 -         projects, this might work better.
081570 -
081571 -         Somehow we need a way to ensure people are paying attention
081572 -         and there is common understanding, and then to follow up, and
081573 -         second, we need to share the burden of writing the SDS record.
081574 -
081575 -         If we share the burden, this means doing the initial dialog
081576 -         and connecting up.  Once it is available, each attendee can
081577 -         still integrate the record into their own SDS data base and
081578 -         supplement it, so we are not stuck with someone else's view.
081579 -         It is only a resource.
081580 -
081581 -
081582 - To succeed faster by understanding better, sometimes we have to slow
081583 - down.  So, we can actually speed up by slowing down.
081584 -
081585 -     The purpose of Ed's presentation is to bring out the need for
081586 -     greater care in analysis needed to overcome misunderstanding and
081587 -     to dig out of the system nuance and implications that otherwise
081588 -     lead to failure, Murphy's Law.
081589 -
081590 -     Explain purpose of Writing and what it accomplishes with respect
081591 -     to thinking, remembering and communicating.  This is something we
081592 -     think about because we learn writing at age 6 and the goal is not
081593 -     to explain why we are learning, but merely to teach it, since the
081594 -     culture has long established the why, i.e., it works!
081595 -
081596 -         Show how writing is a tool of analysis since it requires
081597 -         assemplying symbols in alternate ways to form larger thoughts,
081598 -         ideas, concepts, decisions, leading to action.
081599 -
081600 -         So we are molding, crafting, acquiring understanding, by
081601 -         building, associating, comparing "stuff."
081602 -
081603 -         The better we can manipulate these components, the better
081604 -         chance we have of not deviating from the truth, and so being
081605 -         successful.
081606 -
081607 -     The "why" of writing only arises every 5,000 years or so when we
081608 -     decide to improve on writing as a basic skill.  Wordprocessing
081609 -     merely lets us write better.  But if we want to improve things
081610 -     writing accomplishes, we have to think at a lower level to
081611 -     identify what we are doing in writing a sentence, paragraph,
081612 -     paper, ...
081613 -
081614 -
081615 -
081616 - We might reserve the last hour before lunch to introduce 3 focus
081617 - group leaders, and 3 planning theater leaders.
081618 -
081619 - What about partnering?
081620 -
081621 -     Maybe we should leave this for
081622 -
081623 -
0817 -
Distribution. . . . See "CONTACTS"