THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700


S U M M A R Y


DIARY: February 22, 2000 11:04 AM Tuesday; Rod Welch

Colloquium develops Reference management.

1...Summary/Objective
2...Reference Materials Inventories Documents and Sources
3...Ontology Organizes Information for Efficient Use


..............
Click here to comment!

CONTACTS 

SUBJECTS
Reference Materials
Document Management
Email, Hyperdocuments
META NIC Strategy
Condensing
Organizing
Preserve Contributors
Record Evaluations

1410 -    ..
1411 - Summary/Objective
1412 -
141201 - Follow up ref SDS 34 0000, ref SDS 33 0000.
141202 -
141203 - Frode Hegland suggests using a system to organize reference materials
141204 - in a way that facilitates selecting material based on level of detail
141205 - and expertise.  Eric Armstrong concurs with a letter from Jack Park
141206 - suggesting two lists of references.  One list is for implementation,
141207 - and the other is for content.
141208 -
141209 -
141210 -
141211 -
1413 -
1414 -
1415 - Progress
1416 -
141601 -  ..
141602 - Reference Materials Inventories Documents and Sources
141603 -
141604 - Follow up ref SDS 33 8044.
141605 -
141606 - Received ref DRT 1 0001 from Frode Hegland thanking Eric Armstrong for
141607 - a great job managing reference material being used by the Colloquium,
141608 - reported on 000220. ref SDS 33 8044
141609 -
141610 -     [On 000223 Frode submits further ideas. ref SDS 35 4892]
141611 -
141612 - Frode asks about top level distilations to may help people get some
141613 - parts of this quickly?
141614 -
141615 - Frode cites talk of registering www.unrev2.org and creating an
141616 - overview/list of links there to answer basic questions and point
141617 - people in the right direction, and asks if Colloquium contributors
141618 - should try to cordinate such an effort? Would it be worthwhile?
141619 - ref DRT 1 9108
141620 - ..
141621 - This actually sounds related to the discussion below about
141622 - ontology. ref SDS 0 8044
141623 -
141624 -
141625 -
141626 -
141627 -
1417 -

SUBJECTS
Ontology Organize Structure
Organic Subject Structure
Oranic Subject Structure
Organization Method
Subject Indexing, General
Organic Subject Structure, MBO
Pandora's Box, Information Highway
Subject Indexing is Complex, Others Have Failed

2711 -
271101 -  ..
271102 - Ontology Organizes Information for Efficient Use
271103 -
271104 - Follow up ref SDS 34 8044, ref SDS 33 8044.
271105 -
271106 - Received from Eric Armstrong, ref DRT 2 0001, commenting on a letter
271107 - from Jack Park which is not included in the record, but which proposes
271108 - that the topics of...
271109 -
271110 -          mathematics of knowledge
271111 -
271112 -          methods of learning/teaching
271113 -
271114 -      ...are so important that a second list for such explorations
271115 -      might be started, and leave this or another list to the
271116 -      nitty-gritty of implementation issues. ref DRT 2 3312
271117 - ..
271118 - Eric initially concurs that two lists are needed, at a minimum.
271119 - One is a...
271120 -
271121 -                       content" list
271122 -
271123 -
271124 - ...where issues like those above are discussed. The other is an...
271125 -
271126 -
271127 -                       implementation" list
271128 -
271129 -
271130 - ...where possible designs and methodologies are discussed. ref DRT 2
271131 - 2562
271132 - ..
271133 - Eric further comments...
271134 -      ..
271135 -      Implementation issues are deep and long. Those discussions
271136 -      will choke off content discussions. But it is the content
271137 -      discussions that provide motivation and delineate the purpose(s)
271138 -      that direct the design work. ref DRT 2 7920
271139 -
271140 -      Content discussions tend to be widely diverse and far ranging.
271141 -      Those discussions will put off the folks who want to narrow their
271142 -      focus, dig in, and get something built. Without those discussions
271143 -      and the work that results from them, the content discussions will
271144 -      remain so many breezes in the air, with no concrete results.
271145 -      ref DRT 2 3468
271146 -
271147 -      The goals of the two discussions are so diverse, the discussions
271148 -      themselves so mutually antipathetic to many important
271149 -      contributors, and the sheer volume of each so large, that two
271150 -      lists strikes me as an absolute necessity. ref DRT 2 9630
271151 - ..
271152 - Implementation is meant to support content, so it cannot be
271153 - completely choked off from the crazy, diverse world of content,
271154 - otherwise it will produce something primarily aimed at building
271155 - itself.
271156 -
271157 -
271158 -
271159 -
271160 -
271161 -
271162 -
271163 -
271164 -