THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700


S U M M A R Y


DIARY: November 11, 1999 08:01 AM Thursday; Rod Welch

Patty plans to try Carbon Blanket cancer treatment for Bob.

1...Summary/Objective
2...Patty Recommends Trying Carbon Blanket as Case Study
3...IMP Can Submit Carbon Blanket for Case Study Trial
4...Bob Objects to Further Tests and Treatments
5...Doctor Fogelberg Encourages Investigation of Alternate Treatments
6...Case Studies Require Controlled Application Based on Information


..............
Click here to comment!

CONTACTS 

SUBJECTS
Kathleen and Bob

0403 -    ..
0404 - Summary/Objective
0405 -
040501 - Follow up ref SDS 30 0000, ref SDS 28 0000.
040502 -
040503 - Patty wants to try the carbon blanket cancer treatment as a case study
040504 - to discover a new cure.  Bob has been objecting to new treatments, but
040505 - may respond favorably to Patty's efforts. Case studies require minimum
040506 - information to develop valid data that can be useful to others, and
040507 - also ensure harm will not result to the patient.  The vendor was
040508 - notified on 991110 to submit information on using the Carbon Blanket
040509 - in a trial.  The vendor has not submitted information and has not
040510 - proposed a case study.
040511 -
040512 - Sent letter to Patty, ref DIT 1 0001, suggesting she propose the case
040513 - study idea to her Dad, may need to have review by Doctor Fogelberg.
040514 -
040515 - Asked her consider coming up on Saturday or Sunday and to attend the
040516 - meetings on 991117, ref DIT 1 4455, per planning. ref SDS 31 5933
040517 -
040518 -    [On 991112 Patty cannot attend the meetings. ref SDS 32 0899]
040519 -
040520 -
040521 -
040522 -  ..
0406 -
0407 -
0408 - Progress
0409 -
040901 - Patty Recommends Trying Carbon Blanket as Case Study
040902 -
040903 - Received ref DRT 1 0001 from Patty responding to my letter last night,
040904 - ref DIP 4 0001, explaining the next step in assessing a trial of IMP's
040905 - carbon blanket cancer treatment is to see substantial information
040906 - explaining theory, product spec, application plan, as shown in the
040907 - record on 991110. ref SDS 30 0001
040908 -
040909 - Patty says...
040910 -
040911 -     I'm having a hard time.  I'm thinking that you are trying to make
040912 -     sure that this is not a scam by following proffesional protocal.
040913 -     Are you thinking if there is no written doc's to support Mr.
040914 -     Johnsons claim then it must be a scam?  Mr. Johnson is not the one
040915 -     selling anything. And, my thinking is not "Anything to save my
040916 -     Dad" so to speak, but the larger picture of if there is a cheap,
040917 -     simple, painfree way to "cure" cancer and somebody is working on
040918 -     that, think of all the lives this could save in the future.
040919 -     ref DRT 1 1258
040920 - ..
040921 - Patty suggests her Dad could be a case study to support IMP's
040922 - carbon blanket theory...
040923 -
040924 -     My Dad's case could dissprove Mr. Johnson's theory, but could also
040925 -     support it.  What Mr. Johnson needs is case studies to help
040926 -     support his findings. This whole decision would be made by my Dad,
040927 -     but I WILL be trying to talk him into it. ref DRT 1 1599
040928 -
040929 - Patty noted in her letter on 991109 that substantial information is
040930 - needed to support inquiry about IMP's product.
040931 -
040932 -     [On 991112 Patty plans to present this initiative on Thanksgiving.
040933 -     ref SDS 32 0899]
040934 -
040935 -     [On 991113 Bob's condition worsens, Patty suggest this idea to
040936 -     Kathleen. ref SDS 33 2166]
040937 -
040938 - This begins with a statement of Johnson's "findings."
040939 -
040940 - IMP should submit proposed "findings" that a case study would prove or
040941 - disprove?
040942 -
040943 -
040944 -
040945 - IMP Can Submit Carbon Blanket for Case Study Trial
040946 -
040947 - Review on 991109 proposed that IMP submit information to support a
040948 - case study trial, since a "blanket" does not sound like it could cause
040949 - harm, stating...
040950 -
040951 -     Anything to relieve Bob's pain and possibly effect a cure seems
040952 -     inviting.  Possibly vendor might allow Bob to test the use of his
040953 -     product under a marketing scenario to develop evidence of clinical
040954 -     improvement. ref SDS 28 0001
040955 -
040956 -
040957 -
040958 - Bob Objects to Further Tests and Treatments
040959 - Doctor Fogelberg Encourages Investigation of Alternate Treatments
040960 -
040961 - Patty's plan to talk her Dad into trying the Carbon Blanket treatment
040962 - is supported by Doctor Fogelberg, who encourages patients to try
040963 - treatments they believe can help, or wish to investigate. ref SDS 29
040964 - 1023
040965 -
040966 - Patty says...
040967 -
040968 -     My strong feelings are coming from a conversation that my Dad and
040969 -     I had the day after his surgery.  He was very upset and said, "All
040970 -     the millions of dollars that are spent on Cancer Research and
040971 -     there is no cure for it"
040972 -
040973 -     Another time he said "All the things I've done in my life and it's
040974 -     the big "C" that gets me..." ref DRT 1 2340
040975 -
040976 -     I am not so much in denial about my Dad's condition of facing his
040977 -     death, but I am looking at the fact that he could support a theory
040978 -     which may help the rest of the human race. ref DRT 1 4482
040979 -
040980 - Patty might consider calling her Dad about this, keeping in mind the
040981 - caution about avoiding emotional issues from work on 991102.
040982 - ref SDS 17 0990
040983 -
040984 - Kathleen reported this morning that Bob is objecting to further tests
040985 - and treatment. ref SDS 31 5328
040986 -
040987 - Explaining the Carbon Blanket treatment may of itself be therapeutic
040988 - simply because Patty has taken the initiative and feels strongly about
040989 - following up based on discussions with her Dad.  This may help the
040990 - hospital staff work with Bob on the Doctor Fogelberg's ideas also.
040991 -
040992 -
040993 -
040994 - Case Studies Require Controlled Application Based on Information
040995 -
040996 - Patty's plan and motivation to try new ideas should be implemented,
040997 - based on minimum support information from IMP.
040998 -
040999 - To do a trial, or case study, with the carbon blanket treatment, we
041000 - need information on application, theory, product spec, as shown in the
041001 - record on 991110. ref SDS 30 0001
041002 -
041003 - The attending physician needs to review the application to ensure the
041004 - trial will not cause harm.  If professional opinion recognizes
041005 - potential risk this needs to be properly managed, to avoid harming Bob
041006 - and also to avoid exposure to charges of criminal negligence by the
041007 - family.
041008 -
041009 - IMP can submit information and a proposal to support a case study, but
041010 - has not done so.
041011 -
041012 -
041013 -
041014 -
041015 -
041016 -
041017 -
041018 -