THE WELCH COMPANY
440 Davis Court #1602
San Francisco, CA 94111-2496
415 781 5700
rodwelch@pacbell.net


S U M M A R Y


DIARY: December 8, 2004 07:40 AM Wednesday; Rod Welch

Murray Altheim requests feedback on Ceryle with survey.

1...Summary/Objective
2...Topic Maps Aid Writing by Organizing Information from Research
3...Writer's Survey for Ceryle Evaluation

ACTION ITEMS.................. Click here to comment!

1...This presents an opportunity for Gary to engage Murray, who is working

CONTACTS 

SUBJECTS
Ceryle Topic Map System Organize Postit Notes Biblography to Aid Wri
Ontology Knowledge Organization Representation Subjects Catagories T
Conceptual Graphs Method of Knowledge Representation, Joslyn, Semiot
KM EEPC Subcouncil CAC Woody Follow Up with Marv on Steps SDS ASB Co
Ceryle Project Topic Maps Organize Information Gary Submit Form on C
Ceryle Released for Evalution Murray Submits a Survey
Survey Engage Customers Evaluate Needs for SDS Com Metrics
Com Metrics Welchco Website CGI Services Can be Upgraded by Contacti
Ceryle Survey Illustrates Questions to Engage Customers Topic Map Sy

1211 -
1211 -    ..
1212 - Summary/Objective
1213 -
121301 - Follow up ref SDS 9 0000.
121302 -
121303 - Murray's Ceryle project sounds like helpful method to organize
121304 - research.  It presents an opportunity to place the ASB on SDS in an
121305 - acedemic setting without references to Gary's company, and illustrates
121306 - a good use of survey for marketing.
121308 -  ..
121309 - Submitted this record to Gary via email for consideration of
121310 - contacting Murray.
121311 -
121312 -
121313 -
121315 -  ..
1214 -
1215 -
1216 - Progress
1217 -
121701 - Topic Maps Aid Writing by Organizing Information from Research
121702 -
121703 - Murray Altheim is developing information management for the Ceryle
121704 - project.....
121705 -
121706 -        http://www.altheim.com/ceryle/
121707 -
121708 - ...which he describes...
121709 -
121710 -        Ceryle is a free tool to help you get organized. If you use a
121711 -        lot of post it notes, are a writer, journalist, researcher,
121712 -        student, or anyone compiling a lot of information for a
121713 -        project, maybe just trying to organize your recipes,
121714 -        bookmarks, or your MP3 collection, Ceryle is designed to
121715 -        assist you in keeping track of things.  Ceryle includes
121716 -        features to help you store, find and even visualize your
121717 -        information, using what is called a graph visualization. Those
121718 -        same graphs also enable you to create structures for your
121719 -        documents, see relationships between ideas, and even generate
121720 -        composite documents based on those structures, like building a
121721 -        book from its chapters or a screenplay from its scenes.
121723 -  ..
121724 - Ceryle could help solve the problem of complexity Jack Park cited in a
121725 - letter on 000221. ref SDS 4 3248  Organizing research helps learning,
121726 - which Jack and others are developing for the CALO project at SRI,
121727 - reviewed on 040221. ref SDS 10 5U6J
121729 -  ..
121730 - Cyrle support for organization sounds similar to work on the OHS/DKR
121731 - project...
121732 -
121733 -        Traction tracks
121734 -        categories.................... 011102, ref SDS 7 916Q
121736 -         ..
121737 -        Topic Maps.................... 000623, ref SDS 5 2915
121739 -         ..
121740 -        Dialog Maps................... 010916, ref SDS 6 S44G
121742 -  ..
121743 - The record on 010916 has more background on tools to organize the
121744 - record. ref SDS 6 UW5L
121746 -  ..
121747 - Murray provided helpful feedback on SDS in a letter received on
121748 - 020820. ref SDS 9 UV6G  At that time, Murray was discouraged about
121749 - using technology to augment intelligence, because he had developed a
121750 - system for linking that required more than 10 seconds, but found he
121751 - did not use it, ref SDS 9 LI3J, and so was reluctant to pilot test SDS
121752 - support for linking in less than 10 seconds. ref SDS 9 6P8K
121754 -  ..
121755 - Today, Murray requests feedback with a survey to evaluate Ceryle by
121756 - pilot testing for organizing notes that aid writing. ref SDS 0 1R7G
121757 - The Ceryle survey illustrates how to use survey material for
121758 - marketing, exposure, and engage people to consider needs people care
121759 - about, reviewed recently on 040428. ref SDS 11 0001
121761 -  ..
121762 - Getting more people making progress illustrated by Cyerle will help
121763 - overcome denial that prevents progress toward a culture of knowledge.
121765 -  ..
121766 - This presents an opportunity for Gary to engage Murray, who is working
121767 - on an academic project, in a circle of advocates based on the ASB for
121768 - SDS, per planning in Gary's letter on 041118. ref SDS 15 KT51  This
121769 - could provide exposure to SDS in education.
121771 -  ..
121772 - Gary could submit a letter to Murray saying...
121773 -
121774 -    1.  Murray,
121775 -
121776 -        I've completed your survey listed in Eugene Kim's website...
121777 -
121778 -            http://collab.blueoxen.net/forums/yak/2004-12/msg00018.html
121779 -
121780 -        ...and would love to try Ceryle, if I meet your qualifications.
121781 -        ref SDS 0 1R7G
121782 -
121783 -            Gary can put this survey in his record and publish it under
121784 -            Dynamic..., and then link to it.
121786 -         ..
121787 -    2.  I am using SDS at B***** based on the attached "In Use Proejct
121788 -        Bulletin," and would be pleased to hear how you feel Ceryle
121789 -        might strengthen SDS support for organic structure to reduce
121790 -        the time for finding critical details in organizational memory,
121791 -        based on situational awareness, as shown in the NWO.
121792 -        ref OF 15 08XX  Since you are in the UK, possibly we could do
121793 -        an online demo to get a feel for using Ceryle to construct an
121794 -        organization.
121796 -  ..
121797 - Gary need merely cut and paste the following into his own SDS record,
121798 - then adjust a few of the responses, e.g., he is an engineer,
121799 - ref SDS 0 PJ8S, and uses Microsoft Word. ref SDS 0 PJ9Y
121800 -
121801 -
121802 -
121804 -  ..
121805 - Writer's Survey for Ceryle Evaluation
121806 -
121807 - Murray has developed the following questions...
121808 -
121809 -            http://www.altheim.com/ceryle/eval/writer_survey.txt
121811 -         ..
121812 -    1.  Writer's Survey : Part One of the Ceryle Evaluation
121814 -         ..
121815 -    2.  Thanks for taking part in this Writer's Survey, which is being
121816 -        conducted as part of ongoing academic research towards a
121817 -        doctoral degree at the Knowledge Media Institute of the Open
121818 -        University.
121820 -         ..
121821 -    3.  It is intended to better understand your writing habits, and
121822 -        solicit input in designing a tool to better serve your needs as
121823 -        a researcher and writer. The tool is called Ceryle and will be
121824 -        released as open source (free) software. This is your chance to
121825 -        influence the design of a writer's tool that will be available
121826 -        to you to use for free. By participating in this survey, you
121827 -        will not only be able to obtain an early copy of Ceryle, but
121828 -        assistance in installing it and getting up and running (though
121829 -        please note that this will be limited to some extent by time
121830 -        available).
121832 -         ..
121833 -    4.  The data gathered during this survey will never be used in a
121834 -        way that identifies you by name, and you are encouraged to be
121835 -        completely open about your experience. You will be asked some
121836 -        questions about yourself; these questions are designed to
121837 -        better understand how people react to using Ceryle based on
121838 -        their background.
121840 -         ..
121841 -    5.  This survey is also available as a Word document or Web page,
121842 -        and can be found at:
121843 -
121844 -           http://purl.org/ceryle/eval/
121846 -         ..
121847 -    6.  Let's begin...
121848 -
121849 -           1. Name:  Rod Welch
121850 -
121851 -           2. Age:   60
121853 -               ..
121854 -           3. Gender:
121855 -
121856 -              x Male
121857 -              _ Female
121859 -               ..
121860 -           4. Please state your educational level:
121861 -
121862 -              x secondary school
121863 -              _ some college or university
121864 -              _ university degree
121865 -              _ master's degree
121866 -              _ doctoral degree
121868 -               ..
121869 -           5. What kind of work do you do? I.e., your current job, work
121870 -              or career.
121872 -               ..
121873 -              Develop and market SDS for intelligence support, as set
121874 -              out in NWO. ref OF 15 JU8O
121876 -               ..
121877 -           6. Which type of computer operating system do you use?
121878 -              Windows? Macintosh? Linux? or other?
121880 -               ..
121881 -              Windows
121883 -               ..
121884 -           7. At what level do you consider your computer skills (for
121885 -              the purposes you use computers)? Beginner, intermediate,
121886 -              or expert?
121888 -               ..
121889 -              Expert.
121891 -               ..
121892 -           8. Do you find your work area covered with post-it notes and
121893 -              small slips of paper? Do you tend to organize your paper
121894 -              notes in some manner? If so, how?
121896 -               ..
121897 -              Notes are organized with SDS using a paperless office
121898 -              model, explained in NWO, ref OF 16 4356, based on the
121899 -              organic structure of context and alignment with prior
121900 -              work, as explained in NWO. ref OF 15 QR6J
121902 -               ..
121903 -           9. What kind of equipment do you use for composition? Do you
121904 -              use a computer, a specialized electronic word processor,
121905 -              a typewriter, and/or pencil and paper? If more than one,
121906 -              at which stages of the process?
121908 -               ..
121909 -              SDS.
121911 -         ..
121912 -        If you do not use a computer during composition,
121913 -        skip to question 12.
121915 -               ..
121916 -          10. Which word processor software do you use?
121917 -
121918 -              None.
121920 -               ..
121921 -          11. Do you tend to write without regard to formatting on the
121922 -              page, saving that for the end of the process, or do you
121923 -              format as you go along?
121925 -               ..
121926 -              Generally format while constructing the record, often
121927 -              rearrange formatting.
121929 -               ..
121930 -          12. Do you think of yourself as a writer (or even an aspiring
121931 -              writer), or more as someone who writes now and then as
121932 -              part of work, school or for fun?
121934 -               ..
121935 -              Writer to plan, perform, and report daily work using a
121936 -              process of "thinking through writing," explained in
121937 -              POIMS. ref OF 10 3742
121939 -               ..
121940 -          13. What kinds of writing projects have you worked on, or are
121941 -              currently working on? (e.g., fiction, non-fiction,
121942 -              essays, research papers, magazine or newspaper articles,
121943 -              for the Web)
121945 -               ..
121946 -              Filling out this form using SDS for the eight (8) steps
121947 -              of Communication Metrics that augment intelligence is a
121948 -              writing project, as set out in POIMS. ref OF 9 685K
121949 -              Developing software is a "writing" project,"  illustrated
121950 -              by the work on 041107, ref SDS 14 0001, obtaining a 2nd
121951 -              opinion for a work plan to treat a cancer patient is a
121952 -              writing project illustrated by the record on 041019.
121953 -              ref SDS 13 0001 Reading is a writing project, illustrated
121954 -              by the record on 980307. ref SDS 3 0001  Other examples
121955 -              are listed on 950204 explaining SDS improves literacy for
121956 -              reading and writing. ref SDS 2 7499  Writing projects for
121957 -              daily tasks are listed on 020708. ref SDS 8 MZ6O
121959 -               ..
121960 -          14. Were they written for school? As part of your work?  Or
121961 -              for other reasons?
121963 -               ..
121964 -              Part of performing daily work, as set out POIMS.
121965 -              ref OF 8 T79J
121967 -               ..
121968 -          15. Have you ever been paid for a writing project? What kind
121969 -              of project(s)?
121971 -               ..
121972 -              Management projects.
121974 -               ..
121975 -          16. Do you do any research or prior planning for your writing
121976 -              projects? This includes any time spent writing a
121977 -              bibliography or keeping notes. If so, roughly what
121978 -              percentage of a project (time-wise) do you estimate you
121979 -              spend on research and planning?
121981 -               ..
121982 -              Planning and reporting are closely related, as set out in
121983 -              POIMS. ref OF 9 6649  This varies from 20% - 60% of the
121984 -              time.
121986 -               ..
121987 -              If you generally don't do any research or planning for
121988 -              your writing projects, skip to question 26.
121990 -               ..
121991 -          17. What kinds of research do you find yourself doing for
121992 -              your writing projects? Do you ever travel or conduct
121993 -              interviews for research purposes?
121995 -               ..
121996 -              Interviews and onsite inspection are critical elements of
121997 -              research.
121999 -               ..
122000 -          18. In your writing projects, do you normally keep track of
122001 -              references for the purposes of creating a bibliography?
122002 -              If so, do you use software for this purpose? If yes,
122003 -              which software?
122005 -               ..
122006 -              SDS tracks biblography.
122008 -               ..
122009 -          19. Do you use a file cabinet or notecard system to organize
122010 -              your paper-based notes?
122012 -               ..
122013 -              No.
122015 -               ..
122016 -          20. If you organize your notes, do you do so by subject? How?
122017 -
122018 -              SDS is used to organize knowledge based on the organic
122019 -              structure of context in relation to objectives,
122020 -              requirements and commitments, as set out in POIMS.
122021 -              ref OF 15 QR6J
122023 -               ..
122024 -          21. When planning the overall structure and/or the plot of a
122025 -              writing project, do you ever draw it out graphically, use
122026 -              notecards or any other means of laying out the
122027 -              organization to help visualize it? If so, please
122028 -              describe.
122030 -               ..
122031 -              Writing projects are based primarily on chronology,
122032 -              because time imparts the sequence of causation that aids
122033 -              reasoning.
122035 -               ..
122036 -              A method of graphical representation for some writing
122037 -              projects could complement traditional outlining supported
122038 -              by SDS, and illustrated by the outline for the scope of
122039 -              "intelligence" support. ref OF 15 LW5I
122041 -               ..
122042 -          22. Do you use a computer when doing research or when
122043 -              organizing a writing project?
122045 -               ..
122046 -              Yes.
122048 -         ..
122049 -        If no, skip to question 26.
122050 -
122051 -          23. Do you use the web to do research? In what way, briefly?
122052 -
122053 -              The Internet has sources, for example, to research the
122054 -              efficacy of cancer treatments, reviewed on 040517.
122055 -              ref SDS 12 6M9H
122057 -               ..
122058 -          24. Have you ever used a computer database to organize your
122059 -              work or keep track of details?
122061 -               ..
122062 -              Yes.
122064 -               ..
122065 -          25. Have you ever used project planning software to help with
122066 -              a writing project?
122068 -               ..
122069 -              Yes.
122071 -               ..
122072 -          26. Have you ever written non-fiction? If so, what type?
122073 -              (e.g., essay, magazine article, journal or technical
122074 -              paper, etc.)
122076 -               ..
122077 -              Magazine articles, technical papers, etc.
122079 -         ..
122080 -        If no, skip to question 28.
122081 -
122082 -          27. Are you commonly required to submit written work
122083 -              according to some specific formatting, such as for
122084 -              journal papers?
122085 -
122086 -              Yes.
122088 -               ..
122089 -          28. Have you ever written fiction? If so, what length? (e.g.,
122090 -              short stories, novellas, novels)
122092 -               ..
122093 -              Short stories, illustrated by the record on 940612.
122094 -              ref SDS 1 8239
122096 -         ..
122097 -        If no, skip to the end of the survey.
122099 -               ..
122100 -          29. In your fiction writing, within what genres have you
122101 -              written? (e.g., mystery, romance, crime or detective
122102 -              drama, adventure, science fiction, fantasy, etc.)
122104 -               ..
122105 -              Mystery, detective, fantasy.
122107 -               ..
122108 -          30. When planning your characters, do you create a detailed
122109 -              biography of their traits? Do you do any research into
122110 -              their backgrounds? If so, please describe.
122112 -               ..
122113 -              No.
122115 -               ..
122116 -          31. When planning the setting of your stories, what kinds of
122117 -              research do you normally do? How do you organize it?
122119 -               ..
122120 -              SDS organizes research based on context.
122122 -               ..
122123 -          32. Have you ever used any software designed specifically to
122124 -              assist in writing fiction (not including word processor
122125 -              software), such as story or plot planners?
122127 -               ..
122128 -              SDS supports writing fiction and non-fiction.
122130 -         ..
122131 -    7.  We're done.
122133 -         ..
122134 -    8.  Thanks very much for participating in this survey! Your input
122135 -        is greatly appreciated. You can send your completed survey via
122136 -        email, or print it out and mail or fax to the address below.
122138 -         ..
122139 -    9.  If you have any further comments, questions, or feedback, or
122140 -        wish to remain in touch with this project and your name is not
122141 -        already on the Ceryle mailing list, please contact the author:
122142 -
122143 -           Murray Altheim
122144 -           The Knowledge Media Institute, The Open University
122145 -           Milton Keynes MK7 6AA, United Kingdom
122146 -           Email:  m.altheim@open.ac.uk
122147 -           Fax:  +44 (0)1908 653169
122148 -           Revision 1 (2004-11-09)
122149 -
122150 -
122151 -
122152 -
122153 -
122154 -
122155 -
122156 -
1222 -